Geothermal Energy: Pollution Or Clean Power Source?

Geothermal energy is a renewable energy source that is considered one of the cleanest forms of energy used for electricity generation. However, it is not without its environmental impacts, which include air pollution, water quality and use, land conversion and subsidence, and the safe disposal of hazardous waste. The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted into useful energy, with direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps having minimal negative consequences. Geothermal power plants emit harmful gases, including hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide, ammonia, methane, and boron, which contribute to air pollution and acid rain. Additionally, the process of extracting and re-injecting water can cause land subsidence and minor earthquakes.

Geothermal energy is one of the cleanest forms of energy, but it does produce some air pollutants

Geothermal energy is widely regarded as one of the cleanest forms of energy available today. It is a renewable energy source that provides substantial benefits for our climate, health, and economy. However, like any other energy generation process, it is not entirely free from environmental impacts.

The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted into useful energy. Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have almost no negative effects on the environment. In fact, they can positively impact the environment by reducing the use of more harmful energy sources. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide, carbon dioxide, ammonia, methane, or boron.

Hydrothermal plants, the most widely developed type of geothermal power plant, are located near geological "hot spots," which tend to have higher levels of earthquake risk. There is evidence that these plants can lead to an even greater frequency of earthquakes. Enhanced geothermal systems (hot dry rock) can also increase the risk of small earthquakes. Land subsidence, the sinking of the land surface, is another potential impact of geothermal energy production due to the removal of water from geothermal reservoirs.

Geothermal power plants emit significantly fewer air pollutants than fossil fuel power plants. They produce approximately 30 times less sulfur dioxide per megawatt-hour than coal plants and emit 97% less acid rain-causing sulfur compounds and about 99% less carbon dioxide than similarly-sized fossil fuel plants. Methane emissions from geothermal plants are also several orders of magnitude smaller than those from coal and natural gas plants. However, it is important to note that geothermal plants may produce small amounts of mercury emissions, which must be mitigated using mercury filter technology.

Hydrogen sulfide is the most concerning air pollutant, causing acid rain

The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted. Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have almost no negative effects on the environment. In fact, they can have a positive effect by reducing the use of energy sources that harm the environment. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide.

Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is the most concerning air pollutant emitted by geothermal power plants. It is present in the air, water, soils, and vegetation surrounding geothermal fields. H2S occurs naturally in all types of waters that are depleted in oxygen. It forms when elemental sulfur comes into contact with organic material, especially at high temperatures.

H2S is a significant concern because it causes acid rain, which has various detrimental effects. Acid rain damages crops, forests, and soils, and acidifies lakes and streams. It contributes to the formation of small acidic particulates that can be absorbed by the bloodstream and cause heart and lung disease.

To mitigate the issue of hydrogen sulfide, geothermal power plants use scrubbers to remove it from their reservoirs. Additionally, new methods have been tested to remove hydrogen sulfide from geothermal fluids during well operation. These methods involve the use of ferric iron, either as granulated iron hydroxide or as an FeCl3 solution, which is added to a reaction vessel containing thermal water directly removed from the wells. The water is then pumped through a particle filter, ensuring the complete removal of sulfide.

Geothermal plants also emit small amounts of carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, and boron

Geothermal energy is generally regarded as a low-carbon and climate-friendly energy source. However, geothermal plants do emit small amounts of carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, and boron. The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted to useful energy. The type of technology and cooling systems used also determine the environmental impact of a geothermal plant.

Open-loop geothermal systems emit carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, and boron into the atmosphere. In fact, about 10% of the air emissions from open-loop systems are carbon dioxide. These systems expel waste steam and gases, resulting in greater environmental impacts than closed-loop systems. Closed-loop systems, on the other hand, do not release these gases into the atmosphere. Instead, they inject them back into the ground, resulting in minimal air emissions.

The gases emitted by geothermal power plants are natural constituents of geothermal reservoirs. They would eventually vent into the atmosphere without geothermal power development, but at a much slower rate. Carbon dioxide, while not a pollutant, is a greenhouse gas. Geothermal power plants emit 97% less sulfur compounds and 99% less carbon dioxide than similarly-sized fossil fuel power plants.

Geothermal plants may also emit other pollutants, such as hydrogen sulfide, which has a distinctive "rotten egg" smell and contributes to air pollution. Other emissions include mercury, radon, and volatile species of boron, arsenic, and nitrogen. These emissions can have adverse impacts on ecosystems, human health, and man-made structures.

Water quality and use are key impacts of geothermal energy production

Water quality and consumption are key impacts of geothermal energy production. Underground geothermal reservoirs often contain high concentrations of harmful substances, such as sulfur, salts, silica, sulfates, carbonates, and other compounds and minerals. In open-loop geothermal power plants, these substances can escape into the local environment and affect the quality of the local water table. Water quality is less of a concern in closed-loop systems, where the water is contained within the system and often re-injected into the ground.

Most geothermal facilities have closed-loop water systems, in which extracted water is pumped directly back into the geothermal reservoir after it has been used for heat or electricity production. This helps to prevent contamination and land subsidence. However, not all water removed from the reservoir is re-injected, as some is lost as steam. To maintain water levels in the reservoir, additional sources of water are needed, which can be a concern in areas where water is scarce.

Geothermal power plants consume water in two ways: for cooling purposes and for re-injection. The amount of water needed depends on the size of the plant and the technology used. Tower-cooled geothermal plants can consume up to 5,147 gallons of water per megawatt-hour, making them the second-highest water-consuming power plants after hydropower. This high water consumption can raise conflicts with other water users or uses, such as fish spawning and rearing in water-scarce areas.

While geothermal power plants can impact water quality and consumption, it is important to note that there have been no reported cases of water contamination from geothermal sites in the United States. Additionally, the use of geothermal energy can reduce the consumption of fossil fuels, which has wide-ranging benefits for the environment and human health.

Land subsidence and minor earthquakes are potential consequences of geothermal energy extraction

Geothermal energy is a clean and renewable source of energy. However, it does have some potential environmental impacts, including the risk of land subsidence and minor earthquakes.

Land subsidence

Land subsidence is the slow sinking of the land surface. It can occur when water is removed from geothermal reservoirs, causing the land to sink or subside. This risk can be mitigated by re-injecting wastewater back into the geothermal reservoirs after capturing its heat. Most geothermal facilities employ this method to address the risk of land subsidence.

Minor earthquakes

Geothermal energy projects have been associated with increased seismic activity in some instances. Hydrothermal plants, which are the most widely developed type of geothermal power plants, are often sited on geological "hot spots" with higher levels of earthquake risk. Enhanced geothermal systems (hot dry rock) can also increase the risk of minor earthquakes. This risk can be minimized by maintaining steady water flow rates and ensuring that plants are located an appropriate distance away from major fault lines.

While the drilling itself does not cause earthquakes, steam removal and water return can produce new instability along fault or fracture lines, leading to minor tremors. The threshold goal for acceptable earthquakes is typically set at 2.0 or lower on the Richter scale, and authorities work to prevent earthquakes that can be felt by residents.

In summary, land subsidence and minor earthquakes are potential consequences of geothermal energy extraction. However, these risks can be managed through careful planning, monitoring, and mitigation strategies.

Frequently asked questions