Cruise Ships: Polluting Our Oceans And Atmosphere?

Cruise ships are a popular choice for holidaymakers, with around 20 million passengers per year. However, their impact on the environment has been a cause for concern. From air pollution to waste disposal, cruise ships have been accused of causing significant harm to the planet. With their enormous engines, they burn vast amounts of fuel, emitting high levels of greenhouse gases and other harmful pollutants. The issue is exacerbated by the fact that they are allowed to burn dirtier fuel than what is permitted on land. In addition to air pollution, cruise ships also contribute to water pollution and plastic pollution, with sewage and solid waste often ending up in the ocean, posing risks to marine life and humans alike.

Air pollution from emissions

Cruise ships are a major source of air pollution, emitting harmful gases and particulate matter that contribute to global warming, climate change, and air quality issues in surrounding areas, including coastal cities and ports. The emissions from these ships, including greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide, have a significant impact on the environment and human health.

One of the primary concerns regarding cruise ship emissions is the release of sulfur dioxide, a harmful gas that can cause respiratory problems and acid rain. Studies have shown that sulfur dioxide emissions from cruise liners are higher than those of other types of ships, and these emissions peak when the ships are docked. The issue of sulfur dioxide emissions has led to the implementation of regulations, such as the International Maritime Organization's (IMO) 2020 rules, mandating the use of fuels with lower sulfur content. While these regulations are a positive step, more needs to be done to mitigate the impact of cruise ship emissions.

Cruise ships also contribute significantly to nitrogen oxide emissions, which have been associated with respiratory diseases and lung cancer. Additionally, the burning of fossil fuels on these ships releases particulate matter, specifically PM2.5, which can have detrimental effects on human health. The increase in the number of cruise ships, the time they spend around ports, and the fuel they consume have all contributed to a rise in these harmful emissions.

The environmental impact of cruise ships is further exacerbated by their enormous fuel consumption. The largest cruise ships can burn up to 300,000 litres of fuel per day, leading to carbon footprints comparable to those of millions of cars. The adoption of alternative fuels, such as LNG, is gaining traction in the industry, but concerns have been raised about methane leaks, which contribute to climate change.

While the cruise industry has made commitments to reducing emissions and developing cleaner fuels, environmental groups remain sceptical about their ability to achieve net-zero carbon goals by 2050. The implementation of shore power at ports, where docked ships can plug into electricity instead of running their engines, is one potential solution to reducing air pollution. Additionally, increasing public awareness about the environmental impact of cruise ships can drive demand for more sustainable practices and technologies in the industry.

Sewage waste

Cruise ships produce a large volume of sewage waste, which can contain harmful pathogens, bacteria, chemicals, pharmaceuticals, heavy metals, and hazardous waste. In the past, cruise ships routinely dumped untreated sewage directly into the ocean, posing risks to marine life and humans. This practice continues today, despite regulations prohibiting the discharge of untreated sewage within certain distances from shore. The U.S., for example, allows cruise ships to dump treated waste within three and a half miles of the shore, and beyond that, there are no restrictions on dumping untreated sewage.

The discharge of untreated or inadequately treated sewage can have severe ecological and health consequences. Harmful bacteria and pathogens in the sewage can cause health issues for marine life, including fish, dolphins, and whales. It can also pose risks to humans who come into contact with contaminated water, such as swimmers or beachgoers. The sewage can contain harmful bacteria that can cause skin infections, respiratory problems, and other health issues.

Additionally, the sewage waste from cruise ships can contribute to nutrient pollution in the ocean. High levels of nitrogen and phosphorus in sewage can cause algae blooms, which can suffocate and harm coral reefs, marine mammals, and fish. This adds to the problem of pollution and oxygen depletion in the waters.

To address these issues, modern cruise ships have implemented advanced sewage treatment systems. These systems treat sewage extensively onboard to remove harmful materials before releasing the treated water into the ocean. However, not all cruise lines have installed these advanced treatment systems, and there are still concerns about the adequacy of regulations governing sewage waste disposal.

Furthermore, while the treatment of sewage waste has improved, the sheer volume of waste generated by cruise ships remains a challenge. With modern cruise ships carrying up to 7,600 passengers, the amount of sewage produced can be significant. Properly treating and disposing of this waste requires adequate infrastructure and stringent regulations to ensure it does not cause harm to the ocean and its ecosystems.

