Windsor's Pollution Problem: A Critical Analysis

The air pollution in Windsor, Ontario, is a cause for concern, with the city's air quality being impacted by various sources, including local transportation, industrial activities, and power plants. The level of air pollution in Windsor has been found to exceed the national average for sulphur dioxide, a colourless and toxic gas, despite the city lacking any industrial sources that report emitting this pollutant. The city's proximity to heavily industrialised areas in the United States, such as Michigan, New York, and Ohio, contributes significantly to its air pollution. Local sources, such as vehicle emissions and power plants, also play a role in the city's air quality issues. The health impacts of air pollution in Windsor are significant, with annual costs estimated to exceed $1 billion in Ontario due to hospital admissions, emergency room visits, and absenteeism.

Windsor's air pollution is impacted by neighbouring US states

Windsor, Ontario, Canada, is located on the Canada-US border. The air pollution in Windsor is impacted by neighbouring US states, including New York, Ohio, and Michigan. These states are heavily industrialized, with major manufacturing hubs, power generation facilities, and automobile production plants. The industrial activities in these states release thousands of tonnes of air pollutants, including sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides (NOx), and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which can be carried by wind or weather patterns into Windsor.

For example, Wayne County in Michigan, known for its automotive industry, has over 180 industrial businesses that emit significant amounts of pollution each year. The Marathon refinery in Detroit, Michigan, has also been identified as a significant polluter, impacting Windsor's air quality.

The transboundary movement of air pollutants between the US and Canada has been studied, and it was found that a considerable percentage of air masses arriving in Windsor originate from the US. In a two-year study, it was observed that 53-55% of air masses over a 48-hour period and 81-82% over a 24-hour period came from the US. However, statistical analyses did not find consistent, significant correlations between the travel path of the air masses and the measured pollutant concentrations in Windsor.

Nevertheless, the impact of US industrial emissions on Windsor's air quality is significant enough that there are treaty obligations in place for both Canada and the US to adhere to air quality standards. Scientists from both countries are working together to evaluate the effects of their respective emissions. Additionally, local initiatives in Windsor, such as the purchase of hybrid electric buses, aim to reduce vehicle emissions and improve air quality.

The air pollution in Windsor has serious health and economic impacts. The Ontario Medical Association has published research highlighting the costs of air pollution, including hospital admissions, emergency room visits, and absenteeism, totalling over $1 billion annually for the province. As climate change contributes to increasing temperatures in Ontario, the formation of smog may also increase, further exacerbating the health impacts of air pollution on residents.

Local transportation and vehicle emissions

The air pollution in Windsor, Ontario, is a regional issue that requires collaboration with other governments to address. Local transportation and vehicle emissions are significant contributors to the city's air pollution.

The City of Windsor has acknowledged that local transportation is the third major source of air pollution in the city. To mitigate this, the city has purchased 18 hybrid electric buses, converting 18% of the Transit Windsor fleet to hybrid technology. These buses use significantly less fuel than conventional buses and are expected to encourage private citizens and businesses to adopt hybrid technology for their vehicles.

Vehicle emissions from smaller personal vehicles to large heavy-duty vehicles like trucks and lorries contribute to Windsor's air pollution. Diesel-powered larger vehicles emit more chemical pollutants and hazardous particulate matter than smaller vehicles. The combustion processes of fossil fuels in vehicle engines release various chemical pollutants, including particulate matter (PM2.5), which has detrimental effects on human health.

Additionally, Windsor's proximity to heavily industrialised areas in neighbouring countries, such as the United States, contributes to its air pollution. Transboundary factors, including emissions from industrial activities in border states like Michigan, impact the city's air quality. Sulphur dioxide, a colourless gas byproduct of industrial activities, is one such pollutant that exceeds the national average in Windsor, despite the city lacking industrial sources of sulphur dioxide emissions.

To reduce exposure to air pollution, residents are advised to monitor air quality levels and plan activities accordingly. During periods of high air pollution, individuals are encouraged to use public transportation, carpool, or opt for walking or biking when air quality is good.

Power plants burning fossil fuels

Windsor, Ontario, has been impacted by air pollution from the US, particularly from Michigan, which has a history of heavy manufacturing. While the city's levels of sulphur dioxide are below national standards, they exceed the national average. In addition to these external sources, Windsor also has its own local sources of pollution.

