Hydrogen Burning: Clean Energy Or Polluting Nightmare?

Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe. It is a promising and clean energy carrier, which could potentially replace fossil fuels in the transportation sector in the future. Burning hydrogen does not produce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, which is good news for the climate. However, hydrogen combustion produces other emissions, such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), which are hazardous air pollutants. NOx emissions can be reduced using existing and emerging technologies, but it is important to note that hydrogen production can also have a large environmental impact, as it is currently mostly produced from fossil fuels.

Hydrogen combustion produces nitrogen oxide (NOx)

While hydrogen combustion does not produce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, it can produce dangerously high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx). Nitrogen oxides are hazardous air pollutants. NOx formation occurs when air, which contains nitrogen and oxygen, is exposed to very high temperatures (above 1,500°C). Any type of high-temperature combustion, including that of hydrogen, can produce NOx. Nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) are the two hazardous air pollutants that make up NOx.

Because hydrogen burns at higher temperatures than natural gas, combustion of pure hydrogen may result in comparably higher NOx emissions. However, hydrogen has a larger stable combustion temperature range, meaning a higher ratio of air to fuel can be used. This additional air effectively dilutes the hydrogen, which cools off the flame and results in lower-temperature combustion, thereby reducing the amount of NOx emissions produced.

There are multiple mitigation strategies to prevent or reduce NOx emissions when hydrogen is used for combustion. For example, flue gas treatment approaches can convert harmful emissions into less harmful compounds, using processes similar to those in the catalytic converters currently integrated into gasoline- and diesel-powered vehicles.

It is important to note that the standard method for calculating NOx emissions can result in large errors when applied to hydrogen. Researchers have found that hydrogen combustion via turbines can achieve comparable performance and NOx emissions to those of today's turbines running on natural gas. Therefore, it is likely that we are overestimating NOx emissions from hydrogen combustion.

Hydrogen is a clean fuel that produces no pollutants

Hydrogen is an abundant resource that is the lightest chemical element in the universe. It can be produced using fossil fuels or clean electricity and burned to provide power.

When burned, hydrogen does not produce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, which is good news for the climate as it means burning hydrogen does not contribute to climate change. Instead, burning hydrogen yields water vapour, and only water vapour—no soot, no nitrous oxides, and no carbon dioxide. This makes hydrogen a clean fuel that produces no pollutants.

However, hydrogen combustion does produce other air emissions, including nitrogen oxide (NOx). NOx is a hazardous air pollutant that is the main ingredient in smog and can damage lungs and trigger breathing and lung problems in people. Children are especially vulnerable to air pollution like nitrogen oxides.

The production of hydrogen can also be polluting. Close to 95% of hydrogen production is from fossil fuels like natural gas and coal, which emit harmful pollutants. Steam-methane reformation (SMR), the most common way to produce hydrogen, is heavily polluting as it requires extremely high heat, which comes from burning fossil fuels.

Despite this, hydrogen is still a promising clean energy carrier that could potentially replace the use of fossil fuels in the transportation sector in the future.

Hydrogen production can be polluting

Hydrogen is the most abundant chemical substance in the universe. Hydrogen gas can be stored, transported, and burned to provide power. Unlike most fuels, burning hydrogen does not produce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, which is good news for the climate. However, hydrogen production can be polluting, depending on how it is produced.

Today, close to 95% of hydrogen production comes from fossil fuels like natural gas and coal. As a result, we emit 830 million tonnes of CO2 each year to produce 74 million tonnes of hydrogen. Fossil fuel companies are pushing for the use of hydrogen produced from fossil fuels ("dirty hydrogen") to create a huge new source of demand for their product and continue polluting.

One way to produce hydrogen is through steam-methane reformation (SMR), which involves separating hydrogen from methane gas using extremely high heat and pressure. This process is heavily polluting, as the heat comes from burning fossil fuels, which emit harmful pollutants like particulate matter and nitrogen oxides.

