Gasoline Vs Diesel: Which Pollutes Our Air More?

The global gasoline and diesel vehicle fleets have a substantial impact on air quality, human health, and climate change. While gasoline is a toxic and highly flammable liquid that contributes to air pollution through vapors and the substances produced when burned, diesel vehicles have recently been found to cause over four times the pollution of petrol cars. Diesel engines produce toxic emissions that are immediately harmful to humans, and the fine particulate matter (PM) they emit causes cancer and acute respiratory issues.

Diesel vehicles produce more toxic emissions than petrol cars

Diesel engines are "lean-burn", meaning they use less fuel and more air to achieve the same performance as a petrol engine. While diesel fuel contains slightly more carbon per litre than petrol, overall CO2 emissions from diesel cars tend to be lower. However, diesel engines produce more toxic nitrogen dioxide, making diesel one of the main sources of this harmful gas.

In a petrol car, toxic emissions can be cleaned up by a three-way catalytic converter, so it emits around 30% less nitrogen oxide than a diesel car without after-treatment. Long-term exposure to nitric oxide can increase the risk of respiratory problems, so these emissions are regulated. The fine particulate matter that diesel engines produce also causes cancer and has acute respiratory effects.

Particulate filters in car exhausts can reduce particulate matter emissions by more than 90%require good operating conditions and regular maintenance. Diesel engine manufacturers have had to resort to these technologies to achieve emissions standards, but they tend to clog up with urban driving. By contrast, petrol emissions systems regulate themselves, needing less driver input.

It seems likely that to tackle the problem of toxic emissions, governments will eventually have to start banning vehicles with internal combustion engines altogether, initially in urban areas. For most cars built over the past 20 years, petrol is likely to be less polluting overall than diesel.

Gasoline leaks from vehicles and pipelines contribute to air pollution

Gasoline is a highly flammable and toxic liquid that significantly contributes to air pollution. The vapors released when gasoline evaporates, as well as the substances produced when it is burned, such as carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and unburned hydrocarbons, all contribute to air pollution. Additionally, burning gasoline releases carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas, into the atmosphere.

Gasoline leaks from vehicles and pipelines further contribute to air pollution. These leaks are a common occurrence at gas stations, as gasoline can drip from the nozzle onto the ground, and vapors can escape from open gas tanks. Leaks can also happen in pipelines and underground storage tanks, often going unnoticed. The Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 addressed these issues by mandating cleaner-burning reformulated gasoline to reduce air pollution in metropolitan areas with high ground-level ozone pollution.

To comply with the Clean Air Act, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) implemented several measures to reduce pollution from gasoline use. These included mandating emissions-control devices and cleaner-burning engines for passenger vehicles, as well as establishing emissions standards for other vehicle types and engines in gasoline-burning, non-road equipment. The EPA also banned leaded gasoline due to its adverse health effects, replacing it with catalytic converters to minimize toxic air pollutants.

Despite these efforts, gasoline leaks continue to be a significant source of air pollution. Leaking gas infrastructure, including pipelines and storage tanks, can create emissions hotspots and negatively impact public health, particularly in disadvantaged areas. The transition away from gasoline dependence is crucial for improving air quality and mitigating the climate crisis.

When comparing gasoline to diesel, it is important to note that diesel vehicles have recently been scrutinized for producing more toxic emissions. Studies indicate that diesel vehicles generate over four times the pollution of petrol cars, leading some governments to consider restrictions or bans in urban areas. However, it is worth mentioning that diesel engines were once promoted as a more environmentally friendly alternative due to their lower carbon dioxide emissions.

Diesel engines produce more nitrogen oxides than petrol engines

NOx gases include nitrogen dioxide (NO2), nitrous oxide (N2O), and nitric oxide (NO). These gases have harmful effects on human health and the environment. For example, NO2 is a major pollutant and component of smog, contributing to respiratory problems, acid rain, and tropospheric ozone depletion. Long-term exposure to nitric oxide (NO) can also increase the risk of respiratory issues.

