Ethanol-Gasoline Mix: Reducing Air Pollution?

The use of ethanol as an additive to gasoline has been a topic of debate for environmentalists and researchers. Ethanol is a biofuel made from biomass feedstocks such as corn, barley, and sugar cane, and it has been added to gasoline to reduce air pollution. While some argue that ethanol reduces harmful tailpipe emissions, others claim that it increases air pollution and has negative impacts on the environment. The benefits and drawbacks of adding ethanol to gasoline are complex and depend on various factors, including vehicle type, engine calibration, blend level, and farming practices.

Does adding ethanol to gasoline reduce air pollution?

Ethanol's impact on air pollution reduction is dependent on the blend ratio with gasoline

Ethanol is often made from corn, switchgrass, or cellulose, and it can be grown and refined in the United States. One of the key arguments in favor of ethanol is that it helps gasoline burn more completely, reducing air pollution. Additionally, because the plants used to make ethanol absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, ethanol does not add additional greenhouse gases to the atmosphere. However, the process of growing corn for ethanol can have environmental impacts and it can drive up food prices.

When blended with gasoline, ethanol can offer emissions benefits, depending on the vehicle type, engine calibration, and blend level. For example, a blend of 85% ethanol and 15% gasoline, known as E85, results in lower evaporative emissions compared to gasoline. E85 also decreases carbon dioxide emissions and reduces the emissions of harmful toxins, such as benzene, a known carcinogen. However, it increases acetaldehyde emissions, which are also anticipated to be carcinogenic and can contribute to ground-level ozone formation.

The blend ratio of ethanol to gasoline can have varying effects on air pollution. For instance, a University of California, Riverside study found that increasing the ethanol content from 10% to 15% in gasoline (E10 to E15) reduced tailpipe emissions of particulate matter, carbon monoxide, and other pollutants. On the other hand, a study by environmental engineer Mark Jacobson concluded that burning ethanol adds 22% more hydrocarbons to the atmosphere compared to burning gasoline, leading to increased surface ozone and potential health risks.

Overall, while ethanol-blended gasoline may offer some emissions benefits, the impact on air pollution reduction is complex and dependent on various factors, including the blend ratio. Further research and life cycle analyses are necessary to fully understand the environmental impacts of ethanol-blended gasoline and determine the optimal blend ratios for minimizing air pollution.

Ethanol's ability to reduce harmful tailpipe emissions

Ethanol has been the subject of much debate in recent years, with some arguing for its ability to reduce harmful tailpipe emissions and others criticising its environmental impact. Despite this, ethanol is currently used as a fuel additive in the US to help gasoline burn more completely and reduce air pollution.

Ethanol is a biofuel made from biomass feedstocks such as corn, barley, and sugar cane. It can be blended with gasoline as a direct substitute for aromatics, which are toxic air pollutants known to cause cancer, adverse reproductive effects, and other health issues. Aromatic hydrocarbons made up 20% of the gasoline sold in the US in 2016, and their combustion produces ultra-fine particulate matter and other harmful air pollutants. The addition of ethanol to gasoline has allowed the US to reduce the total volume of aromatics in gasoline from 25% in 2005 to 20% in 2016. This substitution of toxic aromatics for ethanol reduces the health impacts associated with gasoline.

A University of California, Riverside study found that low-aromatic, high-ethanol blended gasoline can reduce tailpipe emissions of particulate matter, carbon monoxide, BTEX, and other pollutants. Testing of 20 vehicles in 2022 found that replacing E10 (gasoline blended with 10% ethanol) with E15 (gasoline containing 15% ethanol) provided emissions benefits, including the reduction of fine particulate matter, which can enter the lungs and cause serious health effects.

E85, a high-level blend of 85% ethanol and 15% gasoline, has been found to decrease carbon dioxide emissions and the emissions of many harmful toxics, such as benzene, a known carcinogen. However, it increases acetaldehyde emissions, which are also anticipated to be a human carcinogen and are moderately reactive for ground-level ozone formation.

While the addition of ethanol to gasoline has been shown to reduce certain tailpipe emissions, it is important to consider the overall environmental impact of its production. Critics argue that growing corn for fuel has a significant environmental impact, increasing food prices and requiring the use of chemicals and fertilisers. Additionally, the combustion of ethanol has been found to add more smog-forming pollution to the atmosphere, potentially exacerbating the ill effects of air pollution.

Ethanol's impact on the environment when considering the production process

Ethanol is produced by converting grains, beverages, food waste, trees, grasses, and more into ethanol. The grain is first separated into its basic components through soaking. After steeping, the slurry is processed through grinders to separate the corn germ. The remaining fibre, gluten, and starch components are further segregated. Yeast is then added, and the conversion of sugar to alcohol begins. After fermentation, the resulting "beer" is separated from the remaining "stillage". The ethanol is then distilled and dehydrated, then blended with about 2% denaturant (such as gasoline) to render it undrinkable.

