Land Pollution's Link To Florida's Red Tide

Florida's red tide is caused by the growth of a microscopic algae called Karenia brevis, which produces a harmful algal bloom (HAB) that can be seen from space. While human pollution is not the sole cause of red tide, it does exacerbate the problem. Nutrient pollution from sources such as excess agricultural fertilizers, septic tank leaks, and urban stormwater runoff can worsen the intensity of red tide blooms. The Caloosahatchee River in Southwest Florida, for example, has been linked to increased nitrogen levels and more severe red tide outbreaks along the coast. As such, limiting pollution in Florida's waterways is crucial for reducing the severity of red tides and preventing other harmful algal blooms, which can have drastic consequences for the environment, economy, and public health.

Human pollution's role in Florida's red tide

Red tide, or a harmful algal bloom, is a higher-than-normal concentration of a microscopic alga (plantlike organism) that occurs nearly every summer along the coasts of Florida and Texas. In Florida, the species that causes most red tides is Karenia brevis, often abbreviated as K. brevis. This species of algae produces potent neurotoxins that can be suspended in the air near beaches and cause human respiratory illness. They can also accumulate in shellfish and cause neurotoxic shellfish poisoning in humans.

While human pollution is not the sole cause of red tide, it does play a significant role in magnifying its effects. Nutrient pollution from excess agricultural fertilizers, underground septic tank leaks, and urban stormwater runoff are leading causes of water-quality problems. These nonpoint sources of pollution diffusely contaminate waterways, providing nutrients that fuel the growth of red tide algae.

Research has specifically linked increasing amounts of nitrogen, a persistent problem causing harmful algal blooms, to the intensity of red tide on Florida's coast. A study focusing on the Caloosahatchee River in Southwest Florida found a clear cause-and-effect relationship between nitrogen levels and red tide severity. This research provides strong evidence that humans directly influence the intensity of toxic blooms.

The southwest coast of Florida is especially susceptible to Karenia brevis blooms due to its warm and naturally nutrient-rich water. However, nutrients produced from pollution have exacerbated the problem, intensifying the blooms once they reach the coast. This has severe consequences for the environment, economy, and public health in the affected regions.

To mitigate the effects of red tide, strategies should focus on limiting pollution in Florida's waterways. This includes improving wastewater infrastructure, promoting best practices in agriculture, and building green infrastructure to support the state's wetlands. By reducing nutrient inputs, the severity of red tide can be decreased, saving the lives of marine animals and protecting human health.

The impact of nutrient pollution on red tide

Red tide, or a harmful algal bloom, is a higher-than-normal concentration of a microscopic alga (plant-like organism). In Florida, the species that causes most red tides is Karenia brevis, often abbreviated as K. brevis. These algal blooms can cause respiratory illness and eye irritation in humans and can even kill marine life.

While human pollution does not cause red tide on its own, it does magnify it. Nutrient pollution from excess agricultural fertilizers, underground septic tank leaks, and urban stormwater runoff are all sources of waterway pollution that are not regulated by the Clean Water Act. These nonpoint sources of pollution are the leading cause of water-quality problems across the nation.

A study conducted by the University of Florida found a clear link between increasing amounts of nitrogen in the Caloosahatchee River and the intensity of red tide on the coast. The study focused on the Caloosahatchee River in Southwest Florida, which carries water and pollutants from Lake Okeechobee as it flows west to the Gulf of Mexico. While excess nitrogen does not cause red tide, it exacerbates the problem.

The southwest coast of Florida is especially susceptible to Karenia brevis blooms because of the area's warm and naturally nutrient-rich water. However, nutrients produced from pollution make the phenomenon much worse. Therefore, limiting pollution in Florida waterways is one of the best strategies for mitigating the effects of red tide.

The effects of nitrogen on red tide

Nitrogen is one of the leading causes of pollution in Florida, and it has been linked to the intensity of red tide blooms. While red tides are a natural occurrence, they are worsened by high levels of nutrients, such as nitrogen, from human sources, including agricultural and urban activities.

Red tide, or harmful algal blooms, are caused by a species of microscopic algae called Karenia brevis, often abbreviated as K. brevis. These blooms can turn the water a deep red colour and produce toxins that have harmful effects on humans, marine life, and the environment. K. brevis feeds on nitrogen and phosphorus, and when there is an excess of these nutrients, the algae can multiply out of control, sucking oxygen out of the water and producing neurotoxins.

