How Green Are Submarines?

Nuclear submarines have the potential to pollute the ocean, and this is a pressing concern for many nations. Nuclear submarines contain nuclear reactors, with uranium and plutonium cores, which are not soluble in water. However, there is still a risk of corrosion and leakage, and the dumping of radioactive submarine parts into the sea would be in contravention of the current global moratorium on this practice.

Nuclear submarines and radioactive waste

Nuclear submarines, such as the AUKUS submarines, produce radioactive waste that needs to be carefully disposed of. This waste includes spent nuclear fuel, which contains large amounts of highly enriched uranium and is highly radioactive and produces heat.

The disposal process for this type of waste is complex and requires specialized facilities. In the case of AUKUS submarines, the Australian government has announced that a new facility will be built on defence land to handle the high-level nuclear waste generated by these vessels. The site selection process is set to begin in 2023, with the first submarines expected to arrive in the early 2030s.

Tony Irwin, a nuclear engineer at the Australian National University, offers insight into the management of radioactive waste. He suggests that Australia needs to be prepared to manage low and intermediate-level waste from routine submarine operations from 2033 and high-level waste from around 2060 when the first submarines are decommissioned. Irwin proposes that one of the four options for disposal can be utilized after the waste has cooled down sufficiently for safe transportation.

The selection of a site for the disposal of high-level nuclear waste is a controversial issue. Community engagement expert Professor Sara Bice emphasizes the importance of early and transparent consultation with the public and affected communities, including First Nations groups. Bice highlights the need for public discussion about the desirability of the technology and the potential impact on local communities. Similarly, a First Nations Voice to Parliament in South Australia advocates for transparent consultation with First Nations people from the outset of the decision-making process.

Ocean acoustics and sonar

Acoustic and sonar technologies are widely used in marine and maritime applications. These technologies are designed to enhance access to subsea environmental data, improve efficiency, and reduce operating costs. Acoustic scattering, which is central to the design and operation of active sonar systems, involves studying the propagation of acoustic waves and their interaction with objects and the environment. This field of study encompasses the theories and models that describe how sound waves scatter, reverberate, and interact with ambient noise in the ocean.

Sonar systems, which utilise acoustic waves, play a crucial role in underwater exploration and data collection. These systems can be categorised as active or passive. Active sonar systems emit acoustic signals and analyse the reflected echoes, while passive sonar systems focus on receiving and interpreting existing acoustic signals in the environment. The design and operation of these sonar systems involve a comprehensive understanding of underwater acoustics, including the behaviour of sound waves and their interaction with the environment and various materials.

The development and implementation of sonar processes involve several key steps. Firstly, the conditioning input stage involves the initial transmission or reception of acoustic signals. This is followed by output processing, where the received signals are interpreted and analysed. The design considerations for sonar systems include the choice of transducers and antennas, as well as the types of signal processing techniques employed. Transducers play a crucial role in converting acoustic signals into electrical signals and vice versa.

Acoustic and sonar technologies have various applications in commercial fishing, scientific research, and the protection of marine life. For example, acoustic monitoring systems can optimise fishing operations by providing depth and temperature information, helping achieve optimal catch yields while reducing the impact on endangered marine mammals. Additionally, acoustic methodologies are employed in marine biology research to study animal behaviour, communication, and the effects of human activities on their environment.

The field of ocean acoustics and sonar is constantly evolving, with ongoing research and development in academia and industry. Researchers and engineers work together to address challenges and improve the performance of sonar systems. This includes the development of new sensors, synthetic aperture sonar imaging, and the exploration of acoustics navigation techniques. The collaboration between researchers and industries such as fishing, aquaculture, and oil and gas ensures that acoustic and sonar technologies remain sustainable and adaptable to the changing needs of various sectors.

Stealth and strategic advantage

Submarines offer significant strategic advantages due to their stealth capabilities. Their invisibility and the unpredictable nature of the ocean provide a powerful deterrent against the use of nuclear weapons in a crisis. The ocean environment acts as a protective shield against antisubmarine forces, making it challenging for enemies to detect and target submarines.

The deep ocean is particularly advantageous for submarines due to its superior sound transmission properties. Sound travels efficiently over long distances in deep water, enabling submarines to detect hostile targets from hundreds of miles away. This capability enhances their strategic advantage by providing early warning and the ability to remain undetected.

