Fracking's Impact: Is Our Water Table Safe?

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, is a popular technique used to extract oil and gas by cracking shale rock deep underground. It is particularly prevalent in the United States, with thousands of wells across the American West and California. The process has been the subject of intense controversy, with concerns raised about its potential impact on water quality and public health. While some studies and government organizations have found evidence of water contamination due to fracking, others maintain that it does not pose a significant risk to water sources. The complex nature of groundwater investigations related to fracking and the presence of exotic compounds used in the process add to the challenge of understanding its full environmental and health implications.

Fracking contaminates water with harmful chemicals

There is a lot of controversy surrounding the topic of fracking and its impact on water pollution. While some studies and organizations have claimed that fracking contaminates water with harmful chemicals, others refute these claims, stating that there is no evidence of groundwater contamination.

One of the main concerns regarding fracking and water pollution is the potential contamination of groundwater, which is a crucial source of drinking water for many communities. In 2024, a study by former EPA scientist Dominic DiGiulio found that fracking had polluted groundwater in Wyoming, specifically in Pavillion. DiGiulio's research detected the presence of toxic chemicals and methanol in the Pavillion aquifer, indicating possible contamination by fracking fluids. Methanol, a simple alcohol, can cause permanent nerve damage and blindness if consumed in sufficient quantities. However, it should be noted that methanol degrades rapidly, and commercial labs often lack the protocols to detect small traces of this chemical.

In addition to the Pavillion case, there have been other instances where fracking has been linked to water contamination. For example, a study by Elaine Hill, Ph.D., and Lala Ma, Ph.D., published in the Journal of Health Economics, linked shale gas development to the pollution of public water supplies and negative impacts on infant health. Their research found that drilling near an infant's public water source was associated with poorer birth outcomes and an increase in fracking-related contaminants in public drinking water. The study specifically noted an 11-13% increase in the incidence of preterm births and low birth weight in infants exposed during gestation.

Furthermore, the process of hydraulic fracturing requires the use of various chemicals, such as acid mixed with water to dissolve portions of oil-bearing rock formations. The extensive equipment used in fracking, including high-pressure pumps and storage tanks for chemicals and wastewater, also poses a risk of contamination if not properly managed. The oil and gas industry generates billions of gallons of wastewater annually, which can contain toxic hydrocarbons, heavy metals, salts, and even radioactive materials.

However, despite these concerns, several organizations and studies have found no evidence of groundwater contamination due to fracking. For example, the United States Geological Survey (USGS) in 2017 concluded that unconventional oil and gas operations, including fracking, did not affect drinking water quality. Similarly, studies by Duke University (2017), the University of Cincinnati (2016), and the University of Texas-Austin (2016) found no indication of groundwater contamination over their respective study periods. While the debate continues, it is essential to consider the potential risks and impacts of fracking on water quality and to advocate for stricter environmental regulations to protect public health and natural resources.

Fracking causes birth defects and impacts infant health

Fracking is a popular technique used to extract oil and gas by cracking shale rock deep underground. However, it is also controversial, as it involves pumping water and chemicals at high pressure into the wells being drilled, and there are concerns that it may contaminate drinking water sources and negatively impact human health.

A recent study published in the Journal of Health Economics has found evidence that fracking impacts drinking water quality and infant health. The study, which focused on the geographic expansion of shale gas drilling in Pennsylvania from 2006 to 2015, found that drilling near an infant's public water source yielded poorer birth outcomes and more fracking-related contaminants in public drinking water. Specifically, the study found that every new well drilled within one kilometer of a public drinking water source was associated with an 11-13% increase in the incidence of preterm births and low birth weight in infants exposed during gestation. These findings are consistent with previous research, which has also found links between shale gas development and drinking water quality, as well as reproductive health and subsequent impacts on childhood health and development.

In addition to the risks posed to drinking water sources, fracking also releases chemicals into the air and contributes to noise and light pollution, which can also have negative health impacts on nearby communities. A two-year investigation by Environmental Health Perspectives examined the severe mental, physical, and social toll of fracking on communities in Pennsylvania. The authors of this study emphasized the need for better regulations on the fracking industry to protect public health.

While the specific mechanisms are still being investigated, there is growing evidence that exposure to environmentally hazardous chemicals during pregnancy may increase the risk of birth defects. A study of birth defects and hydraulic fracturing activities in the Barnett Shale region of Texas found that the risks of specific birth defects, including atrial septal defect (ASD), ventricular septal defect (VSD), and patent ductus arteriosus (PDA), were significantly higher in counties with high hydraulic fracturing activities. These defects can have serious and sometimes lifelong impacts on the health and well-being of affected infants and children.

