Air Purifiers: Friend Or Foe In The Air Quality War?

Air purifiers are household appliances that improve indoor air quality by removing airborne pollutants from circulation. They are designed to reduce or eliminate allergens and pollutants such as dust, pollen, smoke, and pet dander. However, there is a concern that some air purifiers, particularly electronic ones, may produce ozone and other pollutants that can be hazardous to health. While air purifiers can help improve air quality, they should be part of a comprehensive strategy that includes proper ventilation and source control to effectively reduce indoor air pollution.

Air purifiers can reduce some health risks, but not all

Air purifiers can be an important strategy for improving indoor air quality and reducing certain health risks. They work by drawing in air and passing it through a filter, which captures pollutants and particles, and then pushing the clean air back into the room. However, it's important to note that air purifiers cannot eliminate all health risks associated with indoor air pollution.

One of the main benefits of air purifiers is their ability to reduce allergens and pollutants, such as dust, smoke, pollen, and pet dander. This can be especially helpful for individuals with allergies or asthma, as it may lessen their symptoms and triggers. For example, HEPA air purifiers can reduce particulate matter (PM2.5) by an average of 50% or more. Additionally, some air purifiers can reduce airborne particles containing viruses, bacteria, and fungi, which may lower the risk of respiratory illnesses.

However, air purifiers have limitations and may not be effective against all types of pollutants. For example, portable air purifiers may struggle with larger, heavier allergens, such as dust mites and pollen, which can settle to the ground faster than the purifier can capture them. Additionally, while some air purifiers claim to remove mould, they do not prevent mould growth, and the source of moisture must be addressed to mitigate this issue.

Another concern is the type of air purifier used. Electronic air cleaners and ozone-generators are not recommended for home use due to health and safety risks. These devices can produce ozone, a gas that can irritate the lungs and aggravate asthma conditions. Instead, filtered air purifiers with HEPA filters are considered safer and more effective for removing particulate matter from the air.

Furthermore, air purifiers should be part of a comprehensive approach to improving indoor air quality. Proper ventilation, regular cleaning, and source control of pollutants are crucial for maintaining healthy indoor air. Air purifiers work best in conjunction with these measures, and a well-ventilated space can reduce the workload on the purifier. Additionally, it's important to position the purifier in an open area and clean or replace the filters regularly to maintain its efficiency.

Air purifiers are ineffective at preventing mould growth

While air purifiers can help reduce airborne mould spores, they are unable to eliminate mould growing on or beneath surfaces like walls and floors. Therefore, it is essential to identify and address the root cause of mould, which is typically related to moisture and humidity levels.

Additionally, when selecting an air purifier, it is important to consider the type of filter it uses. HEPA filters are recommended as they effectively capture mould spores without emitting ozone, a potential lung irritant. However, UV light filters, which claim to destroy mould, often require higher wattage and more extended exposure times to be effective, and they can also damage HEPA filters over time.

Furthermore, air purifiers should be part of a comprehensive strategy for maintaining healthy indoor air. They should be combined with other measures such as regular cleaning, proper ventilation, and addressing common sources of pollutants to effectively reduce indoor air pollution.

In summary, air purifiers alone are ineffective at preventing mould growth. They should be used alongside other measures to address the root cause of mould, which is typically related to moisture and humidity levels.

Air purifiers are not a silver bullet solution

Firstly, it is important to note that no air purifier can eliminate all pollutants from a home or even 100% of one pollutant. Portable air purifiers, in particular, may not be effective for larger, heavier allergens, such as dust mites and pollen, which may settle to the ground more quickly than the purifier can capture them.

Secondly, the effectiveness of an air purifier depends on several factors, including the specific type of air purifier and how well it matches the user's needs. For example, HEPA air purifiers can reduce gaseous pollutants, but studies have shown inconsistent results. UV filters, which claim to destroy biological impurities like mold or bacteria, often require higher wattage and greater exposure to be effective, and some bacteria are UV-resistant. Reusable filters are generally good at removing larger particles, but they require meticulous maintenance and are therefore not usually found on the most effective air purifiers.

Thirdly, air purifiers may not perform as well in real-life situations as they do in carefully controlled laboratory tests. A 2024 analysis found that portable air cleaners removed on average 49% of 2.5-micron particles and 44% of 10-micron particles, which is far less than what is often promised by manufacturers.

