Asphalt's Impact On Water: Pollution And Environmental Concerns

Asphalt is a ubiquitous material used in roads, roofs, and driveways. While asphalt carries the smallest carbon footprint of all paving types, there are concerns about its impact on the environment, particularly water pollution. Some sources claim that asphalt does not dissolve in water nor does it leach chemicals into the soil. However, other sources claim that asphalt can contaminate nearby water sources, adversely affect biodiversity, and cause cancer.

Does Asphalt Pollute Water?

Asphalt millings can be toxic and pollute water sources

Asphalt millings are somewhat toxic. They can sometimes leach toxic substances like polycyclic hydrocarbons or lead but not in large amounts. Although the amount of these substances is usually quite low, it’s still a cause of concern and can pollute water and the surrounding environment. Polycyclic hydrocarbons are toxic to marine life and can negatively impact development, increase the risk of cancer, and affect bone health and hormones. Lead is toxic to humans and can negatively impact the growth and development of plants and animals.

Research has found that regular asphalt can release VOCs, which are potent air polluters. The higher the temperature, the more compounds are released. However, since there is less asphalt in asphalt millings, they emit fewer VOCs. Asphalt millings can leach into the soil, which can then enter water sources.

Asphalt millings are porous and permeable, which means that water can slowly drain through to the soil underneath, reducing the risk of flooding. These types of pavements may even cut down on the spread of pollution as they can trap hazardous substances and stop them from spreading further. However, without a pavement top surface, asphalt millings can migrate due to intense weather conditions or heavy use, contaminating new environments. For example, the bitumen binder used in asphalt paving contains polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, which are pollutants. These compounds are carcinogenic and toxic to marine life.

While asphalt millings can be somewhat toxic and pollute water sources, it is important to note that research has also found that asphalt millings did not leach trace elements in amounts exceeding EPA standards for drinking water. In addition, asphalt millings are made from recycled asphalt, reducing waste and the need for old asphalt pavement to be sent to a landfill.

Asphalt is non-toxic and safe to use as construction fill

There is a common misconception that asphalt is harmful to the environment. While it is true that asphalt can contribute to air pollution and soil contamination, it is not as harmful to water sources as some believe. In fact, asphalt is non-toxic and safe to use as construction fill.

Asphalt is a near-ubiquitous substance, found in roads, on roofs, and in driveways. However, its chemical emissions rarely figure into urban air quality management plans. Some people believe that asphalt releases toxic chemicals, but this is not true. Asphalt is so non-toxic that it is frequently used in fish hatcheries as a barrier to keep out contaminants from hazardous landfills. It is important to note that asphalt does not dissolve in water and does not leach chemicals into the soil. Most of the contamination blamed on asphalt is actually the result of human carelessness, such as trash left in parking lots or waste that is improperly disposed of.

Asphalt millings are somewhat toxic and can sometimes leach toxic substances like polycyclic hydrocarbons or lead, but not in large amounts. The amount of these substances is usually quite low and is not considered a significant risk. However, it is still a cause for concern as it can pollute water and the surrounding environment. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are toxic to marine life and can negatively impact development, increase the risk of cancer, and affect bone health and hormones.

Research has also found that asphalt millings did not leach trace elements in amounts exceeding EPA standards for drinking water. Asphalt millings are permeable, which can help to prevent flooding and curb pollution. However, some people choose to seal asphalt millings, which can impact their permeability. These seals can contain coal tar or acrylic, which are not renewable resources and can cause pollution.

In summary, asphalt is a safe and non-toxic substance that can be used as construction fill. While it may contribute to air pollution and soil contamination in some cases, it is not a significant source of water pollution. The main concerns with asphalt and water pollution are the potential for leaching of toxic substances into the surrounding environment and the impact of coal tar or acrylic seals on permeability. However, the amount of toxic substances leached is typically low, and asphalt millings are permeable, which helps to curb pollution.

