Air Pollution's Transnational Impact: China And The Us

Air pollution is a pressing issue that affects countries worldwide, and China and the US are no exception. China, with its massive manufacturing industry and high population density, has some of the highest levels of particulate airborne pollution globally. This pollution doesn't respect borders, and recent studies have shown that it is spreading across the Pacific to the US, impacting air quality and human health in Western US states. The complex dynamics of cloud formation and international trade further influence the spread of pollution between the two countries. This issue highlights the interconnectedness of environmental challenges and the need for global cooperation to address them effectively.

China's air pollution is carried by winds to the US

China is the world's largest emitter of anthropogenic air pollutants, and its massive manufacturing industry has led to remarkably bad urban air quality. This has had tangible local effects, such as schools being forced to close, and an estimated 1.2 million premature deaths. However, the impact of China's air pollution is not limited to within its borders.

A combination of factors, including typical westerly wind flows and the outsourcing of manufacturing to China by the US, has resulted in the movement of air pollutants across the Pacific Ocean to the Western US. Studies have shown that on days with the strongest westerlies, which usually occur in the spring, between 12 and 24 percent of the sulfate-based air pollution over the Western US originated in China. This has led to an increase in the number of days where ozone levels exceed EPA standards for air quality, with negative consequences for public health and air quality standards.

The impact of China's air pollution on the US is not just a one-way street, however. American demand for cheap, manufactured goods fuels Chinese pollution in the first place. As Steve Davis of UC Irvine, a co-author of a study on the global spread of Chinese air pollution, stated: "We've outsourced our manufacturing and much of our pollution, but some of it is blowing back across the Pacific to haunt us." This complex dynamic between the two countries highlights the interconnected nature of international trade and its impact on global air pollution.

Furthermore, the US could be contributing to its own mercury pollution if it pushes through plans to scale up the export of coal to China. This would create a feedback loop of pollution exchange between the two countries, exacerbating the problem. Addressing this issue will require cooperation and a recognition of the shared responsibility for tackling air pollution.

US outsourcing manufacturing to China increases air pollution

The US outsourcing manufacturing to China has a complex effect on air pollution. While it has resulted in reduced air pollution in some regions of the US, it has simultaneously led to deteriorated air quality in other areas, particularly in the western United States. This is due to the combined effects of changes in emissions and atmospheric transport.

On the one hand, outsourcing manufacturing to China has resulted in a reduction in US emissions. By relocating manufacturing processes to China, the US has decreased its domestic production-based emissions. This has led to improved air quality in certain regions, particularly in the eastern United States.

However, on the other hand, the increased production and emissions in China have had a detrimental impact on air quality in the western United States. The manufacturing industry in China is massive, and it is responsible for a large portion of the country's air pollution. As the US outsources manufacturing to China, the enhanced transport of Chinese pollution blows back across the Pacific, affecting downwind areas in the western US.

Studies have found that measurable amounts of Chinese pollution are transported via the atmosphere to the western United States. This pollution includes particulate matter, sulfate-based pollution, carbon monoxide, and ground-level ozone. On days with strong prevailing winds, such as the Westerlies, between 12 and 24 percent of the sulfate-based air pollution and 4 to 6 percent of carbon monoxide over the Western US can be traced to China. This increase in pollution can have significant health impacts, with pollutants like black carbon linked to asthma, cancer, emphysema, and heart and lung disease.

Additionally, China's reliance on coal-burning power plants contributes significantly to its emissions. Coal is the dirtiest of all fossil fuels, and China depends on it for a substantial portion of its energy needs. This contributes to the high levels of particulate pollution in Chinese cities, which can have detrimental effects on human health.

In conclusion, while outsourcing manufacturing to China may provide economic benefits to the US, it comes at the cost of increased air pollution in certain regions, particularly in the western US. This complex issue highlights the interconnectedness of global trade and environmental impacts and it underscores the importance of international cooperation in addressing transboundary air pollution.

China's coal consumption impacts air quality

China's air pollution, largely resulting from its massive manufacturing industry and coal consumption, has been found to spread across the Pacific to the US. Research has shown that on days with strong prevailing winds, up to 24% of sulfate-based air pollution over the Western US originates from China. This has resulted in Los Angeles and other regions in the Eastern US experiencing additional days of non-compliance with the US ozone standard.

China's coal consumption significantly contributes to its air pollution, particularly in rural areas where many households rely on coal and other solid fuels for heating and cooking. While households account for only a small percentage of China's total coal consumption, their emissions are less filtered and thus have a disproportionately large impact on air quality. The burning of coal releases various air pollutants, including particulate matter, carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen dioxide, which have severe health impacts.

