Hydro Power: Water Pollution Or Clean Energy?

Hydroelectricity is often considered a clean energy source as it does not directly emit air pollutants and has a smaller carbon footprint per unit of energy than electricity generated from fossil fuels. However, the construction and operation of hydroelectric dams can have significant environmental and societal impacts, including water pollution. The degradation in water quality in hydroelectric reservoirs and downstream can affect plant and animal life, with potential consequences for human health and aquatic activities. This raises the question: does hydroelectricity contribute to pollution in water, and if so, what are the implications for this widely adopted renewable energy technology?

Hydroelectric facilities impact aquatic ecosystems

Hydroelectric facilities can have a significant impact on aquatic ecosystems. The construction and operation of dams and reservoirs can alter the environment over a much larger area than just the reservoir site. This can result in the relocation of human populations and the disruption or destruction of entire ecosystems.

One of the primary ways hydroelectric facilities impact aquatic ecosystems is by blocking the annual inflow of sediments and nutrients and disrupting migratory fish populations. Fish and other organisms can also be injured or killed by turbine blades, despite the existence of methods to minimise this impact, such as fish ladders and intake screens.

Hydroelectric dams can also affect water quality. Reservoir water tends to be more stagnant, with higher levels of sediments, nutrients, and algae than normal river water. This can lead to eutrophication, the enrichment of water with chemical nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus, and oxygen stratification, where thermal energy accumulates in the top layers of the reservoir closest to the sun. When water is released from the reservoir, it can be colder and have lower levels of dissolved oxygen than normal river water, potentially harming downstream plants and animals.

Additionally, if too much water is stored behind a reservoir, river segments downstream can dry out, harming plant and animal life. Greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide and methane can also form in reservoirs due to the decomposition of biomass. While hydropower generators do not directly emit air pollutants, the construction and decommissioning of concrete and steel dams can produce emissions, particularly if fossil fuels are used for energy during manufacturing.

Hydropower plants divert water, causing unnatural droughts

Hydropower is generated by funneling water through power plants contained within dam structures. The size of the reservoir created by a hydroelectric project varies, depending on the size of the generators and the topography of the land. Hydropower plants in flat areas tend to require much more land than those in hilly areas or canyons.

Hydropower plants divert water, which can cause unnatural droughts. Drought and water scarcity present unique challenges for the energy sector, as all sources of energy require water in their production processes. The availability and predictability of water resources can directly affect energy systems. For example, a recent PNNL report shows that even during the most severe droughts of the past century, hydropower has sustained 80% of average generation levels. However, the report also highlights the concern that the current megadrought in the Southwestern United States could deplete water reservoir levels to critically low levels.

Hydropower projects must deal with a range of hydrological risks, from too little to too much water, and climate change is projected to increase these risks in many regions. By 2050, 61% of all global hydropower dams will be in basins with a very high or extreme risk of droughts, floods, or both. Falling water levels have already impacted hydropower generation in the southwestern US, southern Africa, and Brazil.

The creation of reservoirs can also result in the relocation of people and negatively impact the environment. The water in reservoirs is usually more stagnant than normal river water, and it can undergo eutrophication, the enrichment of water with chemical nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorous. Additionally, the accumulation of thermal energy in the top layers of reservoirs closest to the sun can alter the temperature of the water downstream, a form of thermal pollution.

Hydroelectricity contributes to greenhouse gas emissions

The use of water to produce electricity can pollute the water, either directly as a result of the dam's action or as a byproduct of creating a reservoir or redirecting water systems. Hydroelectricity contributes to greenhouse gas emissions in several ways. Firstly, the creation of a reservoir can lead to the emission of greenhouse gases due to the decomposition of flooded organic material. The long residence time of the water in the reservoir contributes to eutrophication, which is the enrichment of water with chemical nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus. This can result in the formation of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide and methane through the aerobic and anaerobic decomposition of biomass in the water.

Secondly, the operation of a dam and the use of water can alter the environment beyond the area covered by the reservoir. This includes the relocation of people and changes to downstream water temperatures due to thermal pollution. Thermal pollution occurs when thermal energy accumulates in the top layers of the reservoir closest to the sun, causing the water drawn into the turbine from the bottom of the reservoir to be colder and thus altering the temperature of the water downstream.