Asphalt production plants can be a source of water pollution

Asphalt itself does not dissolve in water, and the contamination often associated with it may be due to human carelessness, such as trash left in parking lots or improper waste disposal. Nevertheless, the bitumen binder used in asphalt paving contains polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, which are pollutants. These can migrate due to intense weather conditions or heavy use, contaminating new environments.

The impact of asphalt on water pollution is a complex issue. While asphalt millings are more durable than gravel, the mining process required for gravel can cause water pollution and degrade riverbanks. Gravel is also permeable, which can help prevent flooding and curb pollution. However, driving on gravel can release silica dust, which is harmful to people and animals if inhaled.

Overall, while asphalt production plants can contribute to water pollution through the release of toxic substances, the paving industry has made significant efforts to reduce environmental impact, and much of the contamination associated with asphalt may be due to human factors rather than the inherent properties of the material itself.

Asphalt can contaminate water through human carelessness

While asphalt itself is not toxic and does not dissolve in water, human activities can cause asphalt to contaminate water sources. For instance, asphalt millings are somewhat toxic and can leach toxic substances like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and lead, which are harmful to marine life and can negatively impact human and animal development. PAHs are also carcinogenic.

Asphalt production plants are sometimes located within residential areas for convenience and proximity to construction sites. However, this can lead to the escape of heavy metals and bitumen during asphalt production, which can contaminate the surrounding soil and water sources. Aggregates used for asphalt production, such as gravel, crushed stones, rock dust, or powder, can contain varying concentrations of heavy metals.

In addition, human carelessness, such as littering in parking lots, leaking gas and oil from cars, and improper waste disposal, can lead to water contamination. These contaminants can then be washed off from asphalt pavements and enter nearby water sources.

Furthermore, the recycling or storage of recycled asphalt materials has been shown to release trace elements such as heavy metals and organic compounds into groundwater and soil. Experiments have detected pollutants like Mn, Ni, and Pb in reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) samples, with Pb exceeding the US Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) drinking water standards.

To minimize the risk of water contamination, hot mix asphalt plants should not be built near water resources, and proper waste disposal and maintenance of vehicles should be practiced.

Asphalt is a source of air pollution

Asphalt is a significant source of air pollution, especially in hot and sunny places. A study by Yale University researchers found that asphalt emits a wide range of organic compounds, including hazardous pollutants, under a variety of temperature and solar conditions. The emissions from asphalt are highest on hot, sunny days, with total emissions doubling when the temperature rose from 40°C to 60°C, a typical temperature range for asphalt in a Californian summer. These emissions contain toxic carbon-based chemicals, often with 12 to 25 carbon atoms per molecule, which can have negative impacts on human health.

The researchers also found that asphalt-related products emit substantial and diverse mixtures of organic compounds into the air, with the rate of emissions depending on temperature and other environmental conditions. The emissions at summer temperatures eventually levelled out but continued at a steady rate, indicating that asphalt is a source of long-term, continuous emissions. The potential for asphalt to emit secondary organic aerosols (SOAs) is comparable to that of vehicles, making it a significant contributor to air pollution, especially in urban areas.

The compounds emitted by asphalt can lead to the formation of tiny particles called PM2.5, which are one of the most dangerous types of air pollution for human health. These particles are much smaller than the width of a human hair and can cause respiratory and heart problems, as well as potentially impacting birth outcomes and brain development in children. The effects of asphalt emissions on ozone formation are minimal compared to motor vehicles and volatile chemicals in personal care and cleaning products, but they still contribute to overall air pollution levels.

While the asphalt industry has claimed that pollution from applied asphalt is negligible, the findings of this study are important as most states and cities have focused on reducing combustion sources of air pollution, such as cars and power plants, while neglecting asphalt emissions. The researchers emphasised that more research is needed to understand the full extent of asphalt's contribution to air pollution and its interaction with other sources of pollution. However, the results suggest that finding ways to make roads more environmentally friendly is just as crucial as making cars and trucks more sustainable.

Frequently asked questions