Recognizing the detrimental effects of coal consumption on air quality, China has implemented policies to reduce its usage. The 2013 Airborne Pollution Prevention and Control Action Plan identified coal as a key driver of air pollution and set caps on its consumption. In 2016, China released sub-plans under the Thirteenth Five-Year Plan, aiming to reduce coal's share of total energy consumption to 58% by 2020. These efforts reflect China's concrete steps to address air pollution stemming from coal burning.

The impact of China's coal consumption on air quality extends beyond its borders. Studies have shown that the transport of export-related Chinese pollution contributes to increased sulfate and ozone levels in the Western US. This is due to the outsourcing of manufacturing to China by US companies, which has led to enhanced transport of Chinese pollution across the Pacific. As a result, the US is experiencing the consequences of its demand for cheap products, fueling Chinese pollution that ultimately affects its own air quality.

In conclusion, China's coal consumption has significant impacts on air quality, both within the country and across the Pacific. The pollution resulting from China's coal usage contributes to detrimental health effects and environmental degradation. China's efforts to reduce coal consumption and implement policies to combat air pollution are essential steps towards improving air quality on a global scale.

US demand for cheap products fuels Chinese air pollution

Air pollution is a pressing issue in China, with the country being among the greatest emitters of air pollution worldwide. The country's massive manufacturing industry, which produces goods for foreign consumption, is a significant contributor to its poor air quality. This issue is not contained within China's borders, as detectable levels of pollution from China have been found in the United States.

While China is responsible for some of the pollution over the US, American demand for cheap products also fuels air pollution in China. The US has outsourced much of its manufacturing to China, taking advantage of the country's weaker environmental regulations and lower production costs. This outsourcing has led to increased pollution in China, as the energy needed to support China's economic growth and production of goods for export comes largely from the combustion of fossil fuels.

A study by researchers from both the US and China found that on days with strong westerly winds, between 12 and 24% of sulfate-based air pollution over the Western US originated in China. This pollution has had tangible impacts on US air quality, with Los Angeles experiencing an extra day of ozone levels exceeding EPA standards in 2006 due to Chinese pollution.

Another study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, traced much of the responsibility for Chinese pollution back to American consumers, who buy a large proportion of the goods manufactured in China. The study found that about a fifth of the man-made sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide, carbon monoxide, and black carbon over China were associated with products exported to the US. These pollutants have acute effects on human health and can drive the formation of acid rain.

While China has made commitments to address its air pollution problems and combat climate change, it remains to be seen whether it will meet these goals. In the meantime, the US's demand for cheap, manufactured goods continues to fuel Chinese air pollution, with consequences for both countries' air quality and the global climate.

Chinese New Year and sandstorms affect air pollution levels

Air pollution is a pressing global issue, with China being one of the greatest emitters of air pollution worldwide. This pollution not only affects China but also has far-reaching consequences, including in the United States. Certain events in China, such as sandstorms and Chinese New Year, have been found to impact air pollution levels both within the country and across borders.

Sandstorms are a common, naturally occurring source of air pollution in China, particularly in the northern, northwestern, and northeastern regions of the country. These sand and dust storms (SDS) originate mainly from the Gobi and Taklamakan deserts. During March and April 2023, three sandstorms affected an area with over 500 million people in China. The storms led to increased aerosol optical, microphysical, and radiative properties, with many cities north of the Yangtze River experiencing high daily average PM10 concentrations.

Chinese New Year, a 7-day national holiday, also influences air pollution levels. During this period, anthropogenic air pollution levels from industrial and vehicle emissions are lower. Studies have shown that Chinese New Year is associated with modest reductions in background air quality in the US, representing between 0.4 and 2.5% of PM levels.

The impact of these events on air pollution is not limited to China but extends across the Pacific Ocean to the US. Sandstorms have been linked to significant increases in background coarse and fine particulate matter (PM) in the US, contributing between 16 and 39% of average levels. The transport of export-related Chinese pollution, influenced by events like sandstorms, has been found to contribute to increased sulfate concentrations and ozone levels in the western US.

In summary, sandstorms and Chinese New Year impact air pollution levels within China and have transboundary effects, including on the western US. These events highlight the global nature of air pollution and the interconnectedness of emissions between countries. Understanding the dynamics of these events and their impact on pollution levels is crucial for addressing this pressing environmental and public health issue.

Frequently asked questions