Geothermal Energy: Clean Power Source Or Polluter?

Geothermal energy is a clean and sustainable energy source with minimal environmental impact. It is a type of energy generated from the Earth's natural heat, accessed through hydrothermal energy (hot water or steam) or hot dry rock. Geothermal power plants use this geothermal energy to produce electricity, providing an alternative to traditional fossil fuel power plants. While geothermal energy production does release small amounts of gases such as carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, methane, and hydrogen sulfide, the emissions are significantly lower than those of fossil fuel plants. Additionally, geothermal plants re-inject wastewater to prevent land subsidence and contamination, addressing potential environmental concerns. Overall, geothermal energy is a promising renewable energy source that reduces negative environmental impacts and offers a cleaner alternative for electricity generation.

Geothermal energy is one of the cleanest forms of energy

There are three main processes for capturing geothermal energy: dry steam, flash steam, and binary cycle. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide. However, these emissions are significantly lower than those of fossil fuel power plants of similar size. Geothermal power plants emit 97% less sulfur compound and about 99% less carbon dioxide than fossil fuel plants.

The environmental impact of geothermal energy depends on the conversion and cooling technology used. Most geothermal plants can use either geothermal fluid or freshwater for cooling, with the use of geothermal fluids reducing the overall water impact. Closed-loop systems, which directly convert geothermal steam or hot water into electricity, are preferable to open-loop systems, as waste steam and gases are injected back into the ground rather than expelled into the atmosphere.

Enhanced geothermal systems (EGS), which require energy to drill and pump water into hot rock reservoirs, have higher life-cycle global warming emissions than natural geothermal systems. However, EGS still has significantly lower emissions than natural gas or coal-generated electricity. Overall, geothermal energy has minimal negative effects on the environment and can even have positive effects by reducing the use of more harmful energy sources.

Geothermal plants emit some gases, but in small amounts

Geothermal energy is a clean and sustainable energy source with minimal environmental impacts. It is a form of "earth heat" that uses the natural heat contained beneath the Earth's surface to generate electricity. While geothermal power plants do emit some gases, the amounts are significantly smaller compared to other energy sources.

The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is converted into useful energy. Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have negligible negative effects on the environment. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide, carbon dioxide, methane, and hydrogen sulfide. However, the emissions from geothermal plants are much lower than those of fossil fuel plants of similar sizes. Geothermal power plants emit 97% less sulfur compounds and about 99% less carbon dioxide than fossil fuel power plants.

Hydrothermal energy, which utilizes naturally occurring hot water or steam, is the most widely developed form of geothermal energy. Geothermal plants use different technologies to convert this hydrothermal fluid into electricity, including dry steam, flash steam, and binary cycle systems. These systems can either be open-loop or closed-loop. Open-loop systems release waste steam and gases into the atmosphere, while closed-loop systems inject them back into the ground, minimizing environmental impacts.

Enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) are another type of geothermal technology that requires drilling and pumping water into hot rock reservoirs. While EGS has higher life-cycle global warming emissions compared to hydrothermal systems, it still emits significantly less carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases than natural gas and coal-generated electricity. Land subsidence is another potential issue with geothermal plants, but this can be mitigated by re-injecting wastewater back into the geothermal reservoirs.

Overall, while geothermal plants do emit some gases, the amounts are relatively small compared to other energy sources. Geothermal energy is considered one of the cleanest forms of energy available today for electricity generation.

Hydrogen sulfide is the most concerning pollutant

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the Earth's surface. Hydrothermal energy (trapped hot water or steam) is the only type of geothermal energy that has been widely developed. Commercial electricity is produced by using geothermally heated fluid to turn a turbine connected to a generator. The fluid may be naturally occurring steam or water, or another fluid that has had geothermal heat transferred to it through a heat exchange system.

The environmental effects of geothermal energy depend on how it is used or converted. Direct-use applications and geothermal heat pumps have almost no negative effects on the environment. In fact, they can have a positive effect by reducing the use of energy sources that negatively impact the environment. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide.

