Coffee Roasting: Pollution And Your Daily Brew

Coffee is the third most consumed beverage worldwide, but many are unaware of the environmental and health impact of the coffee supply chain. The roasting process, in particular, has been found to emit harmful compounds and particulate matter, which contribute to air pollution and health issues. The question of whether roasting coffee beans pollute is a pressing one, as it affects the sustainability of coffee and the health of roasters and consumers.

Roasting coffee beans releases toxic compounds

The environmental impact of the coffee industry extends beyond the roasting process. The process of separating the beans from the coffee cherries generates large amounts of waste, and the disposal of this waste into waterways can lead to water pollution and soil degradation. Deforestation is another concern, as some farmers clear-cut forests to fuel the fires used to dry coffee beans. However, there are efforts towards sustainability, such as the development of solar-powered coffee bean drying ovens and the use of biofuels derived from coffee husks.

The health risks associated with coffee roasting have not gone unnoticed. Air samples taken at coffee roasteries in Wisconsin, USA, revealed diacetyl levels that exceeded safety standards. This finding prompted concerns about the potential impact on workers' health, especially since diacetyl has been linked to debilitating lung diseases. While the settlement of a lawsuit brought by coffee workers against a flavouring manufacturer in 2012 brought some attention to the issue, more research is needed to understand the concentrations and exposure levels impacting coffee workers.

To address the environmental and health concerns associated with coffee roasting, various remediation methods have been proposed. One approach involves the use of "afterburners," which are massive incinerators that burn off the emissions. However, this method also contributes to ozone layer depletion. Alternatively, coal-fired power plants employ a combination of wet scrubbing and electrostatic precipitation to control harmful emissions, which could potentially be adapted for use in the coffee industry.

Overall, while roasting coffee beans may contribute to pollution through the release of toxic compounds, there are ongoing efforts to mitigate these impacts and promote more sustainable practices in the coffee industry.

Coffee roasting emits volatile organic compounds

Coffee roasting does emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs). VOCs are released differently depending on the type of coffee and the degree of roasting. The most abundant VOCs present in the samples are 2-butanone, furan, 2-methylfuran, methyl formate, 2.3-pentanedione, methylpyrazine, acetic acid, furfural, 5-methyl furfural, and 2-furanmethanol. Furans were the most abundant group of volatiles present in the coffee samples, with contents higher than 40%.

VOCs are emitted during the roasting, packaging, grinding, and flavoring of coffee. Exposure to VOCs can negatively impact the respiratory health of workers, with inhalation exposure leading to obliterative bronchiolitis. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) has published full-shift Recommended Exposure Limits (RELs) of 5.0 parts per billion (ppb) for diacetyl and 9.3 ppb for 2,3-pentanedione.

In addition to VOCs, coffee roasting also emits greenhouse gases such as carbon, methane, and nitrous oxide, as well as particulate matter (PM), which is airborne dust and dirt. PM can cause coughing and contribute to asthma and other respiratory problems, and exposure to PM is linked to premature death.

Carbon emissions from coffee production to consumption

Coffee is the third most consumed beverage worldwide, with over 9.5 billion kg of coffee produced annually. With global coffee demand expected to triple production by 2050, it is important to consider the carbon emissions associated with coffee production and consumption.

The carbon footprint of the coffee supply chain refers to the total amount of greenhouse gas emissions produced from coffee cultivation, processing, transportation, and consumption. At each stage of the supply chain, various factors contribute to carbon emissions. During the production stage, inputs such as fertilizers, pesticides, and fuel lead to high levels of carbon emissions. The manufacturing processes of harvesting, dry milling, and sorting also result in significant emissions, as they require substantial amounts of water, energy, and land.

The roasting of coffee beans is a significant source of emissions. The combustion of fuel during roasting releases carbon, methane, nitrous oxide, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Roasting also emits toxic compounds such as aldehydes, organic acids, and acrolein. Additionally, the packaging and transportation stages contribute to about 4% of emissions.

The consumption stage of coffee accounts for nearly a third of carbon emissions. The operation of cafes and the use of various machines and appliances, such as blenders, grinders, and brewers, result in high energy consumption. The packaging, grinding, brewing, and disposal of coffee, especially for filter and canned coffees, further contribute to carbon emissions.

