Human Ashes: Water Pollution And Environmental Impact

The popularity of cremation has increased in recent years, with many people choosing to scatter the ashes of their loved ones in natural beauty spots. However, this has led to concerns about the potential environmental impact of human ashes on water sources. While there is no evidence that human ashes themselves are harmful to the environment, non-biodegradable items mixed with the ashes, such as plastic or metal, can cause pollution and damage to plant and animal life.

Do Human Ashes Pollute Water?

Human ashes can be scattered at sea, but there are rules to follow

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is the primary regulator for scattering ashes at sea, and its rules must be strictly followed to avoid any health risks or hazards. According to EPA guidelines, scattering ashes in the ocean is permitted, but it must be done at least three nautical miles offshore. This is to ensure that the ashes are not washed back to shore. The EPA also requires that only biodegradable materials are used during the ceremony, such as urns made from paper, cardboard, natural salt, or other plant-based materials. Real flowers can be scattered with the ashes, but plastic or silk flowers are prohibited.

In addition to EPA regulations, state and local laws may also apply. Some states have specific requirements for scattering ashes in internal, non-ocean waters like lakes and rivers. It is important to contact the relevant state agency, such as the environmental agency or health department, to determine any legal requirements for the specific body of water. For example, the scattering of ashes in inland waters may be prohibited in certain states.

When planning an ash-scattering ceremony at sea, it is important to consider the location and choose a spot far from buildings and areas where people swim or fish. The ceremony should be conducted as close to the water surface as possible, and windy days should be avoided to prevent ashes from blowing onto nearby land.

By following these rules and regulations, families can ensure that they are complying with the law and respecting the environment while commemorating their loved one's connection to the sea.

Human ashes can be scattered on rivers, but permission is needed

The popularity of cremation has been rising, and with it, the trend of scattering human ashes in natural spaces has also grown. Rivers, lakes, and other bodies of water are favoured by families as remembrance spots for their deceased loved ones. While scattering ashes in rivers is not explicitly illegal, it is important to recognise the potential environmental impact and obtain the necessary permissions.

The act of scattering human ashes in a river can have varying effects on the environment. The primary concern lies in the high levels of sodium, calcium and phosphorus present in cremated ashes. These elevated concentrations can significantly influence plant life, stimulating the growth of certain species while adversely affecting others. For instance, in the Indian context, the Mokshda system of pyre cremations has been estimated to avert about 60,000 metric tons of ash from rivers. This reduction in ash disposal in rivers contributes to mitigating the environmental impact on aquatic ecosystems.

Additionally, it is crucial to consider the potential presence of non-biodegradable items mixed with the ashes, such as metal and plastic, which can cause harm to the environment, particularly in water bodies. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in the United States has published a policy specifically addressing the scattering of ashes in rivers and streams to protect the environment from potential pollution. This policy outlines guidelines for scattering ashes in rivers, emphasising the importance of obtaining permission from the relevant authorities.

Before scattering human ashes in a river, it is essential to seek permission from the appropriate governing body or landowner. In the case of inland lakes, rivers, or other bodies of water, state law comes into play, and individuals should contact their respective state's health department or relevant agency to understand the local rules and regulations. For example, in Massachusetts, individuals must contact the Massachusetts Health Department to learn about the specific guidelines for scattering ashes in inland water bodies.

It is worth noting that some boat charter operators specialise in assisting with ash-scattering ceremonies on rivers and can help individuals navigate the necessary permissions and procedures. When performing a scattering ceremony, it is recommended to follow guidelines such as scattering the ashes as close to the water's surface as possible, avoiding windy days, and ensuring that any additional items scattered, such as flowers, are biodegradable to minimise any potential environmental impact.

Burying human ashes is harmful to plant life

Burying human ashes is considered by many to be a natural and safe way to return a deceased loved one to the earth. However, research and firsthand accounts have shown that this practice can be harmful to the environment and plant life.

