Volcanic Emissions Vs Car Pollution: Who's The Bigger Culprit?

There is an ongoing debate about whether volcanoes or human activities contribute more to climate change. While volcanoes can inject huge amounts of volcanic gas, aerosol droplets, and ash into the stratosphere during major eruptions, the impact of human activities on the carbon cycle is much more significant. According to various sources, human activities emit tens of billions of metric tons of CO2 annually, while volcanoes produce less than a billion metric tons. This disparity in emission rates indicates that human activities have a far greater influence on climate change than volcanic activity.

Human activity vs volcanic CO2 emissions

Human activity and volcanic eruptions both release carbon dioxide (CO2), a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change. However, the impact of these two sources on the atmosphere is significantly different.

Volcanoes can release large amounts of CO2 during major eruptions, but these events are infrequent and short-lived. On the other hand, human activities, such as burning fossil fuels and industrial processes, emit significant amounts of CO2 continuously throughout the year. As a result, human emissions far exceed those from volcanoes. For example, in 2010, human activities were responsible for an estimated 35 billion metric tons of CO2, while all studies indicate that volcanoes release less than 1% of that amount, or about 0.13 to 0.44 gigatons per year. This disparity is further highlighted by the fact that atmospheric CO2 levels have consistently risen year after year, regardless of volcanic activity, indicating that human emissions are the primary driver of increasing greenhouse gas concentrations.

While volcanoes can impact climate change, the effect is complex and depends on the specific gases and particles released. Volcanic gases like sulfur dioxide can cause global cooling, as observed after the Laki fissure eruption in Iceland from 1783 to 1784. In contrast, carbon dioxide released by volcanoes can contribute to global warming, although current volcanic activity is not on the same massive scale as past events that may have caused global temperature rises and mass extinctions.

The impact of human emissions on climate change is well-established and supported by overwhelming scientific evidence. Since the Industrial Revolution, human activities have released more than 2,000 billion metric tons of CO2 into the atmosphere, leading to a significant increase in global temperatures and contributing to climate change. The burning of coal, oil, and other fossil fuels, as well as cement production and deforestation, are major sources of human-caused CO2 emissions.

In summary, while volcanoes can release large amounts of CO2 during eruptions, human activities emit far more CO2 on an annual basis. The continuous and cumulative nature of human emissions has led to a significant increase in atmospheric CO2 concentrations, driving climate change. Addressing and mitigating human-caused emissions are crucial in combating the ongoing climate crisis.

The impact of volcanic eruptions on climate change

Volcanic eruptions can influence climate change by releasing gases, dust, and ash into the atmosphere. During major eruptions, large amounts of volcanic gas, aerosol droplets, and ash are injected into the stratosphere. While the injected ash falls rapidly from the stratosphere and has little impact on climate change, volcanic gases can significantly influence the climate.

Volcanoes emit gases such as sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide. Sulfur dioxide moves into the stratosphere and combines with water to form sulfuric acid aerosols, creating a haze of tiny droplets that reflect incoming solar radiation, leading to a cooling effect on the Earth's surface. This cooling impact can last for several years, depending on the eruption's magnitude. On the other hand, carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas that has the potential to promote global warming. While carbon dioxide emissions from volcanoes can contribute to global warming, present-day volcanic emissions of carbon dioxide constitute less than a percent of the carbon dioxide released by human activities.

It is important to note that climate change can also influence volcanic eruptions. Changes in precipitation patterns, glacier melt, and sea-level rise associated with climate change can affect magma production and facilitate its ascent, potentially triggering eruptions. While the specific link between individual eruptions and climate change can be challenging to determine, there is evidence that certain volcanic regions may experience an increase in eruptions due to the changing climate.

The frequency of volcanic eruptions

The largest eruptions originate from rhyolite calderas, a type of volcano that can produce massive eruptions occurring at intervals of 10,000 to 30,000 years. Supervolcanoes, such as Yellowstone in the USA and Lake Toba in Indonesia, are examples of rhyolite calderas. Yellowstone, the largest rhyolite caldera in the USA, has had major eruptions approximately every 600,000 to 700,000 years.

While volcanoes can have a significant impact on the local area and the planet's climate, the frequency of volcanic eruptions is relatively low compared to human activities that contribute to pollution. Since the Industrial Revolution, human emissions of carbon dioxide from fossil fuels and cement production have surged to over 35 billion metric tons annually, far surpassing volcanic emissions, which amount to less than 1 billion metric tons per year.

The unpredictability of volcanic eruptions poses a challenge for scientists. While factors such as timing and eruption history can provide clues, predicting eruptions is complex due to the lack of remote sensing capabilities to determine magma characteristics.

The impact of human emissions on ice sheets

Human activities are responsible for a projected 35 billion metric tons of CO2 emissions annually, with some sources citing this figure to be as high as 24 billion tons. In contrast, all studies to date indicate that present-day volcanoes release less than a percent of the carbon dioxide released by human activities, with estimates ranging from 0.13 to 0.44 gigatons per year. This disparity demonstrates that human emissions far exceed those of volcanoes.

Moreover, the loss of Arctic ice has far-reaching consequences worldwide. The Arctic and Antarctic regions act as the world's refrigerator, reflecting heat back into space and keeping the planet cooler. As the ice melts, darker patches of ocean emerge, disrupting the cooling effect and leading to warmer air temperatures. This phenomenon contributes to the increased frequency of polar vortexes, heatwaves, and unpredictable weather patterns, which are already causing significant damage to global food systems.

To prevent the worst impacts of climate change, it is crucial to limit the increase in global temperatures. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions, particularly from human land use and the burning of fossil fuels, is essential to mitigate the effects on ice sheets. Scientists warn that failing to curb emissions will lead to irreversible consequences and commit the planet to centuries of change, affecting human societies and wildlife for generations to come.

While volcanoes can impact climate change by releasing gases, aerosols, and ash during eruptions, their contribution to pollution is relatively minor compared to human activities. Therefore, addressing human emissions is the key focus to mitigate the impact on ice sheets and prevent catastrophic outcomes.

The impact of volcanic gases on global temperatures

Volcanic eruptions release molten rock, or lava, from deep within the Earth, forming new rock on the Earth’s surface. The largest and most explosive eruptions also impact the atmosphere. The gases and dust particles thrown into the atmosphere during large volcanic eruptions can influence climate change.

Volcanoes release large amounts of greenhouse gases such as water vapour and carbon dioxide. Carbon dioxide is abundant in volcanic gases, but not enough to significantly contribute to the greenhouse effect. Volcanoes contribute about 110 million tons of carbon dioxide per year, while human activities contribute about 10 billion tons per year. The 2010 projected anthropogenic CO2 emissions were about 80 to 270 times larger than the respective maximum and minimum annual global volcanic CO2 emission estimates.

Volcanic eruptions can inject significant amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. For example, the 1980 eruption of Mount St. Helens vented approximately 10 million tons of CO2 into the atmosphere in only 9 hours. However, it currently takes humanity only 2.5 hours to put out the same amount. While large explosive eruptions like this are rare and only occur globally about once a decade, humanity's emissions are ceaseless and increasing every year.

Volcanoes can also cause climate cooling when eruptions spew volcanic gases like sulfur dioxide into the atmosphere. Sulfur dioxide can form aerosols that reflect the sun's rays and cause cooling of the earth's surface. The 1783-1784 Laki fissure eruption in Iceland released approximately 120 million tons of sulfur dioxide, causing regional cooling of Europe and North America. Several eruptions during the past century have caused a decline in the average temperature at the Earth's surface of up to half a degree (Fahrenheit scale) for periods of one to three years.

Frequently asked questions