However, certain environmental factors can hinder a submarine's stealth capabilities. Variables such as temperature, salinity, currents, bottom contour, and human-caused noises can create a complex and challenging environment for submarine crews. These factors can make it difficult for them to interpret their surroundings accurately.

Additionally, shallow water poses a challenge for submarine stealth. Sound reflection and refraction in shallow areas can degrade the performance of sonar systems, making it harder to detect targets and maintain stealth. The Mediterranean Sea, for example, presents difficult detection conditions due to its significant variations in salinity and temperature.

The Arctic region also offers a diverse range of ocean acoustic conditions, including shallow and deep water, open and ice-covered water, and varying wind speeds. The Soviet continental shelf, with its high wind speeds, broken ice, and shipping noise near ports, is characterised by poor detection conditions for submarines.

In summary, submarines possess exceptional stealth capabilities that provide a strategic advantage in military conflicts. While the ocean environment can enhance their invisibility, certain environmental factors and shallow water can also impact their ability to remain undetected. Understanding and navigating these complexities are crucial for maintaining the stealth and strategic advantage of submarines.

Accidents and leaks

One of the most well-known submarine accidents involving pollution is that of the USS Carl Vinson. This incident attracted public attention as one of the few nuclear submarine accidents that have come under the spotlight. The aircraft carrier, powered by two nuclear reactors, is known to be equipped with nuclear-tipped torpedoes, which pose a significant environmental hazard if there is a breach or leak.

The potential for nuclear contamination extends beyond just the reactors and weapons. Ingar Amundsen, an expert in nuclear safety, has warned that the dismantling of nuclear submarines generates substantial radioactive waste. The improper disposal of these radioactive components, including dumping them at sea, would violate international agreements and pose a severe threat to marine ecosystems.

The issue of radioactive contamination in the ocean is not limited to accidents but also includes intentional dumping. The United States Navy has been criticized for dumping low-activity nuclear waste into coastal waters. This has prompted calls for international cooperation to address military radioactive contamination of the seas. However, the lack of incentive for militaries to curb their nuclear activities poses a challenge to any potential solutions.

The presence of sunken submarines at the bottom of the ocean also contributes to the pollution risk. Two submarines containing large amounts of cesium-137 lie in the Atlantic Ocean, with their nuclear reactors intact. There is a real danger of these submarines leaking radioactive materials into the surrounding waters if no action is taken.

The potential for accidents, leaks, and improper disposal of radioactive waste associated with submarines underscores the environmental risks they pose to the ocean. It is crucial to address these concerns through international cooperation and strict adherence to agreements prohibiting the dumping of radioactive materials at sea.

International efforts and regulations

One of the critical annexes is Annex VI, which focuses on air pollution from ocean-going ships. It establishes limits on nitrogen oxide (NOx) and sulphur oxide (SOx) emissions, aiming to reduce ozone-producing pollution and protect human health and the environment. These standards apply to vessels operating in US waters and within 200 nautical miles of the North American coast, known as the North American Emission Control Area (ECA). Annex VI also addresses the use of fuel with lower sulphur content to further mitigate pollution.

Another significant aspect of international efforts is the management of submarine waste. Submarines generate various types of waste, including hazardous materials, food scraps, and wastewater. Effective waste management practices are critical to minimising environmental impact. Submarines employ advanced systems for waste treatment and disposal, treating wastewater onboard using biological and chemical processes before discharge to neutralise harmful substances. International conventions, such as MARPOL Annex V, provide guidelines for waste handling on submarines, ensuring the proper treatment and disposal of hazardous materials to prevent toxic substances from entering aquatic ecosystems.

In addition to international regulations, national policies also play a role in governing submarine operations. Organisations collaborate with naval forces to establish guidelines that promote eco-friendly technologies and sustainable practices. These policies focus on reducing ecological disruption and fostering environmental sustainability in naval activities. Innovations in submarine design and propulsion systems, such as fuel cells and advanced batteries, are being explored to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and reliance on fossil fuels.

The growing global concern over nuclear submarine accidents and the potential for ocean nuclear contamination has also spurred international action. The European Parliament, for instance, passed a resolution urging major naval powers to disclose all nuclear weapons and reactors lost at sea. This resolution highlights the international commitment to addressing the environmental and safety implications of submarine operations.

Frequently asked questions