Human ashes are composed of nutrients that plants require, such as calcium, potassium, and phosphorus. However, they also contain extremely high amounts of salt, which is toxic to most plants and can be leached into the soil, hindering plant growth. This salt content, along with an imbalance of other essential micronutrients, can cause a nutritional imbalance that negatively affects plant health. For example, too much calcium in the soil can reduce the supply of nitrogen and limit photosynthesis.

Additionally, cremation ashes have a very high pH level, which can be detrimental to many plants by preventing the natural release of beneficial nutrients from the soil. While a small amount of human ashes mixed into the soil or spread over a wide area is unlikely to cause harm, a concentrated amount of ashes in one spot can overwhelm the plant life in that area. This is because the ashes, being primarily calcium phosphate, tilt the pH toward acidity, which can be harmful to most plants in high concentrations.

The environmental impact of cremation has come under increasing scrutiny as it has gained popularity over traditional burial methods. While cremation is often marketed as a greener option, it has significant energy requirements and carbon dioxide emissions. In response, some countries have implemented regulations and scrubbing or filtering systems to mitigate the environmental toll of crematoriums.

To minimize the potential harm to plant life, it is recommended to scatter ashes in small amounts over a wide area or mix them with activated charcoal, compost, or soil to dilute the salt and pH levels. Some companies even offer biodegradable urns with specially prepared soil formulated to counteract these issues.

Human ashes can be scattered on private property with permission

The popularity of cremation has led to an increase in people scattering ashes in meaningful locations. However, it is important to understand the rules and regulations surrounding the scattering of cremated remains. While there are no federal laws prohibiting the burial or scattering of ashes on private property, specific state laws and local regulations must be considered.

In the United States, each state has its own regulations regarding the scattering of ashes. While some states, like Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, and Virginia, have no specific laws restricting the scattering of ashes, other states have more defined requirements. For example, California requires that scattered ashes not be distinguishable to the public, and Indiana mandates filing documents with the local county recorder ten days before scattering.

When scattering ashes on private property, it is crucial to obtain permission from the property owner to avoid trespassing and any legal complications. This applies even if the property is owned by a family member or friend. While you have the right to scatter ashes on your own land, scattering on someone else's private property without authorization is prohibited.

Additionally, when scattering ashes, it is important to respect the environment and ensure that only biodegradable materials are used. This means avoiding plastic or silk flowers and choosing urns or memorial items that are environmentally friendly and biodegradable. By following these guidelines, individuals can ensure they are complying with the law and honoring their loved one's wishes in a respectful and eco-conscious manner.

Human ashes can be scattered on land with no lasting effect

The popularity of cremation has soared in recent years, with people seeking greener end-of-life options. As a result, there has been a rise in the scattering of ashes, with people wanting to commemorate their loved ones in meaningful and personal ways.

Scattering ashes on land is a common practice, and it is important to do so with caution and consideration. Legally, it is relatively straightforward to scatter ashes on land, but it does require some research and planning. You may scatter ashes on your own property without any restrictions. However, if you plan to scatter ashes on someone else's property, you must obtain permission from the landowner. It is wise to get written consent to avoid any misunderstandings.

When scattering ashes on public land, such as national parks, you may need to seek approval from the relevant authorities, such as the National Park Service. It is worth noting that some locations, like sports stadiums and amusement parks, are often mistaken for public property but are, in fact, private property. It is crucial to understand this distinction, as scattering ashes without permission on private property is considered trespassing and is illegal.

To ensure a respectful and environmentally conscious scattering, it is important to be mindful of other people and the environment. Many laws related to scattering ashes specify staying away from heavily used public areas to avoid interfering with others' activities. Additionally, it is recommended to use common sense and only scatter biodegradable items along with the ashes to avoid leaving anything behind that might harm wildlife or the environment.

Overall, while scattering human ashes on land can be done without causing lasting effects, it is important to follow legal and ethical guidelines to ensure a meaningful and environmentally friendly commemoration.

Frequently asked questions