Plants: Air Purifiers Or Pollutant Absorbers?

The idea that plants can clean indoor air is appealing, but is it true? Research on the topic has produced mixed results. Some studies, including a 1989 NASA study, have found that plants can absorb carbon dioxide and other pollutants, such as formaldehyde and benzene, through the process of photosynthesis. Other studies, however, have found that plants have little impact on indoor air quality and that it would take a large number of plants to make a significant difference. While the jury is still out on the exact extent of plants' air-purifying abilities, there is evidence that they can provide other benefits, such as improved well-being, productivity, and reduced mental fatigue.

The number of plants needed to purify indoor air

Plants can absorb air pollutants through their leaves and roots. A famous NASA study from 1989 found that plants can remove volatile organic compounds (VOCs) such as formaldehyde and benzene from the air. However, the study was conducted in small, sealed environments, and the effects of plants on air purification in real-world conditions are less significant.

While plants can improve indoor air quality, the number of plants needed to purify indoor air depends on various factors, and it is challenging to provide an exact number. Bill Wolverton, the NASA scientist who conducted the 1989 study, recommends at least two good-sized plants for every 100 square feet (approximately 9.3 square meters) of indoor space. The bigger and leafier the plant, the better, as air purification is influenced by the surface area of leaves present.

In a larger room (8 x 8 meters or 26 by 26 feet), 16 plants were found to provide a 75% improvement in air quality, with 32 plants producing the best results. However, these numbers may vary depending on the size and species of the plants. For example, plants with more leaf surface area and larger pots will generally be more effective at purifying the air.

It is also important to note that the community of microorganisms and the growing medium (such as soil or compost) play a significant role in absorbing pollutants. Exposing the surface of the soil in potted plants can aid in air purification. Additionally, outdoor trees and plants can also help reduce indoor air pollution by filtering particulate matter that enters through open windows or on the bottoms of shoes.

While plants can improve indoor air quality, it is essential to manage expectations. An indoor forest would be required to significantly reduce VOCs in a home. Combining plants with air purifiers can be an effective approach to optimizing indoor air quality.

The impact of plants on mental health

Plants have a profound impact on mental health and overall happiness. They can reduce stress and anxiety, improve focus, and foster a sense of community. Horticultural therapy is used to help people recover from trauma and mental health issues, and it can also improve symptoms of neurological conditions like ADHD and dementia.

Research has shown that engaging with plants can serve as a distraction from negative thoughts and feelings, allowing individuals to focus on the present moment. This can be especially beneficial for those undergoing Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) or Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) as it reinforces therapeutic gains by promoting a more positive emotional state. Exposure to plants can also improve concentration and productivity. A study by the University of Michigan found that participants performed 20% better on attention-related tasks after spending time in natural environments.

Plants can also encourage physical activity, which is beneficial for mental health. Gardening can be a meditative practice, providing structure and mindfulness. It can also be a community activity, fostering teamwork, communication, and a sense of accomplishment.

In addition to the mental health benefits, plants can also improve air quality. They absorb carbon dioxide and other pollutants, which are then used in various plant processes or broken down. NASA studies indicate that plant-filled rooms contain 50 to 60 percent fewer airborne molds and bacteria than rooms without plants. However, it is important to note that the impact of indoor plants on air quality may be modest, and an indoor forest would be required to significantly reduce volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in a home.

The best plants for air purification

Plants can improve air quality, and certain species are known for their air-purifying abilities. Research from NASA has shown that plant-filled rooms contain 50 to 60% fewer airborne moulds and bacteria than rooms without plants.

When choosing the right air-purifying plants, it is important to consider the size of the room. For larger spaces, bigger plants like the Areca Palm are renowned for their air-purifying abilities. The Dragon Tree, including the Black Leaf Dragon Tree and the Hawaiian Sunshine Dragon Tree, is another option that suits larger spaces. For smaller areas, the Lemon Button Fern adds a touch of elegance and is well-suited to compact spaces. The Snake Plant is another common houseplant that can reduce some volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and produce oxygen at night, as well as during the day. The Musa Dwarf is a low-maintenance plant that is also capable of purifying the air.

Cacti and other succulents are great for beginners as they need little water and bright light. They can be placed on a windowsill and watered every 7-21 days, or more frequently during hotter weather.

While plants can improve air quality, it is important to note that the effects are modest. An indoor forest would be required to significantly reduce VOCs in a home. A combined approach using both plants and air purifiers can be highly effective in improving indoor air quality.

The role of microorganisms in soil

Plants can improve air quality and clean toxic soil. They do this through the process of photosynthesis, absorbing light, carbon dioxide, and water to manufacture sugar and release oxygen as a byproduct. However, the impact of plants on air quality is limited, and an indoor forest would be required to meaningfully reduce volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in a home.

Soil microorganisms play a critical role in the restoration of the land ecosystem and are the major biota in the soil. They are directly tied to nutrient recycling, especially carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, and sulfur. Bacteria, the smallest and most hardy microbes in the soil, can survive under harsh or changing conditions and improve the soil so that new plants can become established. Some beneficial bacteria, such as Bacillus, Pseudomonas, and Azotobacter, have been proven to be effective in plant growth promotion and soil remediation.

Microorganisms in the soil also play a role in removing pollutants. They can absorb and transform soil pollutants, reduce the absorption and accumulation of harmful substances, and improve soil fertility by decomposing plant and animal residues. However, it is important to note that not all materials in the soil can be removed by microorganisms, as some harmful substances are toxic or non-bioavailable to them.

The introduction of beneficial microbes can enhance soil fertility, inhibit pathogens, and induce systemic resistance in plants. They can also improve the quality of medicinal plants by removing soil pollutants and reducing the absorption of harmful substances. Overall, microorganisms play a vital role in maintaining soil health and supporting plant growth, but their effectiveness in pollutant removal may be enhanced by combining them with other soil amendments.

The impact of outdoor plants on indoor air pollution

Outdoor plants have been shown to positively impact indoor air pollution. A study from Lancaster University found that having trees between the road and a building can reduce indoor particulate matter by half, acting as a filter for pollutants that might enter through open windows or on shoes. This natural filtration process is enhanced by larger leaves, with evergreens being a preferred option for year-round purification.

However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of current research on this topic. Many studies on air purification by plants are conducted under controlled laboratory conditions, which may not accurately represent real-world environments. For instance, experiments often involve injecting a single VOC into a small, sealed chamber containing a plant, which differs significantly from the diverse VOCs and open spaces of indoor areas.

While plants have the ability to absorb carbon dioxide and other pollutants, the extent of their impact on indoor air quality may be limited. An influential NASA study from 1989 suggested that indoor plants could remove formaldehyde and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from the air. However, translating this into meaningful VOC reduction in a real-world setting would require a substantial number of plants in a well-lit space.

The benefits of outdoor plants extend beyond air purification. They can improve soil health, enhance overall indoor environments, and provide mental health advantages. Air-quality experts and horticultural scientists recognize the positive impact of plants, even if their air purification abilities may be modest.

In conclusion, while outdoor plants can positively influence indoor air pollution, it is important to manage expectations. The impact of plants on indoor air quality is influenced by various factors, including plant species, combination of plants, and real-world conditions. Nevertheless, incorporating outdoor plants is a natural and environmentally friendly step towards improving indoor air quality and creating a healthier living or working space.

Frequently asked questions