To reduce the carbon footprint of coffee consumption, individuals can opt for shade-grown and low-emission coffee options, buy locally sourced coffee, and use reusable cups and filters. By addressing the carbon emissions associated with coffee production and consumption, we can promote sustainability and combat climate change.

Health risks to coffee roasters and nearby residents

Coffee roasting has been associated with several health risks for both coffee roasters and nearby residents. The process of roasting coffee beans generates emissions, primarily particulate matter (PM), that can contribute to air pollution and pose respiratory hazards.

Health Risks to Coffee Roasters

Coffee roasters face various health risks, including both short-term and long-term dangers. The more immediate threats include burns from hot equipment, tripping over extension cords, and ergonomic injuries from bending over packing tables for extended periods. Roasters must also handle heavy sacks of green coffee beans, typically weighing between 50kg and 70kg, which significantly exceeds the safe single-person lifting maximum.

One of the most concerning long-term risks to coffee roasters is the exposure to harmful chemicals released during the roasting process. Green coffee beans contain various chemical compounds, including proteins, fats, sugars, and organic acids. When roasted, these compounds can volatilize, oxidize, or decompose, leading to the emission of toxic compounds such as aldehydes, organic acids, and acrolein.

Of particular concern is the presence of diacetyl, a chemical compound that occurs naturally in coffee beans and is also used as a flavoring agent. Inhalation of diacetyl has been linked to a rare lung disease called bronchiolitis obliterans or "popcorn lung." While modern roasteries often have ventilation systems to protect employees from direct inhalation, exposure to diacetyl above the recommended limit has been detected in some facilities, posing a serious health risk to roasters.

Health Risks to Nearby Residents

The emissions from coffee roasting facilities can also impact the health of people living nearby. As mentioned earlier, roasting coffee beans releases particulate matter (PM) into the air, which includes airborne dust and dirt. According to the EPA, exposure to PM can cause coughing, contribute to asthma, and is linked to premature death. Additionally, coffee roasting emits volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and greenhouse gases such as carbon, methane, and nitrous oxide, further contributing to air pollution.

While the specific health risks to nearby residents from coffee roasting emissions may vary depending on the location and concentration of pollutants, it is important for coffee roasting facilities to implement measures to minimize these risks. Adequate ventilation, air quality monitoring, and sustainable packaging solutions can help reduce the impact of emissions on both employees and the surrounding community.

Deforestation and waste from coffee bean drying

Coffee is the second most traded commodity in the world, with over 150 million 60 kg bags consumed worldwide in 2014. The coffee plant (Coffea arabica) produces red berries that contain the desired coffee bean. Coffee is an extremely sensitive plant that only grows in warm, moist, high-altitude climates. This means that coffee cultivation is the primary threat to cloud forests/rainforests and national parks, as it requires the clearing of forest land for coffee farms.

For a typical cup of conventionally dried coffee, nearly a half-square inch of forest is lost to provide the firewood to dry the coffee beans. The widely used practice of burning forests to then till the land changes the temperature and chemical composition of the soil. The forest canopy no longer provides protection from the sun, and the soil lacks decomposing foliage. This allows moisture that was previously trapped to escape, leaving the land warmer and drier. Soil erosion is another byproduct of deforestation, and when natural ecosystems are permanently converted into agricultural lands, there is a loss of valuable organic soil components, such as soil carbon.

The demand for coffee continues to increase, and it is estimated that to keep up with consumer demand, coffee production will need to triple by 2050. This will require an area the size of Honduras and Nicaragua combined to be converted to coffee farms, threatening the remaining forests in Central America. However, some companies are taking steps to reduce deforestation caused by coffee production. Café Solar® uses forest-friendly production and patented processing methods that help to reduce deforestation. Café Solar® is eliminating the burning of wood from rainforests as fuel to dry coffee beans and is promoting forest-friendly coffee farms that have forest buffers around the areas of cultivation. Carbon-neutral processing (hybrid solar and biofuels) eliminates the use of tropical firewood in industrial coffee drying and reduces electricity consumption by 80%.

Frequently asked questions