The link between nitrogen and red tide has been challenging to establish due to the complex factors contributing to the blooms. However, recent studies have found clear evidence of a cause-and-effect relationship. By analyzing long-term data and patterns over nine years, scientists detected a correlation between increasing amounts of nitrogen in the Caloosahatchee River and the intensity of red tide on the coast. This river flows west from Lake Okeechobee to the Gulf of Mexico, carrying water and pollutants.

The effects of nitrogen-enriched discharges on red tide blooms are significant. Nitrogen inputs from coastal and inland parts of the watershed, including the Kissimmee River, Lake Okeechobee, and the Caloosahatchee River, have been shown to consistently intensify the blooms in the harbor and along the coast. This intensification leads to more severe impacts on wildlife and human health, including respiratory issues, neurologic problems, and gastrointestinal distress.

To mitigate the effects of nitrogen on red tide, efforts should focus on reducing nitrogen loads and improving water-quality monitoring. By restoring the Everglades and optimizing lake operations to increase water flow to the south during the dry season, nitrogen discharges to Florida's Gulf Coast can be significantly reduced, lessening the fuel for red tide blooms.

The consequences of red tide on marine life

Red tide, or harmful algal blooms, have devastating consequences for marine life. The toxins produced by the blooms are fatal to fish, causing violent twisting and corkscrew swimming, defecation, regurgitation, pectoral fin paralysis, and convulsions. Ultimately, fish die because their gills stop functioning. Fish kills are often the only noticeable effect of blooms. These toxins can also accumulate in primary consumers such as zooplankton, fish, bivalves, and other filter feeders, which can then be transferred to predators such as fish, crustaceans, and other bottom-dwelling organisms. This ripple effect continues up the food chain, eventually reaching larger animals, including sea turtles, birds, and marine mammals.

In addition to fish, invertebrates such as shrimp, sponges, sea urchins, crabs, and certain shellfish are also affected by red tides. Shellfish closures are often necessary during red tides to protect public health. Brevetoxins, the toxins produced by Karenia brevis, can accumulate in shellfish, causing neurotoxic shellfish poisoning in humans.

Marine mammals are also impacted by red tides, either by consuming contaminated prey or by inhaling toxins. Catastrophic die-offs of marine mammals have been recorded during red tides, including the largest dolphin die-off, which resulted in more than 740 bottlenose dolphin strandings along the U.S. Atlantic coast from June 1987 to May 1988. Manatees have also been affected, with suspected red tide-related deaths first reported in 1965 and extensive die-offs occurring in recent decades.

Red tides also contribute to low-oxygen conditions underwater, further exacerbating the mortality of marine life. The combination of toxins and low oxygen levels can lead to mass die-offs of various marine species, including fish, invertebrates, and marine mammals.

While red tides have been documented along Florida's Gulf Coast since the 1840s, they are becoming a more frequent environmental concern. The increasing prevalence of red tides is attributed to human activities, with nutrients and sediment from agricultural fertilizers, septic tank leaks, and urban stormwater runoff contaminating water bodies and providing abnormal increases in nutrients for algae growth.

Controlling and preventing red tide

Red tide, or a harmful algal bloom, is a higher-than-normal concentration of a microscopic algae species called Karenia brevis, often abbreviated as K. brevis. This species of algae produces potent neurotoxins that can be suspended in the air near beaches and cause human respiratory illness. They can also accumulate in shellfish and cause neurotoxic shellfish poisoning in humans.

While there is currently no verified method to eradicate and prevent red tide, researchers are actively working on solutions. In the 1950s, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and State of Florida scientists attempted to use copper sulfate to eliminate a red tide, but this led to the release of toxins that had negative effects on other marine organisms.

One promising technique being evaluated by a team of experts from Florida and Massachusetts involves spraying a clay mixture on top of the water to weigh down the algae and drag it to the ocean floor. This method has been successfully used in parts of Asia, but uncertainty about its long-term environmental impacts has prevented its widespread use in the U.S. Initial results from a small field test in July 2021 showed that it killed about 75% of the red tide cells in two hours, but the levels of toxins only decreased slightly.

Another approach being explored is the use of modified clay with a polymer that changes the surface of the clay molecule, making it more attractive to the red tide cells. This method has been shown to be effective in China, requiring significantly less clay compared to the traditional clay flocculation method.

It is important to note that any control strategy for red tide must not only kill the red tide organism but also eliminate the toxins from the water without causing harm to the environment. Researchers are also working on ways to reduce shellfish toxicity during red tide events.

Frequently asked questions