Carlsbad's New Power Plant: Pollution Reaches Encinitas

The Encina Power Station in Carlsbad, California, was retired in 2018, and its demolition was completed by the second quarter of 2022. The power plant was constructed in 1954 and expanded in 1978 to include a 400-foot smokestack. It was one of the major electricity suppliers for the region, serving up to 1 million San Diegans at its peak. The retirement and demolition of the power plant were due to its environmental toll, particularly the destruction of marine life and pollution caused by its operations. The new power plant, known as the Carlsbad Energy Center, is designed to be more environmentally friendly and efficient, addressing the concerns of local homeowners and environmentalists. The question remains whether the pollution from the new power plant in Carlsbad affects the Encinitas area, and if so, to what extent.

The Carlsbad power plant's environmental impact

The Carlsbad Energy Center, a new power plant in Carlsbad, California, has replaced the Encina Power Station, which was retired in 2018. The new power plant has been designed to be more environmentally friendly and efficient than its predecessor.

The Encina Power Station, constructed in 1954, was a large natural gas and oil-fuelled electricity-generating plant. It was one of the major electricity suppliers for the region, serving up to 1 million San Diegans at its peak. However, it drew criticism for its environmental impact, particularly its ocean water intakes, which destroyed marine life. California regulators called for its shutdown by the end of 2017, citing serious environmental concerns.

The new Carlsbad Energy Center is a more modern facility that has addressed some of the environmental issues associated with the Encina Power Station. It is a gas-fired power plant that uses air cooling instead of ocean water cooling, reducing its impact on marine life. The new plant is also designed to be more efficient, with the ability to ramp up within 10 minutes, compared to the 18 hours needed by the old boilers.

Despite the improvements, some critics argue that the new power plant still relies on fossil fuels, which have their own environmental impacts. The burning of natural gas releases pollutants into the atmosphere, and the new plant also injects ammonia into smokestacks to neutralise nitrogen oxides, another pollutant. While this helps to limit smog, ammonia can turn into particles that contribute to air pollution and have been linked to health issues such as stroke, respiratory problems, and low birth weight in babies.

The decision to build the new power plant in Carlsbad was influenced by the closure of the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station in 2012, which created an increased need for power generation in Southern California. The new plant has been designed as a peaking power plant, used during periods of high demand, and is expected to run about 15% of the time. While this reduces its overall emissions, critics argue that cleaner alternatives, such as battery storage, should have been considered instead of building a new fossil fuel-based plant.

Encina Power Station's pollution of the ocean

The Encina Power Station (EPS) was a large natural gas and oil-fuelled electricity-generating plant in Carlsbad, California. Constructed in 1954, it was retired on December 11, 2018, and officially stopped operations. The plant was owned by NRG Energy, which agreed to tear down the old plant within three years of its retirement, at no cost to taxpayers.

EPS sat on the southern shore of the outer segment of Agua Hedionda Lagoon, which is attached to the ocean and other waterways through rising tide levels and small creeks. The lagoon was once a stinking pool at low tide due to the development of Highway 101, but it was opened to a continuous tidal flow to create a cooling system for the plant. The lagoon was home to a diverse range of aquatic life, including blue herons and ibises, and it served as the plant's source of once-through cooling.

The Encina Wastewater Authority (EWA) is a public agency that provides wastewater treatment services to over 379,000 residents in North San Diego County, including Carlsbad. EWA is owned by six public agencies and governed by a Joint Powers Authority (JPA). The Encina Water Pollution Control Facility (EWPCF), originally constructed in 1965, is a key component of EWA's operations. It has undergone several major expansions and improvements over the years to enhance the quality of treated water, improve odour control, and increase treatment capacity to 43.3 million gallons per day (MGD).

While there is no direct information available on the impact of EPS's pollution on the Encinitas area, it is likely that any pollution from the plant could have affected the nearby ocean and surrounding waterways, including the Encinitas area. However, with the retirement of EPS and the implementation of more stringent environmental regulations, the risk of pollution impacting the ocean and surrounding areas has been significantly reduced.

The Carlsbad Energy Center's ammonia emissions

The Carlsbad Energy Center is a 527-megawatt natural gas-fired power plant in Carlsbad, San Diego County, California. The plant was built to replace the Encina Power Station, a large natural gas and oil-fuelled electricity-generating plant that was retired in December 2018. The Carlsbad Energy Center began commercial operations in December 2019.

The Carlsbad Energy Center adds one particular contaminant to the air that has received little attention—ammonia. Ammonia is injected into the smokestacks to neutralise nitrogen oxides, a different pollutant. The ammonia is a smog-limiting device. If the plant runs just 6% of the time, it will release an estimated 17,446 pounds of ammonia per year, according to state documents. This would make it the largest industrial emitter of ammonia in the county. The next largest emitter, the Point Loma wastewater treatment facility, emits less than half of that amount.

