Volcanoes Vs. Humans: Who Pollutes More?

There is an ongoing debate about whether human activity or natural occurrences, such as volcanic eruptions, contribute more to climate change and pollution. While volcanoes do release carbon dioxide and other gases into the atmosphere, the impact of human-induced emissions is far greater. Human activities, such as burning fossil fuels and deforestation, have led to a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions, with levels rising consistently year after year. On the other hand, volcanic eruptions, while capable of emitting large amounts of gases and particles into the stratosphere, are infrequent and have a less substantial overall impact on a yearly basis.

Human activity produces far more CO2 than volcanoes

Human activity produces far more carbon dioxide (CO2) than volcanoes. While volcanoes do release CO2 into the atmosphere, those emissions are dwarfed by emissions from human activity. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, the world's volcanoes, both on land and undersea, generate about 200 million tons of CO2 annually, while automotive and industrial activities cause around 24 billion tons of CO2 emissions every year worldwide. This means that greenhouse gas emissions from volcanoes comprise less than one percent of those generated by human activities.

The argument that human-caused carbon emissions are negligible compared to the greenhouse gases generated by volcanoes is not supported by scientific evidence. Atmospheric CO2 levels, as measured by sampling stations around the world, have consistently increased year after year, regardless of whether or not there have been major volcanic eruptions. If volcanic eruptions were the primary cause of rising CO2 concentrations, we would expect to see spikes in the data corresponding to each eruption. Instead, the records show a smooth and regular upward trend, indicating that human emissions are the dominant factor.

Large, violent volcanic eruptions may briefly match the rate of human emissions, but they are too infrequent and short-lived to rival humanity's annual emissions. For example, the explosive eruption of Mount St. Helens in 1980 emitted carbon dioxide at a very high rate, but only for about nine hours. In contrast, human activities emit CO2 continuously throughout the year, year after year. Several individual U.S. states emit more CO2 in a year than all the volcanoes on Earth combined.

While it is true that volcanoes can impact climate change, the carbon dioxide released by contemporary volcanic eruptions has never caused detectable global warming. Instead, volcanic eruptions often have the opposite effect, leading to short-term global cooling due to the injection of sulfur dioxide, ash, and other particles into the atmosphere. However, it is important to note that volcanoes can contribute to global warming over geological time scales. For example, some geologists believe that a massive eruption in Siberia 250 million years ago may have raised global temperatures, causing one of the worst extinction events in our planet's history.

Volcanic eruptions can cause global cooling

While volcanoes do emit carbon dioxide and contribute to global warming, human activities emit far more carbon dioxide than volcanoes. In fact, several individual U.S. states emit more carbon dioxide in a year than all the volcanoes on Earth combined. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, human automotive and industrial activities cause about 24 billion tons of CO2 emissions annually, while the world's volcanoes generate about 200 million tons of carbon dioxide per year. Thus, human carbon dioxide emissions are more than 60 times greater than those of volcanoes.

However, volcanic eruptions can sometimes cause short-term global cooling. For instance, the eruption of Mount Pinatubo in 1991 cooled the surface of the Earth by 0.5 degrees Celsius a year later. This is because volcanoes emit sulfur dioxide (SO2), ash, and other particles into the air and stratosphere, which reflect incoming sunlight and cause global cooling. Unusually cold decades, such as the 540s, 1450s, and 1600s, have been associated with large volcanic eruptions.

Tree-ring-based temperature reconstructions, historical records of dust veils, and ice core studies have confirmed that some of the coldest years during the last five millennia were directly caused by massive volcanic injections of SO2. The quantification of volcanic cooling during the Last Glacial Period is made possible by annually resolved δ18O records, which show that volcanic coolings during this time were comparable to or greater than those of the Common Era.

Furthermore, a study by the University of Cambridge and the UK Met Office found that as global warming continues to accelerate, it will significantly alter how volcanic eruptions impact the climate. While the cooling effects of small and medium-sized eruptions may decrease by up to 75%, the impact of large eruptions will be amplified by the warming climate. The plumes of ash and gas emitted by these large eruptions will rise higher and spread faster, leading to an enhanced cooling effect.

Volcanic CO2 emissions are released through vents and porous rocks

Volcanoes emit carbon dioxide in two main ways: during eruptions and through underground magma. During an eruption, volcanoes release gases, ash, and particles into the atmosphere. Large, violent eruptions can release significant amounts of carbon dioxide and other gases, but these events are rare and fleeting. The carbon dioxide released during eruptions is a result of the degassing of subterranean magma.