One significant local source of pollution in Windsor is its power plants, which burn fossil fuels such as coal. These combustion processes release various chemical pollutants into the atmosphere, including particulate matter (PM2.5), which is used as a major component in calculating overall air quality. PM2.5 refers to particulate matter that is 2.5 micrometres or less in diameter, and it can have a highly harmful effect on human health. In 2019, Windsor saw higher levels of PM2.5 in the latter months of the year, with October recording 6.7 μg/m³, November 10.8 μg/m³, and December 11.4 μg/m³. December was the most polluted month of the year.

Coal-fired power plants are significant contributors to air pollution, as they are the largest industrial source of harmful emissions. In the US, these plants generate 35% of dangerous mercury emissions, two-thirds of sulfur dioxide emissions, and most soot (particulate matter). Sulfur dioxide is a colourless gas that contributes to acid rain. The burning of fossil fuels, such as coal, also releases carbon dioxide, which has been making our oceans more acidic. Since the Industrial Revolution, the ocean's acidity has increased by 30%.

To address these environmental concerns, many power plants that burn fossil fuels have announced retirement plans. This shift could move electricity generation towards renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power. Additionally, new regulations from the EPA aim to strengthen rules limiting mercury and air toxic pollutants from power plants and tighten carbon pollution standards for coal and gas power plants. These efforts are pushing us towards cleaner, renewable energy sources.

Meteorological conditions

Windsor's air pollution is affected by meteorological conditions, such as the colder months driving up energy demand and causing more fuel to be burnt to meet the required energy needs. The combustion processes from burning more fuel emit a variety of chemical pollutants.

The data from 2019 shows that the latter months of the year tend to have higher levels of PM2.5, with October recording 6.7 μg/m³, November 10.8 μg/m³, and December 11.4 μg/m³. December is the most polluted month of the year, with the rest of the year falling within the WHO's target goal.

The higher levels of air pollution towards the end of the year can be attributed to meteorological factors, such as lower temperatures and an increase in wood-burning practices to meet the higher energy demands during the colder months. This results in more fuel combustion, which releases additional chemical pollutants into the atmosphere.

Additionally, smog is more prevalent during the summer months due to higher temperatures and increased sunlight, which contribute to the formation of smog through a chemical reaction between volatile organic compounds (VOCs), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and sunlight. Ground-level ozone, formed during this process, is one of the common air pollutants that negatively impact human health.

Industrial activities

Windsor, a city in Ontario, Canada, is located directly across from Detroit, Michigan, and is part of the Quebec City-Windsor Corridor, a heavily industrialised and densely populated region. Its economy is largely based on the automotive industry, which has earned it the nickname of the "automotive capital of Canada". As a result of these factors, Windsor's air quality is affected by industrial activities.

While Windsor's air quality is considered respectable, it is impacted by both local and transboundary sources of pollution. The city's proximity to the industrial heartland of the United States, including states like Michigan, New York, and Ohio, exposes it to pollutants from across the border. For example, Wayne County in Michigan, which includes the city of Detroit, is a major centre of American manufacturing, with over 180 industrial businesses, including stamping plants, assembly lines, and oil refineries, that contribute to air pollution in the region.

One of the prominent pollutants affecting Windsor is sulphur dioxide (SO2), a colourless gas that is a byproduct of industrial activities. While the city's levels of ambient sulphur dioxide are below national standards, they exceed the national average, even though Windsor does not have any industrial sources reporting emissions of this pollutant to Environment Canada. This indicates that transboundary factors, such as emissions from neighbouring states, play a significant role in Windsor's air quality.

In addition to sulphur dioxide, other chemical pollutants found in Windsor's air include carbon monoxide (CO), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), various oxides of nitrogen (NOx), and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These pollutants are typically associated with combustion sources, including vehicles, local and international factories, and industrial sites. Fine particulate matter (PM2.5), which includes smoke, fumes, dust, pollen, aerosols, and ash, is another concern as it can penetrate deep into the airways and cause respiratory issues.

To manage air pollution, Windsor has implemented measures such as the Air Quality Health Index (AQHI) and Special Air Quality Statements. When the AQHI reaches a certain level, industries are advised to reduce their emissions, and sensitive groups are warned to limit their exposure to pollutants. However, there are calls for stricter enforcement of regulations to effectively address transboundary pollution sources.

Frequently asked questions