Ammonia can turn into particles, and particle pollution is linked to a long list of health problems, including stroke, respiratory issues, and low birth weight in babies. While San Diego air officials believe the local air is unlikely to convert the ammonia into hazardous particles, the compound is not well-studied. Kimberly Prather, a particle expert at UCSD, notes that ammonia is the only small particle-making molecule that is not regulated.

The Carlsbad Energy Center is projected to be much cleaner than the Encina Power Station, which operated from 1954 until 2018. Compared to other peaker plants in the San Diego region, the Carlsbad Energy Center is expected to be the cleanest in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, with half a metric ton per megawatt-hour. However, some people believe that the correct comparison is with the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, a source of carbon-free energy until its sudden closure in 2012.

Carlsbad's future energy sources

Carlsbad, California has a long history with the oil and gas industry, and the city has traditionally relied on fossil fuels for its energy. However, Carlsbad's energy landscape is changing, with a shift towards cleaner and more sustainable energy sources.

The Retirement of the Encina Power Station

The Encina Power Station (EPS), a large natural gas and oil-fuelled electricity-generating plant, was one of the major suppliers of electricity for Carlsbad and the wider region. Constructed in 1954, the plant was put into “retired” status and officially stopped operations on December 11, 2018. The retirement of the EPS marked a significant turning point for Carlsbad's energy future, as the city began to explore more environmentally friendly alternatives.

The Carlsbad Energy Center Project

The Carlsbad Energy Center Project is a 527.5-megawatt gas-fired power project that began commercial operation in December 2019. The project is currently active and is owned by Clearway Energy. The Carlsbad Energy Center is located on the site of the former EPS and is designed to be more environmentally friendly and lower profile, addressing some of the concerns raised by the local community and environmentalists.

Future Energy Sources for Carlsbad

While natural gas continues to play a significant role in Carlsbad's energy mix, there is a growing recognition of the need for cleaner and more sustainable energy sources. The city has positioned itself as a hub for energy innovation and collaboration, hosting annual summits to foster dialogue, education, and strategic planning.

One area of focus for Carlsbad's future energy sources is renewable energy, such as solar and wind power. The proliferation of rooftop solar in the region and the development of new power plants that utilize air cooling instead of ocean water for cooling are positive steps towards a more sustainable energy future.

Additionally, the city is exploring alternatives to traditional peaker plants, which are power units designed to turn on during periods of high demand. The use of battery storage and other clean energy technologies is being considered as a potential alternative to gas-burning turbines. While there are concerns about the cost and effectiveness of battery storage, it is an area of active discussion and development.

In conclusion, Carlsbad's future energy sources are likely to be a mix of natural gas and renewable energy, with a continued focus on innovation and sustainability. The city's commitment to fostering economic growth, supporting industry development, and enhancing the quality of life for its residents will shape its energy decisions in the years to come.

Carlsbad's tourist-serving, commercial and open space plans

Carlsbad, California, has a strong commitment to preserving open space to ensure an excellent quality of life for its residents. In 1986, Carlsbad residents voted to approve the Growth Management Plan, which ensures that ample land will be set aside as permanent open space.

The city's General Plan, approved by the City Council in 2015, calls for a mix of open space and visitor-serving commercial uses on the site of the retired Encina Power Station. The plan envisions visitor-serving commercial and open space uses to provide residents and visitors with enhanced opportunities for coastal access and services, reflecting the California Coastal Act's goal of "maximizing public access to the coast".

The city has also approved the Robertson Ranch Master Plan, which will add approximately 140 acres of open space to the Calavera Nature Preserve, increasing the preserve's area by more than 50%. The plan includes the creation of a contiguous open space corridor that stretches from Agua Hedionda to Lake Calavera, as well as hiking and walking trails for the public to enjoy.

Carlsbad is also working on adapting its plans to better meet the community's future parks and recreation needs, including improving traffic flow and expanding the trails system. The latest budget includes projects to improve efficiency and community connection through technology, such as installing free public Wi-Fi at city parks and community centers.

The city's commitment to open space is recognized as one of the highest in the region, with nearly 80% of the existing preserved open space in Carlsbad being "natural open space". The city has also committed to setting aside significantly more open space than its neighboring cities, in some cases more than double.

In addition to its focus on open space, Carlsbad is also experiencing new investment in the city, including new corporate headquarters and major hotel, retail, and commercial projects, which will strengthen the local economy and bring new jobs to the area.

Frequently asked questions