Developing Countries: Pollution's Unseen Source?

While air pollution is a global issue, it disproportionately affects developing countries. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), air pollution kills around 7 million people worldwide annually, with 3.8 million deaths resulting from indoor air pollution, predominantly in low- to middle-income countries. This is due to a range of factors, including the use of solid fuels for cooking, heating, and lighting, as well as the outsourcing of polluting industries from developed to developing countries. Wealthier nations have contributed significantly to the climate crisis and have a responsibility to assist developing nations in mitigating and adapting to its impacts.

Wealthy nations outsource dirty manufacturing to developing countries

While air pollution is a global issue, it is often portrayed as a more significant problem in developing countries. This is not a misconception, as scientific studies and news reports confirm that low- and middle-income countries are indeed the most affected by air pollution. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), air pollution kills approximately 7 million people worldwide annually, with 3.8 million of those deaths resulting from indoor air pollution in low- to middle-income countries. This is largely due to the inefficient use of solid fuels such as wood, charcoal, and dung for cooking, heating, and lighting, which release toxic air pollutants.

Furthermore, it is essential to acknowledge the role of wealthy nations in contributing to pollution in developing countries. The consumption patterns of wealthy countries directly impact the environmental conditions in developing nations, as they often outsource their dirty manufacturing practices to these regions. This phenomenon, known as "pollution outsourcing," occurs when companies in wealthy nations relocate their manufacturing processes to poorer areas with cheaper labor and less stringent environmental regulations. For instance, the production of goods in China and other rising economies, such as India and Brazil, has been linked to increased carbon pollution, with many of these goods being consumed in the United States and Europe.

The outsourcing of emissions by wealthy countries takes various forms, including the manufacturing of electronic devices, cheap clothing, and other goods. By importing more steel, cement, and manufactured products, wealthy countries can report lower carbon emissions while effectively outsourcing their pollution to developing nations. This "carbon loophole" skews the accuracy of global emissions accounting, which has traditionally been conducted on a national basis.

To address this issue, international cooperation and a transition away from fossil fuels are crucial. Wealthy nations have pledged to mobilize $100 billion per year to assist developing countries in reducing emissions and adapting to climate change. However, the complexity of defining and funding mitigation and adaptation measures, as well as the lack of a single organization tracking these projects, presents challenges in ensuring the effective use of these funds.

While industrialization and the shift from agriculture to manufacturing have been historically associated with development, it is important to recognize that service-led development is also gaining traction. Middle-income countries like Costa Rica and the Philippines have successfully focused on professional and technical services, achieving gains in productivity and large-scale job creation. This highlights that manufacturing is not the only path to development for poor countries and that exploring alternative sectors can lead to more sustainable progress.

Developing countries lack the resources to transition away from fossil fuels

While air pollution is a global issue, it disproportionately affects people in developing countries. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), air pollution kills around 7 million people worldwide each year, with 3.8 million of those deaths resulting from indoor air pollution. This primarily affects people in low- to middle-income countries due to inefficient cooking, heating, and lighting practices that use solid fuels and kerosene. These practices release toxic air pollutants, causing severe health issues, particularly for women, children, and the elderly in these countries.

Developing countries face challenges in transitioning away from fossil fuels due to a lack of resources and economic constraints. Middle-income developing countries produce about half of the world's oil and gas, and their economies are heavily dependent on this volatile industry. They have fewer resources than wealthy nations to facilitate the transition to cleaner energy sources and protect their communities from the impacts of climate change.

The transition to cleaner energy sources requires significant financial investments, and developing countries may struggle to balance economic growth with environmental protection. They often lack diversified economies, with the oil and gas sector contributing significantly to exports and government revenue. Phasing out fossil fuels can lead to stranded assets, which are investments or infrastructure that become obsolete due to changes in technology or regulations. Developing countries cannot afford to strand their assets, given their urgent development needs and poverty alleviation goals.

To address these challenges, international cooperation and support are crucial. Wealthy nations have pledged to mobilize $100 billion per year to help developing countries reduce emissions and adapt to climate change. However, the distribution and utilization of this funding are complex, and there may be discrepancies between pledged and actual contributions. Additionally, developing countries need tailored strategies and consistent implementation to transition successfully. This includes domestic funding sources, such as taxes on fossil fuels and reforming subsidies, as well as international support in the form of financial resources, technology transfers, and capacity building.

In summary, developing countries face significant challenges in transitioning away from fossil fuels due to limited resources and economic constraints. International cooperation, financial support, and strategic planning are vital to help these countries protect their communities and achieve sustainable economic diversification while contributing to global climate goals.

Energy production is one of the most polluting activities

The environmental problems associated with energy production and consumption go beyond air pollution. Energy production contributes to climate change, water pollution, thermal pollution, and solid waste disposal issues. For example, coal mining can pollute water sources by bringing uncontaminated water into contact with mineral materials, leading to acid mine drainage. Oil spills are another form of water pollution directly linked to energy usage.

