Ontario's Air: Coal Phase Out Impact

In 2005, Ontario began phasing out its coal-fired power plants, with the largest being the Lambton and Nanticoke facilities in southern Ontario. This was done to reduce smog-related air contaminants and improve health outcomes. While the coal phase-out did lead to a reduction in air pollution and improvements in air quality, the impact on overall air quality was modest. The phase-out was associated with a reduction in average urban PM2.5 levels by about 6-12%, but there was no significant effect on NOx levels. The specific health benefits of the coal phase-out will take time to understand and quantify, but the health and environmental benefits have been felt across Ontario, and similar actions are being taken across Canada and the world.

The impact of coal phase-out on air pollution

In 2005, Ontario began phasing out its coal-fired power plants, with the largest being the Lambton and Nanticoke facilities in southern Ontario. This move was based on a cost-benefit analysis that estimated annual savings of around $3 billion in the healthcare system due to reduced smog-related air contaminants. However, the analysis also projected that the phase-out would only have a modest effect on air quality, as electric power generation contributed only a small amount to particulate and ozone pollution at the time.

The coal phase-out in Ontario did lead to a reduction in average urban fine particulate levels (PM2.5) by approximately 6-12%, but this decrease was not statistically significant in Toronto or Hamilton. There was no noticeable impact on nitrogen oxide (NOx) levels, which were primarily influenced by the reduction in NOx emissions from the US. Additionally, while there was a significant decrease in peak ground-level ozone (O3) levels, this was offset by a rise associated with natural gas plant emissions.

Overall, the elimination of coal-fired power plants yielded minor improvements in air quality in certain locations, consistent with pre-closure projections. These improvements were comparable to the expected outcomes of installing new pollution control systems rather than shutting down the plants. This has important implications for understanding the costs and benefits of transitioning away from coal.

Despite the modest air quality improvements, the coal phase-out in Ontario brought about a significant reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. From 2005 to 2014, the province's energy sector witnessed a nearly 20% decrease in greenhouse gas emissions, contributing to an overall 7% decline across Ontario. This reduction is equivalent to taking 7 million cars off the road, highlighting the substantial environmental impact of the phase-out.

Moreover, the health benefits of cleaner air are well-established. Smog can irritate the respiratory system, damage lung function, and aggravate asthma. While the specific health impacts of the coal phase-out will take time to fully understand and quantify, the improved air quality resulting from reduced emissions of sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, mercury, and greenhouse gases will undoubtedly have positive effects on the health of Ontarians for decades to come.

The impact of coal phase-out on health

The phasing out of coal-fired power plants in Ontario, Canada, has had a positive impact on the health of residents. This is primarily due to the resulting improvement in air quality, which has led to a reduction in air pollution and its associated negative health effects.

Reduced Air Pollution

The coal phase-out in Ontario has contributed to a significant decrease in air pollution. Between 2003 and 2012, sulphur dioxide (SO2) emissions from coal plants were reduced by approximately 140,000 tonnes. This led to a nearly 50% decline in annual air levels of SO2 across the province and a 25% reduction in annual air levels of fine particulate matter (PM2.5). While other factors also contributed to these improvements, the closure of coal plants played a crucial role.

Improved Health Outcomes

The reduction in air pollution has had direct benefits for the health of Ontarians. The specific health impacts of the coal phase-out are complex and challenging to model, but the general effects of smog on health are well understood. These include irritation of the respiratory system, reduced and damaged lung function, and aggravated asthma.

The Ontario government estimated in 2005 that air pollution from coal plants was responsible for over 600 premature deaths, 900 hospital admissions, and 1,000 emergency room visits annually. An independent assessment by Toronto Public Health in 2014 found that improvements in Toronto's air quality from 2000 to 2011 reduced air pollution-related premature deaths by 23% and hospital admissions by 41% in the city alone.

Economic Considerations

While the health benefits of the coal phase-out are significant, it is important to acknowledge the economic implications. The transition to renewable energy sources has resulted in higher energy prices for Ontarians. However, the main causes of these price increases are deferred costs of electricity grid infrastructure investments and nuclear plant refurbishments, rather than the coal phase-out itself.

Ongoing Efforts

Ontario's leadership in phasing out coal has inspired similar initiatives in other provinces and the federal government. The Powering Past Coal Alliance (PPCA), co-founded by Canada and the UK, aims to rapidly phase out traditional coal-fired electricity. As of September 2024, the PPCA has helped ensure that over 75% of coal power in OECD member countries is retired or scheduled to close by 2030.

The coal phase-out in Ontario has led to tangible improvements in air quality and public health. While the specific health benefits will continue to be studied and quantified, the reduction in air pollution and its associated health risks is undeniable. Ontario's experience serves as a model for other jurisdictions working towards a cleaner and more sustainable energy future.

The impact of coal phase-out on the economy

Phasing out coal has a significant impact on the economy, and there are several factors to consider when examining the economic effects of this transition. Firstly, the energy sector is crucial for economic development, and coal has traditionally played a significant role in global energy production. As countries move away from coal, there are economic implications for both coal-dependent regions and the energy sector as a whole.