There are alternative methods for producing hydrogen that are cleaner and more environmentally friendly. One method is to combine fossil fuel-based hydrogen production with carbon capture and storage. Another method is to use water electrolysis powered by electricity from low-carbon sources, such as renewable energy or nuclear power. These methods can help reduce the environmental impact of hydrogen production and move towards a more sustainable future.

Additionally, it is important to consider the potential for hydrogen leakage, which is a concern regardless of the production method. Hydrogen is highly flammable and prone to leaking, which can have a greenhouse gas effect five times more potent than CO2 when leaked into the atmosphere. Overall, while hydrogen has the potential to be a clean energy source, the current production methods and infrastructure challenges contribute to pollution and environmental concerns.

Hydrogen can be used to mitigate GHG emissions

Hydrogen is the most abundant chemical substance in the universe. It can be produced using fossil fuels or clean electricity, and has the potential to be used as a versatile energy carrier. Hydrogen does not produce carbon dioxide (CO2) when burned, unlike most fuels, and instead yields water. This makes hydrogen an attractive option for fighting climate change by replacing fossil fuels.

However, hydrogen production can have a significant environmental impact, depending on how it is produced. Currently, almost 95% of hydrogen production is from fossil fuels, which emit 830 million tonnes of CO2 annually. This contributes to global warming and climate change. To address this issue, there are two main approaches to producing cleaner hydrogen. The first is to combine fossil fuel-based hydrogen production with carbon capture and storage. The second method involves using water electrolysis powered by electricity from low-carbon sources such as renewable energy or nuclear power.

While burning hydrogen does not produce CO2 emissions, it can lead to other forms of air pollution. Hydrogen combustion can produce high levels of nitrogen oxide (NOx), which is a hazardous air pollutant. NOx emissions are a concern for public health and can be particularly harmful to environmental justice communities. However, there are strategies to mitigate these emissions, such as flue gas treatment, and hydrogen's larger stable combustion temperature range can help dilute it, reducing NOx emissions.

Despite these challenges, hydrogen has the potential to play a crucial role in mitigating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, especially in sectors where emissions are challenging to reduce, such as heavy industry and long-distance transport. Hydrogen can also be used for long-term energy storage, providing fuel for heavy-duty transportation, and heat for industrial processes. With the right infrastructure and regulatory frameworks, hydrogen can be a valuable tool in the transition to a more sustainable energy future.

Hydrogen is a dangerous greenhouse gas

Hydrogen is an essential component in transitioning to a low-carbon economy and achieving net-zero greenhouse gas emission targets. However, it is also an indirect greenhouse gas whose warming impact is widely overlooked and underestimated.

When hydrogen is burned, it does not produce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, which is good news for the climate. However, hydrogen combustion produces other emissions, such as nitrogen oxide (NOx), a hazardous air pollutant. Hydrogen also has a larger stable combustion temperature range, which means a higher ratio of air to fuel can be used. This additional air dilutes the hydrogen, cooling the flame and resulting in lower-temperature combustion, thereby reducing the amount of NOx emissions produced.

In many current and expected future applications, hydrogen produces no air pollution at the point of use. For example, hydrogen can be used in a fuel cell to generate electricity without harmful emissions, emitting only pure water vapour. By providing a zero-emissions option, the use of hydrogen can improve local air quality.

However, hydrogen is a powerful greenhouse gas when leaked into the atmosphere. Hydrogen's small molecule is difficult to contain, and it easily leaks throughout the value chain. This contributes to climate change by increasing the amounts of other greenhouse gases such as methane, ozone, and water vapour, resulting in indirect warming. Proper regulation and supply chain management are crucial to mitigating these risks.

In conclusion, while hydrogen has the potential to be a powerful tool in the fight against climate change, particularly in decarbonizing parts of the economy where electrification is not viable, it is important to recognize that it is not without its drawbacks. The warming impact of hydrogen emissions warrants further attention from scientists, industry, and governments to effectively deploy hydrogen in the emerging decarbonized global economy.

Frequently asked questions