Electricity generation and transmission are governed by laws and regulations, such as the Clean Air Act in the United States, which help mitigate the environmental impact. This act has successfully reduced emissions of major air pollutants. To comply with regulations, power plants employ various strategies, including burning low-sulfur-content coal, co-firing wood chips with coal, and using emission control devices like baghouses, electrostatic precipitators, and scrubbers.

While energy production is a significant contributor to pollution, it is important to note that consumption patterns also play a role. Wealthier countries often maintain low pollution levels by outsourcing dirtier manufacturing practices to developing nations with cheaper labor and less stringent environmental regulations. This dynamic results in developing countries suffering the environmental and health consequences of production while the goods are consumed elsewhere.

Furthermore, developing countries may face challenges in transitioning away from polluting infrastructure due to limited resources and the need to prioritize short-term economic gains. This situation underscores the complexity of addressing global pollution and the importance of international cooperation and financial support from wealthier nations to help developing countries reduce emissions and adapt to climate change.

Developing countries face a trade-off between growth and pollution

While every country in the world deals with air pollution to some extent, the problem of air pollution is far worse in developing countries. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), air pollution kills around 7 million people worldwide every year, with 9 out of 10 individuals breathing air that exceeds WHO pollutant guideline limits. In particular, low- and middle-income countries are the most impacted. Based on the WHO's 2016 urban air quality database, 98% of cities in developing countries with over 100,000 inhabitants fail to meet WHO air quality guidelines. In developed countries, this number drops to 56%.

Developing countries face a trade-off between economic growth and pollution. There is pressure on developing nations to grow their economies and remain competitive with already developed nations. This encourages governments in developing nations to invest in cheap but dirty fuel. As Kevin Wood from Camfil USA states, "Developing nations are less likely to invest in cleaner sources of energy because these renewable resources tend to be more expensive to procure than cheap and readily available fossil fuels like coal." Infrastructure in developing countries is frequently expanding so rapidly that cleaner and more efficient forms of energy cannot be practically installed. Coal provides cheap energy that powers developing infrastructure, but it is also the dirtiest fossil fuel.

Developing countries must make difficult choices between the level of pollutants they release and the growth of their economies. Once a nation is sufficiently industrialized, it can begin pursuing alternative forms of energy, but this process of industrialization requires massive amounts of energy, creating a spiral of expansion and pollution that is difficult to escape. As Wood points out, "Over the next 30 years, the most rapid expansion of economies and populations will occur in urban areas distributed throughout the poorest countries." This rapid and unsustainable growth will make developing cities among the primary sources of environmental damage and air pollution. Therefore, efforts to combat air pollution and global climate change should focus on these developing areas.

To reduce emissions, developing countries should pursue the reduction of emissions from industrial smokestacks, invest in renewable energy sources, prioritize rapid and communal transit, and provide options for cycling and walking in cities. Developed nations also need to cooperate and enforce standards of air quality to promote health. These efforts will require intense dedication but are necessary to protect the lives of nearly everyone on Earth.

It is important to note that wealthy countries, particularly the United States and Western European nations, have emitted the majority of greenhouse gases that led to the climate crisis. However, it is the developing nations that are being hit hardest by the effects and are the least ready to respond. This is why there have been efforts by rich nations to provide funding to help developing countries reduce their emissions and adapt to the impacts of climate change.

Indoor air pollution is a major issue in developing countries

While air pollution is a global issue, it disproportionately affects people in developing countries. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), air pollution kills around 7 million people annually, with 3.8 million of those deaths resulting from indoor air pollution, predominantly in low- to middle-income countries.

Indoor air pollution is a significant problem in developing nations, where approximately half of the population relies on coal and biomass, such as wood, dung, and crop residues, for domestic energy needs. These materials are often burned in simple stoves with incomplete combustion, leading to high levels of indoor air pollution. Women and children are particularly vulnerable as they are usually responsible for domestic tasks, including gathering fuel, tending the hearth, and cooking meals. The pollutants released from these practices, such as particulates, carbon monoxide, and other combustion-related pollutants, have severe health implications. Studies have linked indoor air pollution to an increased risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, acute respiratory infections, pulmonary tuberculosis, and various types of cancer.

The lack of access to cleaner fuels and technologies in developing countries exacerbates the problem. Additionally, the economic challenges faced by these countries can create a trade-off between short-term economic gains and transitioning to more sustainable practices. Wealthier nations have contributed significantly to the climate crisis and have a responsibility to support developing countries in mitigating and adapting to its impacts.

Furthermore, the manufacturing practices of wealthier nations often contribute to pollution in developing countries. Outsourcing production to regions with cheaper labor and less stringent environmental regulations shifts the environmental and health burdens of manufacturing to these regions. This dynamic further underscores the global nature of the climate crisis and the interconnectedness of consumption patterns, pollution, and health outcomes across borders.

Addressing indoor air pollution in developing countries requires a multifaceted approach. Increasing access to cleaner fuels and technologies, improving ventilation in homes, and implementing interventions that recognize the link between poverty and dependence on polluting fuels are crucial steps. Additionally, wealthier nations must uphold their commitments to provide financial support and aid in capacity building to help developing countries transition to more sustainable practices and adapt to the impacts of climate change.

Frequently asked questions