Overall, the weight of evidence suggests that fracking can indeed cause birth defects and impact infant health, underscoring the need for stricter environmental regulations and public health protections.

Fracking contaminates water with heavy metals and radioactivity

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, is a technique used to extract natural gas or oil from shale and other forms of "tight" rock. This is done by injecting water into the ground at high pressure, cracking the rock and releasing the valuable hydrocarbons.

This process produces billions of gallons of wastewater each year, which can enter and contaminate the environment in several ways. For instance, during transportation, storage, or treatment. Even the recycling of wastewater poses a threat as it generates concentrated waste products, including a by-product called TENORM (technologically enhanced naturally occurring radioactive material).

Fracking releases naturally occurring heavy metals and radioactive materials from shale deposits, and these substances return to the surface with flowback, or wastewater. This wastewater is often stored in open pits, which can spill, leak, and emit air pollution.

In a 2013 study, researchers found high levels of radioactivity, salts, and metals in the water and sediments downstream from a fracking wastewater plant on Blacklick Creek in western Pennsylvania. The concentrations of radium detected were higher than those found in some radioactive waste dumps and exceeded the federal government's minimum threshold for a disposal site to be considered a radioactive dump site.

While some studies have found no evidence of groundwater contamination from fracking, other research has linked fracking to drinking water pollution and negative impacts on infant health, including an increase in preterm births and low birth weight.

Fracking is regulated by stringent rules to protect water sources

While fracking has been linked to water contamination, there are stringent rules in place to protect water sources. Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is a technique used to extract natural gas or oil from shale and other forms of "tight" rock. This is done by injecting high-pressure water, sand, and chemicals into the ground, creating small fractures in the rock that allow gas and oil to flow more freely to production wells.

In the United States, several federal regulations aim to protect water resources from the impacts of fracking. The Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) regulates the injection of fluids underground to prevent the contamination of drinking water sources. The Clean Water Act (CWA) governs the discharge of pollutants into surface waters, ensuring that fracking operations do not degrade water quality. State governments also play a crucial role in regulating fracking activities, with states like Colorado and Pennsylvania implementing specific regulations to address water usage, chemical disclosure, and well integrity. These state-level regulations often complement federal laws, providing a comprehensive framework for protecting water resources.

To ensure compliance with regulations, fines can be imposed on fracking operators who do not comply. Additionally, they may be required to compensate for pollution incidents, such as by supplying water to affected communities. Well integrity monitoring, groundwater quality monitoring, and taxes for long-term monitoring after well decommissioning are also important tools for protecting water resources.

Internationally, regulations to protect groundwater from contamination during fracking are crucial, especially in water-scarce countries like South Africa. However, the lack of a clear regulatory framework in some countries has limited the development of the oil and gas industry.

While regulations exist to protect water sources, some studies have found increased levels of harmful chemicals in water near fracking sites, suggesting that further monitoring may be necessary. Additionally, there are concerns about loopholes in regulations, such as the "Halliburton loophole," which exempts hydraulic fracturing from certain regulations under the Safe Drinking Water Act unless diesel is used in the fracking fluid.

Fracking causes earthquakes

While most induced earthquakes are not directly caused by fracking, the process can cause small earthquakes or tremors. These tremors are produced by the same processes that could create large, damaging earthquakes. The recent increase in earthquakes in the central United States, especially in Oklahoma, has been linked to the injection of large volumes of saltwater, a byproduct of oil and gas extraction. Wastewater disposal wells typically operate for longer durations and inject much more fluid than is injected during the hydraulic fracturing process, making them more likely to induce earthquakes.

In Oklahoma, which has the most induced earthquakes in the United States, 2% of earthquakes can be linked to hydraulic fracturing operations. The largest earthquake known to be induced by hydraulic fracturing in the United States was a magnitude 4.0 earthquake that occurred in 2018 in Texas. However, it is important to note that reports of hydraulic fracturing causing felt earthquakes are extremely rare. Wastewater produced by wells that have been hydraulically fractured can cause "induced" earthquakes when injected into deep wastewater wells. Wastewater injection can raise pressure levels in rock formations over much longer periods and across larger areas than hydraulic fracturing, making it more likely to induce earthquakes.

To determine the origin of the tremors, researchers used seismometers installed around a fracking site in Wellington, Kansas. The data covered the entire fracking injection period of six months, as well as a month before and after the injections. After discarding the background noise, the team found that the remaining signals were generated below ground and only appeared while the fluid injections were occurring. This confirmed that fracking causes slow, small earthquakes or tremors, whose origin was previously unknown to scientists.

Frequently asked questions