Plastic pollution

The issue of plastic pollution from cruise ships is exacerbated by illegal dumping practices. Despite regulations prohibiting the discharge of plastic waste into the ocean, some cruise lines have been fined for doing just that. For example, in 2019, Carnival Corporation and its subsidiary, Princess Cruise Lines, were fined $20 million for illegally throwing plastic into the ocean. This was not an isolated incident, as Princess Cruise Lines had previously paid a $40 million fine in 2016 for similar offences.

The environmental impact of plastic pollution from cruise ships is significant. Marine wildlife and ecosystems are severely affected by the presence of plastic waste in their habitats. Plastic pollution can lead to the destruction of coral reefs, which are vital shelter for a quarter of marine species globally. Additionally, plastic waste can entangle or be ingested by marine animals, leading to injury or death.

To address plastic pollution, some cruise lines have implemented initiatives to reduce their plastic waste. For instance, Princess Cruises and Royal Caribbean Cruise Line have adopted reusable items, such as switching from single-use plastic packaging to reusable containers for food and cutlery. Recycling programs have also been introduced, with some ships installing compactors to condense plastics and make them easily recyclable upon returning to port. These efforts are crucial in mitigating the environmental impact of plastic pollution caused by cruise ships.

While the cruise industry is taking steps towards reducing plastic pollution, stronger regulations and enforcement are necessary to ensure compliance across the sector. The high profitability of the industry means that fines often do not serve as a sufficient deterrent, and more stringent measures may be required to bring about meaningful change.

Sulfur dioxide emissions

Cruise ships emit large amounts of sulfur dioxide, contributing to air pollution and acid rain. A single large cruise ship emits about the same amount of sulfur dioxide as 3.6 million cars. In 2017, Carnival Corporation, the world's largest cruise operator, emitted more sulfur dioxide around Europe's coasts than all of Europe's cars combined multiplied by ten. This is because the fuel used by cruise ships emits about 2,000 times more sulfur oxides than normal diesel fuel.

The high emissions of sulfur dioxide from cruise ships have significant environmental and health impacts. Sulfur oxide emissions form sulfate aerosols that contribute to health risks in humans, including respiratory illnesses such as asthma and various types of cancer. They also contribute to the formation of acid rain, which has detrimental effects on marine ecosystems, killing fish, coral, trees, and dolphins.

To address the issue of sulfur dioxide emissions from cruise ships, several measures have been proposed and implemented:

• The International Maritime Organization (IMO) has set targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from shipping by 50% by 2050 compared to 2008 levels.
• The IMO's shipping fuel rule lowered the sulfur content limit of ship fuel from 3.5% to 0.5% in 2020, reducing sulfur emissions from individual ships.
• Some cities, such as Venice and Amsterdam, have imposed restrictions or outright bans on large cruise ships to mitigate their detrimental effects on air quality, marine ecosystems, and cultural landmarks.
• Ports can encourage ships to plug into electricity instead of running their engines, reducing emissions.
• The adoption of alternative fuels, such as liquefied natural gas (LNG), is being explored as a cleaner alternative, although it still emits carbon dioxide and methane.

Despite these efforts, critics argue that more urgent action is needed as the cruise industry continues to expand. The increasing number of cruise ships and the time spent at ports contribute to rising sulfur dioxide emissions, posing risks to both the environment and public health.

Water pollution

The cruise industry is a multi-billion-dollar industry that is a significant source of pollution in oceanic and marine areas. Cruise ships generate billions of gallons of waste, including sewage, greywater, oily wastewater, and food waste, which is pumped into the oceans and contributes to water pollution. This waste contains harmful chemicals, metals, and minerals that have a detrimental effect on marine ecosystems.

Cruise ships also release ballast water, which is used to stabilize the boat while travelling. This ballast water is often filled in one region and discharged in another, releasing microbes, microorganisms, vegetation, and sea animals that can cause ecological damage to local species.

In addition, cruise ships have been known to illegally dump plastic waste and other garbage into the ocean. This includes plastic straws, food waste, and aluminum. Fines have been imposed on some companies, but these often do not serve as a sufficient deterrent as they are a negligible fraction of the companies' annual revenue.

The impact of cruise ship water pollution is far-reaching. It affects marine life, such as whales, dolphins, and coral reefs. The noise pollution from ships' machinery and entertainment activities disturbs marine animals, and the physical presence of the ships can cause damage to coral reefs, which are already struggling due to water pollution.

Despite the growing concerns about pollution and emissions, the cruise industry continues to grow, with projections showing that it will continue to expand in the coming years. However, there are efforts being made to reduce pollution, with the development of new technologies and the push for cleaner fuel alternatives.

Frequently asked questions