One of the main economic impacts of the coal phase-out is the potential for stranded assets and early retirement of coal plants. Coal-fired power plants often require substantial capital investments, and a rapid transition away from coal could lead to these assets becoming stranded, impacting the financial viability of energy companies and affecting global energy markets. Additionally, the closure or repurposing of coal mines and power plants can have significant economic consequences for coal-dependent regions, as the economy and local identity of these areas are often closely tied to the coal industry. Managing these transitions and ensuring a just shift for workers and communities is essential to mitigate potential negative economic impacts.

The transition away from coal also creates opportunities for economic growth and development. The shift towards renewable energy sources and low-emission technologies requires significant investments and innovations, which can stimulate economic growth and create new job opportunities. For example, the development and deployment of renewable energy technologies, such as solar, wind, and battery storage, can drive economic growth and create new industries. Additionally, the phase-out of coal can lead to improved health outcomes, reducing the economic burden of respiratory illnesses and other health issues associated with air pollution.

The economic impact of the coal phase-out also varies across different countries and regions. Developed countries may have more financial resources and infrastructure to facilitate the transition, while developing countries may face challenges in accessing financing and technologies for renewable energy sources. However, developing countries that are heavily reliant on coal may also benefit economically from improved health outcomes and reduced environmental impacts, which can have long-term economic benefits.

Overall, the coal phase-out has complex and far-reaching economic implications. While there may be challenges and costs associated with the transition, the potential for economic growth, improved health outcomes, and a more sustainable energy future makes a compelling case for a well-managed and just transition away from coal.

The impact of coal phase-out on the environment

The phasing out of coal-fired power plants in Ontario, Canada, has had a positive impact on the environment, leading to a reduction in air pollution and an improvement in air quality. This has resulted in significant health and environmental benefits for the people of Ontario.

Reduction in Air Pollution

The coal phase-out in Ontario has contributed to a decrease in air pollution levels, specifically in the emissions of sulphur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxide (NOx). Between 2003 and 2012, SO2 emissions from coal plants were reduced by approximately 140,000 tonnes, leading to a nearly 50% decline in annual air levels of SO2 across the province. Additionally, the phase-out has helped reduce airborne mercury emissions, which previously contributed to the contamination of fish with toxic substances harmful to human brains.

Improved Air Quality

The elimination of coal from the energy grid in Ontario resulted in a modest reduction in average urban fine particulate matter (PM2.5) levels. However, the impact on nitrogen oxide (NOx) levels was not statistically significant. There was also a notable decrease in peak ground-level ozone (O3) levels due to the coal phase-out, although this was offset by an increase associated with natural gas plant emissions. Overall, the coal phase-out led to small improvements in air quality, which were consistent with projections made prior to the closure of coal-fired power plants.

Health Benefits

The improved air quality resulting from the coal phase-out has positively impacted the health of Ontarians. The specific health benefits are still being studied and will take time to fully understand and quantify. However, it is well-known that smog, a byproduct of air pollution, can irritate the respiratory system, damage lung function, and aggravate asthma. The reduction in air pollution due to the coal phase-out is expected to lead to a decrease in respiratory illnesses and other health issues associated with air pollution.

Climate Change Mitigation

The coal phase-out in Ontario has also contributed to the fight against climate change. From 2005 to 2014, greenhouse gas emissions across the province declined by 7%, with a nearly 20% reduction in the energy sector. This is significant as coal-fired electricity generation is one of the largest sources of pollution globally. By phasing out coal, Ontario has taken a crucial step towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions and mitigating the impacts of climate change.

Overall, the coal phase-out in Ontario has had a positive impact on the environment, leading to reduced air pollution, improved air quality, and potential long-term health benefits for the province's residents. Additionally, it has contributed to global efforts to address climate change by reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

The future of coal-fired power

In 2012, Canada became the first country to introduce stringent regulations on coal-fired power plants, limiting their greenhouse gas and air pollutant emissions. This was followed by the founding of the Powering Past Coal Alliance (PPCA) in 2017, which now has 180 members, including governments, businesses, and institutions, working to rapidly phase out traditional coal-fired electricity. The PPCA aims to ensure a sustainable and inclusive transition, providing support for affected workers and communities.

Ontario, in particular, has been a leader in this regard, with its decision to phase out coal-fired power plants resulting in significant health and environmental benefits. From 2005 to 2014, the province saw a 7% decline in greenhouse gas emissions, with a nearly 20% reduction in the energy sector, equivalent to taking 7 million cars off the road. The number of smog days also decreased drastically, from 53 in 2005 to 0 in 2014.

However, the transition away from coal-fired power is not without its challenges. Some critics have pointed to the increase in energy prices as a result of the phase-out, causing electricity prices to rise. Additionally, the availability of alternative energy sources, such as natural gas and renewables, and the implementation of pollution controls, also contribute to the decline in coal-fired power.

Despite these challenges, the future of coal-fired power is expected to continue its decline. With the growing awareness of the health and environmental impacts of coal, and the increasing economic competitiveness of alternative energy sources, governments and organizations worldwide are committed to phasing out coal-fired power. The goal is to achieve an 80% reduction in global coal emissions this decade to limit global warming, with targeted timelines for different regions.

In conclusion, the future of coal-fired power is one of transformation and decline, as countries transition towards cleaner and more sustainable energy sources to address the pressing issues of climate change and air pollution.

Frequently asked questions