Cruise Ships: Ocean Polluters Or Sustainable Voyagers?

Cruise ships are a major source of air, water, and land pollution, affecting fragile ecosystems and marine life. With the cruise industry expanding rapidly, cruise ships are dumping enormous amounts of sewage, food waste, oily wastewater, plastics, and other pollutants into the ocean, destroying coral reefs and marine life. Air pollution from cruise ships contributes to respiratory and cardiovascular problems, and their economic benefits to port cities are hotly debated. As environmental concerns grow, port cities are considering restrictions or bans on cruise ships.

Cruise ships release untreated sewage into the ocean

While modern cruise ships have sophisticated water treatment facilities, the problem lies in the inadequate regulations and enforcement surrounding the treatment and disposal of sewage. In the United States, for example, cruise ships are permitted to dump treated waste into the ocean if they are within three and a half miles from the shore. Beyond this point, there are no restrictions on dumping untreated sewage into ocean waters. This lack of regulation has led to a significant amount of sewage being dumped into the ocean, with an estimated one billion gallons of sewage discharged annually.

The sewage released by cruise ships contains harmful pollutants, including chemicals, pharmaceuticals, bacteria, viruses, heavy metals, and hazardous waste. These pollutants have severe impacts on marine ecosystems, including coral reefs, manatees, shellfish, and fish. The increased waste in the ocean contributes to pollution and oxygen depletion, and the added nitrogen and phosphorus promote algae blooms, which can suffocate marine life.

The release of untreated sewage into the ocean is not limited to the United States. Cruise ships operating in Europe have also been identified as significant contributors to water pollution. The issue has gained attention from activists and environmental organizations, who advocate for stricter regulations and a reduction in cruise ship activity to mitigate the environmental damage caused by these vessels.

The public, including cruise passengers, are increasingly concerned about the impact of sewage dumping on ocean health. Surveys have shown that a majority of cruise customers support requiring cruise ships to upgrade their onboard waste treatment facilities and are even willing to pay a premium to ensure that raw sewage is not dumped into the ocean. Despite growing awareness and calls for change, the cruise industry's response has been inadequate, with pollution from cruise ships remaining a pervasive issue.

Cruise ships damage coral reefs

Cruise ships have a significant impact on the health of coral reefs. They contribute to water pollution, which negatively affects coral reefs, and their large anchors and anchor chains can cause irreparable damage to coral reef ecosystems.

Coral reefs are incredibly important for the health of the planet and the oceans. They provide a habitat for a vast array of marine life, with one-quarter of all marine species relying on coral reefs at some point in their lives. They also provide coastal protection, are a source of tourism, and are aesthetically beautiful.

Cruise ships, however, present a number of threats to coral reefs. Firstly, they contribute to water pollution. Cruise ships dump sewage, food waste, and oily wastewater into the ocean. This waste contains bacteria, viruses, parasites, chemicals, heavy metals, and toxins, which can cause toxic algae blooms. These blooms are a major threat to coral reefs as they decrease oxygen levels and alter the chemical balance of the water.

Secondly, cruise ships physically damage coral reefs with their anchors and anchor chains. Coral reefs are often found in shallow, sensitive areas, and when a cruise ship anchors above a reef, the anchor and chain can scrape and damage the coral. This damage can be irreparable, and even if the reef can recover, it may take up to 50 years.

In addition to anchoring, coral reefs are also threatened by cruise ship groundings, oil spills, salvage efforts, dredging, propeller wash, and towing cable drags. In some cases, cruise ships may even destroy coral reefs to build docks and channels to get into port.

The impact of cruise ships on coral reefs has been well-documented. In 2017, a British-owned cruise ship, the Caledonian Sky, ran aground at Raja Ampat, one of Indonesia's most popular dive sites, damaging approximately 1,600 square meters of coral. In 2015, off the coast of Grand Cayman, two scuba divers witnessed the Pullmantur Zenith cruise ship lower its anchor onto a coral reef. In 2010, a Chinese cargo ship ran aground on the Great Barrier Reef, causing serious damage to the coral.

Given the significant and well-documented impact of cruise ships on coral reefs, it is clear that urgent action is needed to mitigate this damage. This may include expanding marine protected areas, regulating shipping, installing advanced sewage treatment systems, implementing garbage management plans, and abolishing destructive practices. With concerted efforts, it may be possible to reduce the damage caused by cruise ships and preserve the delicate beauty and vital importance of coral reefs.

Cruise ships emit air pollutants

The use of traditional marine fuel, such as diesel, contributes significantly to air pollution. Cruise ships that do not use liquefied natural gas (LNG) often rely on these fuels, releasing harmful emissions into the air. In an effort to reduce sulphur emissions, some ships use scrubbers, which spray seawater into the exhaust pipes. However, this practice leads to water pollution as the resulting polluted seawater is often discharged into the ocean, altering its chemical balance.