The environmental impact of ethanol depends on the source of its production. Ethanol made from trees and grasses is considered an advanced biofuel, as these sources require less fuel, fertilisers, and water to grow than grains, and they can grow on lands that are not suitable for growing food crops. On the other hand, the environmental costs of increased corn production for ethanol have been criticised. Growing corn for ethanol in the US heartland has a major environmental impact, and this will only increase with higher-ethanol blends in gasoline. The demand for corn for ethanol production has also contributed to the decline in bee populations in the Midwest corn belt and California's Central Valley.

Despite the environmental costs of corn production for ethanol, some argue that improved agricultural methods and farming techniques have reduced the use of chemicals and fertilisers on cornfields, and that increasing the amount of corn ethanol in US gasoline would reduce air pollution and lower greenhouse gas emissions. Ethanol made from corn kernel fibre and other cellulosic feedstocks is delivering reductions of 80% or more in greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline.

While the overall climate impacts of ethanol remain uncertain, a recent study found that ethanol may not help reduce air pollution. The study, which used a computer model to assess air pollution in the US, found that ethanol could increase levels of dangerous smog pollution. This is because burning ethanol adds 22% more hydrocarbons to the atmosphere than burning gasoline, which would lead to a nearly two parts per billion increase in tropospheric ozone. This surface ozone has been linked to inflamed lungs, impaired immune systems, and heart disease. However, other studies have found that ethanol blended fuels present a lower risk to human health than regular gasoline as they can replace toxic aromatic compounds in gasoline.

Ethanol's effect on the octane rating of gasoline

Ethanol has a positive effect on the octane rating of gasoline. It boosts the octane number of fuel, helping to prevent pre-ignition knock. Knock occurs when fuel is prematurely ignited in the engine's cylinder, degrading efficiency and potentially damaging the engine. The octane rating of normal unleaded gasoline in the US is 87, while that of pure ethanol is 100. When blended with gasoline, ethanol performs as if its octane rating is 112, making it a very effective octane booster.

The high octane number of ethanol-gasoline blends can increase the minimum octane number (Research Octane Number, RON) of regular-grade gasoline. Higher RON enables greater thermal efficiency in engines through a higher compression ratio (CR) and/or more aggressive turbocharging and downsizing. This can lead to improved fuel economy and higher engine performance. Additionally, the use of ethanol in gasoline blends can eliminate the need for other octane boosters, potentially reducing petroleum prices.

However, it is important to note that the benefits of ethanol as an octane booster may be more pronounced in newer vehicles. Older engines may require manual adjustments to compensate for the different combustion conditions caused by the higher oxygen content in ethanol blends. Some users have reported engines overheating when using ethanol blends, although this is not fully understood, as ethanol has a lower flame temperature than gasoline.

Overall, while ethanol has a positive effect on the octane rating of gasoline, it is just one factor to consider in the broader discussion of the benefits and challenges of using ethanol as a fuel additive.

Ethanol's potential to reduce cancer risk

Ethanol, or ethyl alcohol, is a chemical substance found in alcoholic beverages. The addition of ethanol to gasoline has been a topic of debate, with some arguing that it can help reduce air pollution by improving gas mileage and lowering gas prices, while others claim that it can increase air pollution and damage engines.

While the overall impact of ethanol on the climate is still uncertain, it is important to acknowledge that ethanol, when blended with gasoline, can offer some emissions benefits. The use of ethanol as a fuel additive helps gasoline burn more completely, reducing air pollution. However, a study by environmental engineer Mark Jacobson of Stanford University suggests that ethanol may increase the levels of dangerous smog-forming pollution in the atmosphere, leading to a potential increase in ground-level ozone-related deaths.

Now, let's discuss ethanol's potential to reduce cancer risk. Firstly, it is essential to understand that ethanol, as a component of alcoholic beverages, has been linked to an increased risk of several cancers. According to the National Cancer Institute, researchers have proposed multiple mechanisms by which ethanol may increase cancer risk. One of the key mechanisms involves the metabolization of ethanol into acetaldehyde, a toxic chemical and probable human carcinogen. Acetaldehyde can damage DNA and proteins, increase oxidative stress, impair nutrient absorption, and contribute to inflammation and DNA damage, all of which are factors in cancer development.

Additionally, ethanol can increase the risk of tobacco-related cancers. When combined with smoking, ethanol may enhance the entry of harmful chemicals from tobacco into the cells lining the mouth, throat, and esophagus, increasing the likelihood of oral, throat, and esophageal cancers. Furthermore, ethanol can lead to weight gain through excess calorie intake, and being overweight is a known risk factor for over 12 types of cancer.

However, it is worth noting that some studies have indicated a decreased risk of certain cancers, such as kidney cancer and non-Hodgkin lymphoma, associated with ethanol or alcohol consumption. Nevertheless, the potential benefits of reduced risk for these specific cancers are likely outweighed by the overall harms of ethanol or alcohol consumption. As recommended by MD Anderson Cancer Center, the greatest risk reduction for cancer is achieved by refraining from drinking alcohol altogether.

Frequently asked questions