Finally, air purifiers work best when used in conjunction with other measures to reduce indoor air pollution. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) recommends working to reduce common sources of pollutants and increasing fresh airflow in the home. This can be achieved through regular cleaning, proper ventilation, and source control, such as eliminating or controlling the sources of pollution.

In conclusion, while air purifiers can be a helpful tool for improving indoor air quality, they should not be relied upon as the sole solution. A combination of strategies, including proper ventilation, source control, and the use of proven air cleaning methods, will be most effective in maintaining healthy indoor air.

Air purifiers may not perform as well in real-life situations

Air purifiers are intended to improve indoor air quality by removing airborne pollutants from circulation. They are particularly useful for reducing allergic symptoms, lessening asthma triggers, and reducing dust particles. However, it is important to note that air purifiers may not perform as well in real-life situations as they do in carefully controlled laboratory tests.

Firstly, it is worth noting that the effectiveness of an air purifier depends on various factors, including the specific type of purifier, the user's goals, and the indoor environment. Portable air purifiers, for example, are designed to filter the air in a single room, while whole-house air purification systems are integrated into the HVAC system. Additionally, different types of air purifiers use different technologies, such as HEPA filters, ionizers, or ozone generators, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

One of the main reasons air purifiers may not perform as well in real-life situations is because particles can embed themselves in furniture, bedding, carpets, and other surfaces. This means that simply filtering the air may not be enough to completely remove pollutants from the indoor environment. Regular cleaning and proper ventilation are crucial to ensuring that pollutants are not reintroduced into the air.

Another factor that can affect the performance of air purifiers in real-life situations is the location, installation, flow rate, and runtime. These variables can differ significantly from controlled laboratory conditions, and the constant emergence of new pollutants can also impact the effectiveness of air purifiers over time.

Furthermore, it is important to consider the limitations of air purifiers in terms of the types of particles they can remove. While they are effective at capturing particles like dust, smoke, and pollen, they may struggle with larger, heavier allergens, such as dust mites and pollen, which can settle to the ground faster than the purifier can capture them. Additionally, air purifiers may not be effective at filtering out gases and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) without the use of additional absorbents like activated carbon.

In conclusion, while air purifiers can be a useful tool for improving indoor air quality, they should not be relied upon as a standalone solution. To maximize their effectiveness, it is important to combine their use with other strategies, such as regular cleaning, proper ventilation, and addressing the sources of pollution.

Air purifiers are not all equally effective

Air purifiers can indeed neutralise some of the risks posed by indoor air pollution, but not all purifiers are equally effective, and many don't live up to their marketing hype. While a well-designed appliance is key, even the best air purifier can't do it all. A good air purifier should be part of a multi-pronged strategy for maintaining healthy indoor air, not seen as a silver bullet solution.

The most important variable in an air purifier is the filter. Your best choice to filter particles is a device with a HEPA filter, which is designed to collect at least 99.5% of particles in the air that are 3 microns or less in size. Generally speaking, this type of particle includes pollen, dust, moisture, bacteria, viruses, and dirt. The effectiveness of a HEPA filter depends on how tightly bound the fibres are. This is usually expressed as a rating from MERV 12 to MERV 17. You want a filter that is at least MERV 13.

Another important variable is the clean air delivery rate (CADR). This is the amount of clean air your device will re-circulate. The general rule is that the CADR of your air cleaner should be equal to at least two-thirds of the room's area. For wildfire smoke, the CADR should be higher, equal to the number of square feet of the room you are trying to clean.

Some air purifiers use ionizers to help attract particles like static. Negative ions bond to dust and allergens and make them settle out of the air. If you're interested in buying an air cleaner that uses ionizers, make sure it does not produce dangerous levels of ozone, a gas made up of three oxygen atoms that is often marketed as helping to break down pollutants, because ozone could be a lung irritant and further aggravate any asthma conditions. Usually, air purifiers that emit ozone will have that listed on the packaging or in the marketing descriptions.

Portable air cleaners are the least effective way to clean the air, but they can be a good supplement to ventilation. Filtering air cleaners with High-Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) filters are recommended because they do not emit ozone but do remove particulate matter from the air. Electronic air cleaners (e.g. ionizers) and ozone-generators are not recommended due to the health and safety concerns of the ozone and other potential pollutants they can emit.

Frequently asked questions