Geothermal power plants emit 97% less acid rain-causing sulfur compound and about 99% less carbon dioxide than fossil fuel plants of a similar size. However, hydrogen sulfide is the most concerning pollutant emitted by geothermal energy. Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is a toxic and corrosive gas that occurs naturally in geothermal reservoirs. It is also produced by sulfate-reducing microorganisms that decompose organic matter in the absence of oxygen. The presence of H2S in the air, water, soils, and vegetation is one of the main environmental concerns for geothermal fields.

To address this issue, geothermal power plants use scrubbers to remove hydrogen sulfide from their reservoirs. A new method to remove hydrogen sulfide from geothermal fluids during well operation was tested in situ at a geothermal site in Vienna, Austria. For this purpose, ferric iron was added either as granulated iron hydroxide or as an FeCl3 solution into a reaction vessel containing the thermal water directly removed from the wells. It was found that the sulfide was fully removed from the water by both iron additives.

Geothermal plants require lots of water for cooling

Geothermal energy is heat contained below the earth's surface. Hydrothermal energy (trapped hot water or steam) is the only type of geothermal energy that has been widely developed for commercial electricity production. Geothermal power plants do not burn fuel to generate electricity, but they may release small amounts of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide.

Geothermal plants require water for cooling and re-injection. All U.S. geothermal power facilities use wet-recirculating technology with cooling towers. Depending on the cooling technology used, geothermal plants can require between 1,700 and 4,000 gallons of water per megawatt-hour. However, most geothermal plants can use either geothermal fluid or freshwater for cooling; using geothermal fluids rather than freshwater reduces the plant's overall water impact.

The amount of water wasted in the geothermal process is dependent on the plant type and the type/temperature of the resource. Plants based on organic Rankine cycle technology have very minimal water loss (<1%). On the other hand, plants based on flash steam turbine technology can have much higher water losses due to evaporation to condense the water enough for reinjection (~20%).

Open-loop systems expel waste steam and gases into the atmosphere and generally have greater environmental impacts than closed-loop systems. In closed-loop systems, the heat transfer fluid does not come into direct contact with the earth. Instead, it circulates through piping installed in the earth to a heat exchanger and back to the earth in a completely closed loop.

Most geothermal plants re-inject water into the reservoir after it has been used to prevent contamination and land subsidence. However, not all water removed from the reservoir is re-injected because some is lost as steam. To maintain a constant volume of water in the reservoir, outside water must be used.

Land subsidence can be caused by water removal

Geothermal energy is a clean and sustainable energy source that has the potential to provide substantial benefits for our climate, health, and economy. However, like any other form of energy generation, it has its own set of environmental impacts. One of the concerns associated with geothermal energy is land subsidence, which is the lowering of land-surface elevation due to changes that take place underground.

Land subsidence can occur when water is removed from geothermal reservoirs during the energy generation process. This removal of water can cause the land surface to sink or subside. In most cases, geothermal facilities address this risk by re-injecting wastewater back into the geothermal reservoirs after capturing its heat. This practice helps to maintain the structural integrity of the land and prevent land subsidence.

However, in some instances, not all the water removed from the reservoir is re-injected due to some being lost as steam. This partial re-injection can lead to a net loss of water from the reservoir, potentially contributing to land subsidence. To compensate for this loss and maintain a constant volume of water in the reservoir, external water sources may be introduced.

Land subsidence caused by water removal is not limited to geothermal energy sites. It is a widespread issue that affects various regions, particularly those with intensive agricultural practices or high population densities. For example, long-term groundwater extraction for irrigation has led to significant land subsidence in California's San Joaquin Valley, causing damage to buildings, aqueducts, well casings, bridges, and highways.

The impact of land subsidence can be severe, resulting in millions of dollars in damage and long-term environmental consequences. It can also exacerbate flooding and cause problems with sewer lines and storm drainage systems. Additionally, land subsidence can lead to the formation of fissures and sinkholes, posing risks to infrastructure and human safety.

Frequently asked questions