Thirdly, the physical impacts of a dam and reservoir can affect wildlife both within the dammed reservoirs and downstream. For example, fish and other organisms can be injured or killed by turbine blades, and the water downstream may not receive enough water, causing harm to plant and animal life. Additionally, reservoir water is usually more stagnant than normal river water, which can further impact aquatic ecosystems.

It is important to note that hydropower is still considered a low-carbon source of renewable energy compared to fossil fuels. The long operating lifetime of a hydropower plant (50 to 100 years) helps to offset these emissions, and in some cases, a reservoir may act as a carbon sink, absorbing more emissions than it emits. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's (IPCC) Fifth Assessment Report concluded that hydropower has a lower median lifecycle greenhouse gas emission intensity than most other energy sources.

Hydroelectric dams degrade water quality

Hydroelectricity is often touted as a clean energy source that does not directly emit air pollutants. However, the construction and operation of hydroelectric dams can have significant impacts on water quality and the surrounding aquatic ecosystems.

One of the primary ways hydroelectric dams degrade water quality is through the creation of reservoirs, which have a higher risk of becoming stagnant compared to normal river water. The water in these reservoirs can develop thermal pollution, where the top layers closest to the sun accumulate thermal energy, resulting in layers of water with varying temperatures. When this water is released downstream, it can alter the natural water temperatures, affecting the local ecosystem.

Additionally, reservoirs are prone to eutrophication, which is the enrichment of water with chemical nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus. The efficient trapping of particulates and the long residence time of water in reservoirs contribute to frequent eutrophication. This, coupled with the lack of water movement, often leads to algal blooms. As the algae die, they are decomposed by microorganisms, further degrading the water quality.

The formation of reservoirs can also result in the flooding of land, including forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and even communities. This destruction and relocation can have far-reaching consequences for the environment and local populations. The flooding of vegetation and soil can also lead to the release of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide and methane, during their decomposition.

Furthermore, hydroelectric dams can obstruct fish migration and impact the movement of other aquatic organisms. While measures like fish ladders and intake screens can help minimize these impacts, fish and other organisms remain at risk of injury or death from turbine blades. The altered river flow characteristics and silt loads caused by dams can also affect native plants and animals in and around the river.

In summary, while hydroelectricity may not directly contribute air pollutants, the construction and operation of hydroelectric dams can have detrimental effects on water quality and the surrounding ecosystems. These impacts, including thermal pollution, eutrophication, flooding, and obstruction of fish migration, highlight the complex trade-offs between the benefits of clean energy and the preservation of aquatic environments.

Hydroelectric reservoirs cause eutrophication

Hydroelectric reservoirs can cause eutrophication, a process that occurs when there is an over-enrichment of nutrients in a body of water. This can happen due to the long residence time of the water in the reservoir, which increases the availability of nutrients for phytoplankton and other aquatic organisms. The retention time and high nutrient availability in the water increase the eutrophic level, leading to eutrophication.

Eutrophication is a natural process in aquatic systems, but it can be accelerated by human inputs of nutrients through the discharge of domestic, agricultural, and industrial effluents. This is known as cultural eutrophication. Phosphorus and nitrogen are the two main nutrients that cause cultural eutrophication as they enrich the water, allowing for some aquatic plants, especially algae, to grow rapidly and bloom in high densities. The increase in residence time in reservoirs leads to the availability of nutrients for a longer period, which contributes to eutrophication.

The construction and use of hydroelectric dams and reservoirs can change the hydrodynamics of rivers, causing diverse impacts on terrestrial and aquatic systems. The water in reservoirs is usually more stagnant than normal river water, and the operation of the dam and the use of water can change the environment over a much larger area than the reservoir itself. The size of the reservoir created by a hydroelectric project can vary depending on the size of the generators and the topography of the land, with reservoirs in flat areas requiring more land than those in hilly areas or canyons.

Cultural eutrophication, caused by human activities, has been a problem since the introduction of chemical fertilizers in agriculture (the green revolution of the mid-1900s). Sewage, industrial wastewater, and fertilizer runoff are all human-caused nutrient sources that contribute to cultural eutrophication. These nutrient pollutions usually cause algal blooms and bacterial growth, resulting in substantial environmental degradation.

Eutrophication has significant economic and environmental impacts. It can lead to harmful algal blooms, dead zones, and fish kills, affecting both aquatic life and human activities such as fishing. The degradation in water quality flowing through hydroelectric dams and reservoirs can affect a wide range of plant and animal life, and the accumulation of nutrients in reservoirs can lead to public health problems.

Frequently asked questions