The impact of air pollution from cruise ships is far-reaching. Sulphur dioxide emissions cause respiratory and cardiovascular problems and are a key component of acid rain. According to NGO Transport & Environment (T&E), the 218 cruise ships operating in Europe in 2022 emitted more than four times the amount of sulphur oxides than all the continent's cars combined. This has led to increasing calls for restrictions on cruise ships in port cities across Europe.

In addition to sulphur oxides, cruise ships also emit nitrogen oxides, which are a significant ingredient in smog. An air monitoring study in Skagway, Alaska, found levels of nitrogen oxide five to ten times higher than at other sites in the state with fewer cruise ships. The elevated levels of air pollution near cruise ship ports have been documented by environmental coordinators, further highlighting the impact of these vessels.

The cruise industry's contribution to air pollution is significant, and it is important to recognize that it is just one aspect of the broader environmental impact of cruise ships. The pollution from these ships extends beyond air quality to include water pollution, noise pollution, and damage to marine ecosystems, including coral reefs. As the industry continues to grow, it is crucial to address these environmental concerns and push for more sustainable practices in the cruise industry.

Cruise ships produce plastic waste

Cruise ships produce a large amount of plastic waste, which is detrimental to marine life and the environment. The cruise industry is a multi-billion-dollar industry that has been criticised for its negative impact on the oceans and the planet. While some companies have made efforts to reduce their plastic waste, the problem persists, with cruise ships still dumping plastic and other waste into the ocean.

Cruise ships generate a significant amount of garbage, with hundreds of staff and thousands of passengers on board. This waste includes plastic waste, such as single-use plastic food ware and packaging. In the past, some cruise lines have been caught dumping plastic and other garbage into the ocean, despite it being against US and international maritime law. While there are regulations in place to prevent plastic pollution, such as the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL), the problem continues.

From 1993 to 1998, cruise ships were involved in 87 confirmed cases of illegal discharges of plastic waste into US waters, resulting in millions of dollars in fines. In recent years, companies such as Carnival Corp. and Royal Caribbean have been fined for violating pollution regulations and illegally discharging plastic waste. Despite these fines, the problem persists, with cruise ships still dumping plastic waste into the ocean.

Plastic waste from cruise ships can have detrimental effects on marine life and the environment. It can take hundreds of years for plastic to degrade, and during that time, it can be ingested by marine animals, causing harm or death. Plastic waste can also contribute to the creation of "dead zones" in the ocean, areas with low oxygen levels due to algae growth fuelled by contaminants from plastic waste.

To reduce the impact of plastic waste from cruise ships, some companies have implemented new environmental strategies, such as using reusable plastic containers and cutlery, as well as recycling programs. However, more stringent regulations and enforcement of existing laws are needed to truly address the problem. Individuals can also play a role by choosing cruise lines with strong environmental policies and reporting any observed dumping of plastic waste into the ocean.

Cruise ships generate greywater

Cruise ships generate a significant amount of greywater, which is defined by the International Maritime Organization as "the drainage from dishwater, shower, laundry, bath, and washbasin drains". Greywater is a form of wastewater that can contain harmful pollutants, including bacteria, chemicals, heavy metals, and oily waste.

Greywater discharges from cruise ships can have a significant impact on the environment. As passenger vessels, cruise ships have a high occupancy, which results in a substantial volume of greywater being produced and discharged. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) estimates that the sewage discharge rate on passenger vessels is 8.4 gallons per day per person, while greywater discharges can range from 45 to 65 gallons per day per person.

Cruise ships typically have two types of wastewater treatment facilities: Type I and Type II Marine Sanitation Devices (MSDs). Type II MSDs are more advanced and can treat both blackwater and greywater using biological treatment and disinfection methods. However, not all cruise ships are equipped with Type II MSDs, and even when they are, illegal discharges of untreated greywater can still occur.

The discharge of greywater from cruise ships is regulated by Annex IV to the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL), which has been in effect since 2003. However, there are limited monitoring and enforcement mechanisms in place, and cruise ships have been caught illegally discharging untreated greywater into the ocean.

The impact of greywater on the marine environment is significant. Greywater from cruise ships has been found to contain high concentrations of microplastics, which can have harmful effects on marine life and ecosystems. Additionally, untreated greywater can contain high levels of fecal coliform and other contaminants, similar to domestic sewage, further degrading water quality and posing risks to human health.

To address the issue of greywater pollution from cruise ships, there are several potential solutions. Firstly, stricter enforcement of existing regulations and the implementation of additional international laws to regulate greywater discharges are necessary. Secondly, improving wastewater treatment technologies and ensuring all cruise ships are equipped with advanced treatment systems can help reduce the environmental impact of greywater. Finally, promoting sustainable travel choices and supporting organizations like Friends of the Earth that advocate for reducing cruise ship pollution can drive industry-wide change.

Frequently asked questions