Electric Cars: Emitting Pollution Or A Clean Future?

Electric vehicles (EVs) are widely considered to be a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gas-powered cars. While they do not produce tailpipe emissions, there is some debate about whether EVs emit pollution in other ways, such as through brake and tyre wear, as well as the emissions produced during the manufacturing process and electricity generation. Studies have shown that EVs can improve air quality and reduce carbon pollution, but the extent of their environmental benefits depends on various factors, including weight, electricity sources, and the type of car they are replacing.

Electric cars produce less pollution than petrol and diesel cars

Electric vehicles (EVs) produce less pollution than petrol and diesel cars. Firstly, they do not have tailpipes, so they do not emit tailpipe emissions, which account for 74% of gas-powered cars' life cycle emissions. By comparison, electric vehicles produce less than half as many life cycle emissions as gas-powered cars.

However, electric vehicles are, on average, 30% heavier than petrol and diesel cars, which causes their brakes and tyre treads to wear out faster, releasing tiny, potentially toxic particles into the atmosphere. Research suggests that tyre wear is a significant source of particulate matter pollution, with tyres potentially emitting 9.28 grams of particulate matter per mile. However, another source claims that tyre wear is less of a concern, as the particles emitted from tyres are larger, and therefore less problematic for air quality and human health.

Another factor to consider is how the electricity used to power electric vehicles is generated. In states that rely on renewable energy sources, such as California, electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, whereas in states that rely heavily on fossil fuels, such as West Virginia, electric vehicles produce more emissions. However, even in states that rely on fossil fuels, electric vehicles still produce fewer emissions than petrol and diesel cars. As the electric power sector continues to transition to cleaner energy sources, the emissions associated with electric vehicles are expected to decrease further.

Overall, while electric vehicles are not a perfect solution and do not completely eliminate pollution, they produce significantly less pollution than petrol and diesel cars, and their adoption is linked to improved air quality and health outcomes, particularly in underserved communities that are disproportionately affected by pollution.

Electric cars are heavier, causing more brake and tyre wear

Electric cars do not emit tailpipe emissions, unlike gas-powered vehicles, which produce the largest amount of tailpipe emissions. However, electric vehicles (EVs) are heavier than gas-powered vehicles, and this weight disparity has implications for brake and tyre wear.

On average, EVs are 30% heavier than their gas-powered counterparts, leading to faster brake and tyre tread wear. This wear releases tiny particles, often toxic, into the atmosphere. The increased weight of EVs also contributes to more frequent brake and tyre replacements, potentially offsetting the environmental benefits of reduced tailpipe emissions.

Tyre wear in EVs is influenced by several factors. Firstly, the instant delivery of torque in EVs exposes tyres to a higher load from pull away, resulting in accelerated tyre wear. Secondly, the surplus of powertrain torque makes it challenging to drive EVs gently, further exacerbating tyre degradation. Additionally, the all-wheel drive in EVs, while enhancing safety and traction, distributes tyre wear across all four tyres, impacting each tyre's lifespan.

Despite the heavier weight of EVs, studies suggest that a switch to these vehicles would still reduce PM2.5 emissions, even when considering their weight. This reduction is more significant when EVs have regenerative braking. Furthermore, James Rooney, a fleet engineer at British Gas, noted that their large, heavy electric vans had covered 15,000 miles without requiring tyre or brake replacements, except for punctures.

While EVs may experience more brake and tyre wear due to their weight, it is important to consider other factors affecting tyre degradation, such as driving conditions and torque modulation. Additionally, the absence of tailpipe emissions in EVs improves air quality compared to petrol and diesel cars, even if EVs don't entirely eliminate air pollution.

Tyre wear releases large amounts of tiny, harmful particles

Electric vehicles (EVs) are, on average, 30% heavier than gas-powered vehicles. This causes the brakes and tyre treads to wear out faster, releasing tiny, often toxic particles into the atmosphere. Tyre wear particles (TWPs) are emitted continuously as vehicles travel. They range from visible pieces of rubber or plastic to microparticles. According to Emissions Analytics, a car's four tyres collectively emit one trillion ultrafine particles per kilometre driven. These particles can pass through lung tissue into the bloodstream and cross the blood-brain barrier, or be breathed in and travel directly to the brain, causing a range of problems.

