Wood Vs Vinyl Windows: Which Blocks Pollutants Better?

When it comes to choosing the right windows for your home, there are many factors to consider, including cost, durability, and energy efficiency. Two of the most popular options on the market are wood frame and vinyl windows. While vinyl windows are often chosen for their affordability and easy installation, they have been associated with the release of toxic chemicals during production and after disposal. On the other hand, wood frame windows offer superior insulation, are environmentally friendly, and can last a lifetime with proper care, but they may require treatments to prevent rotting and come at a higher initial cost. So, which type of window is better at keeping out pollutants? Let's explore the pros and cons of each to find out.

Vinyl windows are less environmentally friendly to manufacture

Vinyl windows are made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a type of plastic. While vinyl windows are recyclable, the manufacturing process is less environmentally friendly than that of wood windows. Vinyl window manufacturing releases pollutants and toxic fumes into the air, contributing to climate change and ecotoxicity.

Vinyl window production involves the use of toxic chemicals, such as mercury, which can pose health risks to both firefighters and nearby occupants in the event of a building fire. The burning of vinyl windows releases toxins, including dioxin, into the atmosphere. While levels of dioxin in the US have decreased over the years, the upward trend in vinyl production raises concerns about its long-term environmental impact.

Additionally, vinyl windows are derived from non-sustainable sources, unlike wood, which is the only naturally renewable building material. The use of wood windows helps to reduce the concern of deforestation and illegal logging. Wood windows are also highly customizable, allowing for painting or staining to fit the aesthetics of a home.

While vinyl windows offer advantages such as durability, low maintenance, and energy efficiency, their manufacturing process is less environmentally friendly due to the release of pollutants and the use of non-sustainable materials. Homeowners seeking environmentally friendly options may prefer wood windows or alternative materials like aluminum or fiberglass, which are considered safer and more sustainable.

Vinyl windows are more energy-efficient

Vinyl windows are a popular alternative to wood windows because of their durability and lower price point. They are made of PVC and come in many colours. They typically have hollow cores, but you can increase the insulation by opting for foam-filled frames. This improves their insulating characteristics, making them thermally superior to standard vinyl and wood frames.

Wood windows, on the other hand, require regular maintenance to avoid rot and damage from weather and pests. They must be repainted or stained once every three to four years, which can be a laborious project. Wood that has not been properly maintained may split or decay, allowing heat and cold to travel through. This can cause the frame to distort over time, resulting in an air gap and diminishing efficiency.

Vinyl windows are also easier to maintain. They never need repainting and only require regular cleaning with soapy water. They are also fairly durable, with the most common repairs being for replacing or fixing the hardware.

When selecting energy-efficient windows, it is important to consider the frame materials, glazing or glass features, gas fills, and spacers. All of these factors will influence the overall energy efficiency of the window. To assess and compare the overall window properties, look for an NFRC label, which shows energy performance in four categories: U-factor, Solar Heat Gain Coefficient, Air Leakage, and Visible Transmittance.

Wood windows are high-maintenance

Wood windows are generally considered to be the "best" type of windows available, especially with virtually all companies offering composite or aluminium-clad exteriors. They are highly customisable because you can paint or stain them to fit the aesthetics of your home, and they are a beautiful and timeless option for classically styled spaces.

However, wood windows are high-maintenance. They require regular care to preserve their beauty and functionality. Wood windows need to be regularly cleaned to prevent dirt and debris from accumulating and potentially damaging the wood. A soft cloth or brush with mild soap and water should be used to clean the frames and glass. Wood windows also need to be repainted or restained every few years to protect them from moisture and UV damage. This maintenance can be labour-intensive, depending on the size of your home, and it is important to hire a professional if you are not up to the task.

Wood windows are also susceptible to rot, warping, and insect damage. They must be well-maintained to avoid rot and damage from the weather and pests. Wood that has not been properly maintained may split or decay, allowing heat and cold to travel through. Regions with high humidity levels pose challenges for wood windows, as excessive moisture absorption can cause the wood to swell, leading to difficulties in opening and closing the windows smoothly. Prolonged exposure to moisture can also add mould and mildew growth, compromising the structural integrity of the frames. In dry climates, wood windows can shrink and develop cracks over time due to a lack of moisture.

To prevent these issues, wood windows must be properly installed, and moisture must be controlled. Wood windows should also be sealed with a protective finish like paint or stain, and routine maintenance should be performed. Pest prevention is also important, as wood is susceptible to pests like termites, carpenter ants, and wood-boring beetles. Regular inspections and timely treatments are necessary to prevent infestations and the spread of damage.

Vinyl windows are more durable

Vinyl windows are a popular alternative to wood windows due to their durability and lower price point. They are made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a synthetic plastic material that is durable, light, and versatile. Vinyl windows are also energy-efficient, as they don't conduct heat or cold and have good insulation. The insulation can be further improved by opting for foam-filled frames instead of hollow-core frames.

While wood windows are considered more durable than vinyl, they require regular maintenance to prevent rot and damage from weather and pests. Wood windows need to be repainted or stained every three to four years, which can be labour-intensive. Proper maintenance of wood windows is crucial to ensure their durability and lifespan.

On the other hand, vinyl windows require minimal maintenance as they don't need repainting or sealing. They are also more resistant to environmental conditions and are less likely to crack or dent unless struck with force. Vinyl windows can last over 20 years, while wooden windows typically need to be replaced every 20 years.

The durability of vinyl windows also contributes to their higher return on investment (ROI) compared to wood windows. Vinyl windows have an average ROI of 68.5%, while wood windows have an ROI of around 67% to 70%.

In summary, vinyl windows offer a combination of durability, energy efficiency, and low maintenance, making them a cost-effective choice for homeowners.

Wood windows offer more customisation

Vinyl windows are popular because they are affordable and energy-efficient. They are made of PVC and come in a variety of colours. However, wood windows remain the "gold standard" in the replacement window industry.

Wood windows are also known for their durability, with many lasting for decades when properly maintained. However, they require more maintenance than vinyl windows, as they need to be repainted or stained once every three to four years. Wood windows are also more vulnerable to moisture than other types of materials and are susceptible to rot, warping, or insect damage.

Vinyl windows, on the other hand, offer fewer customisation options. They typically have a smooth finish, giving them a plastic appearance. While they come in a variety of frame sizes and thicknesses, they have fewer alternatives because the more ridges and faux wood grain vinyl has, the more dirt it collects over time. Vinyl windows are also less environmentally friendly to manufacture, as the process releases more pollutants into the air.

Frequently asked questions