While diesel vehicles have been promoted as a more environmentally friendly alternative due to their lower carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, the focus on CO2 reduction has come at the cost of addressing toxic emissions. Diesel engines produce more fine particulate matter (PM), which has acute respiratory effects and is a carcinogen. The higher levels of NOx and PM emissions from diesel engines have led to concerns about their impact on human health, with some governments considering restrictions or bans on diesel vehicles in urban areas.

It is worth noting that the comparison between diesel and petrol engines is complex, and other factors, such as vehicle type, speed, and maintenance, also influence pollution levels. However, the higher NOx emissions from diesel engines remain a significant factor in air pollution and human health considerations.

Gasoline is a toxic, highly flammable liquid

Gasoline, or petrol, is a toxic and highly flammable liquid. It is a human-made substance primarily used to fuel vehicles and other machines with engines, such as small aircraft, boats, and construction equipment. At room temperature, gasoline is usually colorless, pale brown, or pale pink. It is comprised of hydrocarbon compounds, including alkanes, benzene, toluene, and xylenes.

The toxicity of gasoline poses significant health risks. Ingesting even a small amount can be fatal, and exposure to gasoline or its vapors can cause serious health complications. Hydrocarbons entering the bloodstream can reduce the functioning of the central nervous system and cause organ damage. Additionally, skin, eye, and lung damage can occur when coming into contact with gasoline liquid or its fumes. The vapors released during evaporation and the substances produced when gasoline is burned, such as carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and unburned hydrocarbons, contribute to air pollution.

The highly flammable nature of gasoline poses safety concerns. Gasoline has a low flashpoint, allowing it to ignite at normal working temperatures, and it can be lit with a match at temperatures as low as -45°F (-42.78°C). Its autoignition temperature is 536°F (280°C). The boiling point of gasoline, or the temperature at which it vaporizes, is initially 95°F (35°C) at atmospheric pressure, but it can vary with altitude and atmospheric pressure.

Due to the hazardous nature of gasoline, specific precautions must be taken in the event of a spill or leak. The immediate area should be isolated for a minimum of 50 meters (150 feet) in all directions, and all ignition sources, including smoking, flares, sparks, or flames, must be eliminated. Spilled gasoline should not be touched or walked through, and any contaminated clothing should be removed immediately. In the case of eye contact, immediate irrigation with large amounts of water is necessary. If there is suspected gasoline exposure or poisoning, individuals in the United States are advised to call Poison Control at 800-222-1222 for care instructions.

Diesel vehicles are more polluting than petrol vehicles

Diesel engines produce nitrogen oxides (NOx), which include the toxic nitrogen dioxide (NO2), nitrous oxide (N2O), and nitric oxide (NO), which reacts with oxygen to form NO2. Petrol cars can reduce these emissions by around 30% through the use of three-way catalytic converters. Long-term exposure to nitric oxide can increase the risk of respiratory problems, and the fine particulate matter (PM) produced by diesel engines has been linked to cancer and acute respiratory issues.

Particulate filters in car exhausts can reduce PM emissions by more than 90%, but they require optimal operating conditions and regular maintenance. However, these filters tend to clog when used mainly for urban driving, and the latest emissions technology requires the addition of a urea mixture to the engine, which is more convenient for petrol engines that regulate themselves.

While diesel engines produce slightly more carbon per litre than petrol engines, diesel vehicles were previously promoted as a more environmentally friendly alternative due to their lower overall CO2 emissions. This focus on reducing CO2 emissions, however, has come at the cost of ignoring other harmful compounds, such as toxic emissions, produced by diesel engines.

The negative impact of diesel emissions on air quality, human health, and climate change is significant. Diesel engines contribute to the production of ground-level ozone, which damages vegetation, and acid rain, which affects soil, water sources, and the human food chain. As a result, some governments are planning to discourage the use of diesel vehicles or even ban them from urban areas.

Frequently asked questions