Underground magma, which is the molten rock beneath the Earth's surface, can also release carbon dioxide through vents and porous rocks. This occurs when the magma cools and the dissolved gases are released. The vents and porous rocks act as pathways for the gases to escape from the magma and into the atmosphere. This process is a significant contributor to volcanic CO2 emissions, as much of the carbon dioxide is emitted when the volcano is not actively erupting.

Volcanic degassing has been monitored and studied by scientists to better understand the impact of volcanic activity on the Earth's atmosphere and climate. The development of miniature, durable, and inexpensive instruments has allowed for the continuous monitoring of CO2 emissions from many of the world's most active volcanoes. This data has provided valuable insights into the contribution of volcanic activity to global carbon dioxide levels.

While volcanoes are a natural source of carbon dioxide emissions, human activities such as burning fossil fuels and industrial processes have a much larger impact on the Earth's atmosphere. According to various sources and estimates, human activities emit 40 to 100 times more carbon dioxide than volcanoes each year. This disparity is due to the continuous nature of human emissions, as well as the scale and frequency of volcanic eruptions.

Volcanic gases, aerosol droplets, and ash are injected into the stratosphere

Volcanic eruptions can have a significant impact on the climate, as they inject volcanic gases, aerosol droplets, and ash into the stratosphere. These injections can cause both global cooling and warming effects. While the ash generally falls back to the ground within days to weeks and has little impact on climate change, the gases and aerosols can have more significant and long-lasting effects.

Volcanic gases, such as sulfur dioxide (SO2), are released during eruptions and through passive degassing. In the atmosphere, SO2 can be oxidized to form sulfate aerosols, which have a cooling effect on the planet. The conversion of SO2 to sulfuric acid (H2SO4) is particularly important, as it rapidly condenses in the stratosphere to form fine sulfate aerosols. These aerosols increase the reflection of radiation from the Sun back into space, leading to a cooling effect on the Earth's lower atmosphere or troposphere. The eruption of Mount Pinatubo in 1991, for example, injected 20 million tons of SO2 into the stratosphere, causing a half-degree (0.6°C) drop in global temperatures that lasted for two years.

Volcanic carbon dioxide (CO2) is also released during eruptions and through underground magma. While CO2 is a greenhouse gas and can contribute to global warming, the amount released by volcanoes is relatively small compared to human activities. According to estimates, volcanoes emit around 0.13 to 0.44 gigatons of CO2 per year, while human activities emit 24 billion to 40 billion tons of CO2 annually. This means that human emissions are 60 to 90 times greater than volcanic emissions.

It is important to note that the effects of volcanic injections into the stratosphere can be complex and depend on various factors, such as the size and frequency of the eruptions, as well as the interaction with climate change. While large, explosive eruptions can have significant short-term impacts, they are relatively rare, and the overall effect of volcanic activity on the climate is small compared to human-caused emissions.

Volcanic activity has contributed to global warming over geological time

Volcanoes emit carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas, which has the potential to promote global warming. During major eruptions, huge amounts of volcanic gas, including carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide, are injected into the stratosphere. While the injected ash falls rapidly and has little impact on climate change, the volcanic gases can have a cooling or warming effect on the Earth's atmosphere.

Sulfur dioxide, for example, can cause global cooling, as seen in the case of the Mount Pinatubo eruption in 1991, which injected a 20-million-ton sulfur dioxide cloud into the stratosphere. This led to a significant cooling of the Earth's surface for several years. On the other hand, carbon dioxide released during volcanic eruptions has the potential to cause global warming, although there is ongoing scientific debate about its exact impact.

Over geological time, volcanoes have occasionally contributed to global warming by producing significant amounts of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. For instance, geologists hypothesize that around 250 million years ago, a massive and prolonged eruption in Siberia likely raised global temperatures, resulting in one of the worst extinction events on Earth. However, it is essential to distinguish between the effects of volcanic eruptions and human activities in terms of their scale and frequency.

While volcanoes can emit carbon dioxide at high rates during eruptions, these rates are only sustained for short periods. In contrast, human activities, such as burning fossil fuels and industrial processes, release carbon dioxide consistently throughout the year, leading to much higher cumulative emissions. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, human activities emit 60 or more times the amount of carbon dioxide released by volcanoes annually. This disparity highlights the significant impact of human-induced emissions on global warming compared to volcanic activity in the present day.

Frequently asked questions