The Clean Energy Conundrum: Geothermal's Environmental Impact

Geothermal energy is heat that flows continuously from the Earth's core to the surface, and has been doing so for about 4.5 billion years. This heat is replenished by the decay of naturally occurring radioactive elements in the Earth's interior, providing an inexhaustible supply of energy. The most widely developed type of geothermal power plant is hydrothermal plants, which are located near hot spots where hot molten rock is close to the earth's crust and produces hot water. Other types of geothermal energy include hot dry rock geothermal, geopressured resources, and magma. Geothermal energy is considered one of the cleanest forms of energy used for electricity generation today, but it does have some environmental impacts. The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted, with direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps having minimal negative effects on the environment.

Geothermal energy is a clean, renewable energy source

Geothermal power plants operate by drawing fluid or steam from underground reservoirs, and these reservoirs have proven their longevity at various geothermal plants around the world. The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used or converted, but overall, it is much cleaner than many other energy sources. For example, geothermal power plants emit 97% less acid rain-causing sulfur compound and about 99% less carbon dioxide than fossil fuel plants of similar sizes.

Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have almost no negative effects on the environment and can even have positive effects by reducing the use of more harmful energy sources. Additionally, most geothermal plants reinject water into the reservoir to prevent contamination and land subsidence, and they use scrubbers to remove the hydrogen sulfide naturally found in geothermal reservoirs.

Closed-loop geothermal systems, which directly convert geothermal steam or hot water into electricity, do not release gases or fluids into the atmosphere as they are usually injected back into the ground. In contrast, open-loop systems expel waste steam and gases, resulting in greater environmental impacts. However, even in open-loop systems, the emissions are still minimal compared to other energy sources. For instance, in open-loop systems, only about 10% of air emissions are carbon dioxide, with smaller amounts of methane, and the global warming emissions are estimated at approximately 0.1 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalent per kilowatt-hour.

Overall, geothermal energy is a clean and renewable energy source that has the potential to provide substantial benefits for our climate, health, and economy.

Environmental impact depends on conversion and cooling technology used

The environmental impact of geothermal energy depends on the technology used for conversion and cooling. Geothermal energy is considered one of the cleanest forms of energy used for electricity generation today. However, the specific environmental effects can vary depending on the technology employed.

Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have negligible negative environmental impacts. They can even have a positive impact by reducing the use of more harmful energy sources. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide. These emissions are significantly lower than those of similarly sized fossil fuel power plants. For instance, geothermal plants emit 97% less sulfur compounds and 99% less carbon dioxide. Additionally, most geothermal plants use scrubbers to remove hydrogen sulfide from geothermal reservoirs.

The type of cooling technology employed also influences the environmental impact. Geothermal plants can use either geothermal fluid or freshwater for cooling. Using geothermal fluid reduces the overall water impact of the plant. Furthermore, most plants reinject water into the reservoir to prevent contamination and land subsidence. However, the amount of water required for cooling can range from 1,700 to 4,000 gallons per megawatt-hour, depending on the cooling technology.

The design of the geothermal system also affects its environmental impact. Open-loop systems release gases and waste steam into the atmosphere, while closed-loop systems do not. Open-loop systems have higher emissions, with approximately 10% of their air emissions being carbon dioxide and a smaller amount being methane. Enhanced geothermal systems, which require drilling and pumping water into hot rock reservoirs, have higher life-cycle global warming emissions than closed-loop systems.

In summary, the environmental impact of geothermal energy is influenced by the conversion and cooling technologies used, as well as the system design. While geothermal energy is generally considered clean and environmentally friendly, certain technologies and systems may have more significant impacts than others.

Open-loop systems release gases, closed-loop systems don't

Geothermal energy is a renewable energy source that provides substantial benefits for the climate, health, and economy. The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used or converted. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide.

Open-loop geothermal systems pump water from a well, run it through the system, and then dump it back into the ground. These systems are often referred to as "pump and dump" and can also be installed as standing column systems that utilize single wells. They are cost-effective, energy-efficient, and require little maintenance. However, they consume a significant amount of water, with some estimates placing their water usage at over 1 million gallons per year. Additionally, open-loop systems release gases into the atmosphere. Approximately 10% of their air emissions are carbon dioxide, with smaller amounts of methane, a potent global warming gas, also being released.

Closed-loop geothermal systems, on the other hand, do not release these gases into the atmosphere. These systems circulate water or a blended water-glycol solution through a closed loop of deeply buried pipes that conduct the Earth's heat. There are two common designs for closed-loop systems: the U-tube and the tube-in-tube. Closed-loop systems can be placed anywhere in the world and provide carbon-free, baseload energy with no impact on natural water resources. They are drilled much deeper than open-loop systems to access hotter rock and produce larger volumes of energy.

While open-loop systems offer advantages such as cost-effectiveness and energy efficiency, they release gases that contribute to global warming. In contrast, closed-loop systems are a prominent category of next-generation geothermal systems that do not release gases into the atmosphere and offer additional benefits such as carbon-free energy and reduced environmental impact.

Hydrogen sulfide is the most concerning pollutant

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the Earth's surface. The most widely developed type of geothermal power plant is hydrothermal plants, which are located near "hot spots" where molten rock close to the Earth's crust produces hot water. Another type of geothermal energy that has been explored is hot dry rock geothermal, which involves drilling into the Earth's surface to reach deeper geothermal resources.

Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur and carbon dioxide. They emit 97% less acid rain-causing sulfur compounds and about 99% less carbon dioxide than fossil fuel plants of a similar size. However, one of the main environmental concerns regarding geothermal energy is the presence of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) in the air, water, soils, and vegetation surrounding geothermal fields.

Hydrogen sulfide is a toxic gas that poses serious problems for the environment, human health, and geothermal equipment. It is both naturally occurring and human-made, with the latter source expected to increase due to increased heavy oil refining. While most geothermal power plants use scrubbers to remove hydrogen sulfide from the water, the gas can still be released into the atmosphere during the process of generating electricity from geothermal energy.

The decomposition of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) with simultaneous hydrogen (H2) generation offers a promising alternative solution for energy requirements. Research has shown that hydrogen sulfide in geothermal resources can significantly and economically contribute to the process of hydrogen generation. This process not only provides a sustainable energy production option but also helps in environmental pollution abatement.

Geothermal plants emit fewer greenhouse gases than fossil fuels

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the Earth's surface. The most widely developed type of geothermal power plant, known as hydrothermal plants, are located near geological "hot spots" where molten rock close to the Earth's crust produces hot water.

Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity and are therefore much cleaner than fossil fuel power plants. However, they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide. These emissions are significantly lower than those of fossil fuel power plants of a similar size. Geothermal power plants emit 97% less acid rain-causing sulfur compounds and about 99% less carbon dioxide. They use scrubbers to remove the hydrogen sulfide naturally found in geothermal reservoirs.

Open-loop geothermal systems release approximately 10% carbon dioxide and a smaller amount of methane, a potent global warming gas. However, closed-loop systems do not release these gases into the atmosphere. Instead, the geothermal steam and water used are injected back into the earth. This recycling helps renew the geothermal resource and reduce emissions.

The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used and converted into energy. Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have almost no negative effects on the environment. They can positively impact the environment by reducing the use of energy sources with negative effects. Additionally, most geothermal plants can use either geothermal fluid or freshwater for cooling, and the use of geothermal fluids reduces the overall water impact.

Frequently asked questions