Tyre emissions are a significant source of microplastics in urban runoff and contain unique and highly potent toxic substances. They are transported through various atmospheric, terrestrial, and aquatic routes in the natural and built environments. Tyre particles are a major component of microplastics in urban runoff, and their production and use generate multiple heavy metals, plastics, PAHs, and other compounds that can be toxic alone or in combination. The environmental and health risks associated with tyre wear particles are well-documented. Ecotoxicological studies have shown effects on aquatic organisms, and a recent risk assessment indicates a low risk of health effects in humans via inhalation, but there is no information on the risk caused by intake via the food chain.

The chemical 6PPD, added to tyres to prevent cracking and degradation, transforms into 6PPD-q when exposed to ground-level ozone. This compound is acutely toxic to several fish species, including coho salmon. While electric vehicles do not produce tailpipe emissions, the weight of EVs contributes to increased tyre and brake wear, which can release significant amounts of metallic particles and organic chemicals into the environment.

Some solutions to the problem of tyre emissions are being explored. For example, The Tyre Collective, a UK-based clean-tech startup, has developed an electrostatic plate that captures up to 60% of particles emitted by tyres and brakes, storing them for reuse in new tyres. In San Francisco, scientists found that rain gardens installed in yards not only captured stormwater but also trapped 100% of black rubbery fragments, preventing them from entering waterways.

Electric cars reduce harmful ground-level ozone

Electric vehicles (EVs) are widely considered to be a much cleaner alternative to traditional cars. They have zero direct emissions, making the air we breathe cleaner and safer. However, there are still question marks surrounding their overall environmental impact.

EVs do not emit pollutants through a tailpipe, but they are heavier than traditional cars, which causes their brakes and tyre treads to wear out faster, releasing tiny, often toxic particles into the atmosphere. This is a significant issue, as tyre wear is a major source of air pollution. However, EVs with regenerative braking emit less pollution as the system saves the brake pads and rotors, reducing maintenance costs.

EVs also contribute to ground-level ozone pollution, which is very harmful to human health. Ground-level ozone is a noxious pollutant that causes eye and respiratory irritation, reduced lung function, and is suspected to aggravate cardiovascular function. It is formed in the atmosphere through a complex set of chemical reactions involving hydrocarbons, oxides of nitrogen, and sunlight. Cars, buses, trucks, and construction vehicles are major contributors to these emissions.

While EVs may contribute to ground-level ozone, they still reduce overall ozone levels compared to traditional cars. Gasoline and LPG's per-kilometre ozone impact is 44-88% of diesel's, and when fuel production is added, liquid fuels generate 48-80% of electricity's impact. Therefore, switching to EVs will reduce ozone levels, especially in urban areas where air pollution is a significant issue.

In conclusion, while EVs may not be entirely pollution-free, they are still a much cleaner alternative to traditional cars. They reduce harmful ground-level ozone levels, improve air quality, and lower maintenance costs for drivers.

Electric cars improve air quality in cities

Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a solution to cutting emissions and improving air quality in cities. While they do not completely eliminate pollution, they can significantly reduce air pollution compared to petrol and diesel cars. This is especially true for nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds, which are dominant factors in the creation of smog.

A study by UCLA found that electric vehicle travel improves air quality for all, but disadvantaged communities still face higher pollution levels. The study noted that electric vehicle ownership is higher in wealthier neighbourhoods, and the traffic corridors running through low-income neighbourhoods remain heavily polluted by gas-powered vehicles. This highlights the need for policies that incentivise lower-income households to adopt zero-emission vehicles.

Another study by Timmers and Achten (2015) compared emissions from petrol cars and EVs with different levels of regenerative braking. They found that EVs emit slightly less PM2.5, and if EVs were the same weight as petrol cars, their emissions would be even lower. Additionally, EVs with regenerative braking further reduce emissions.

While EVs may be heavier than traditional cars, resulting in more pollution from brake, tyre, and road wear, they still offer overall pollution reduction. The extent of this reduction depends on factors such as vehicle weight, the type of car replaced, and the electricity mix used to power the EV.

To maximise the benefits of EVs in improving air quality in cities, it is essential to transition to cleaner energy sources for electricity production and address the emissions associated with battery manufacturing.

Frequently asked questions