Steel Industry's Toxic Legacy In The Ohio River

The Ohio River has been a significant waterway for American industry, particularly steel production, since the Industrial Revolution. While it is much cleaner than it was a generation or two ago, the river remains vulnerable to industrial pollution. In 2020, it was reported that the Ohio River received the highest volume of toxic discharges from heavy industry, including steel manufacturers, of any other watershed in the United States. This has raised concerns about the river's water quality and its impact on human health, as it serves as a drinking water source for over 5 million people.

Steel industry pollution in the Ohio River

The Ohio River has long been impacted by industrial pollution, with steel manufacturing being a significant contributor. In 2015, the river was identified as having the highest levels of industrial pollution in the nation. This distinction was made based on data compiled by the Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation Commission, which revealed that the river remained heavily influenced by industrial activity. While the river is much cleaner than it was a generation or two ago, the presence of legacy pollutants and new industrial inputs continue to pose challenges.

Pittsburgh's steel industry, which once thrived along the Ohio River, has been a notable source of pollution. During the 1960s and 1970s, large pipes from industrial plants could be seen discharging effluents into the river. This period was marked by a lack of environmental regulations, allowing excess chemicals, grease, and untreated wastewater to contaminate the waterway. The passage of the Clean Water Act in 1972 marked a turning point, leading to the gradual cleanup of the river. However, the toxins released during this industrial era, such as mercury and PCBs, persist in the environment and continue to pose risks to wildlife and human health.

The steel industry's impact on the Ohio River extends beyond Pittsburgh. In 2020, the Environmental Protection Agency identified the Ohio River Basin as one of the most toxic watersheds in the country. Industrial discharges from steel manufacturers, among other industries, contributed to the release of nearly 41 million pounds of toxic pollution into the basin. Notably, the steel producer North American Stainless in Carroll County, Kentucky, was identified as the largest industrial polluter in the state, releasing over 3 million pounds of toxins into the river.

The pollution in the Ohio River has had significant ecological and human health implications. Researchers have found high levels of "forever chemicals" in fish tissue, raising concerns about the accumulation of toxins in the food chain. Additionally, the river serves as a drinking water source for more than 5 million people. While dilution has been suggested as a solution to pollution, it does not address the persistence and bioaccumulation of certain chemicals, such as mercury. As a result, there is a growing recognition of the need to balance industrial activities with improved wastewater treatment and stricter regulations to protect the health of the river and the communities that rely on it.

In conclusion, the steel industry has historically played a significant role in polluting the Ohio River. While efforts have been made to reduce pollution and improve water quality, the river continues to face the dual challenges of legacy pollutants and new industrial inputs. Addressing these issues requires a comprehensive approach that includes stricter regulations, improved wastewater treatment technologies, and a commitment to protecting the river as a vital natural resource and drinking water source for millions of people.

Nitrate compounds and other toxins

The Ohio River is considered the most polluted river in the United States, with about 20 million pounds of toxic emissions. In 2020, industrial facilities released at least 193.6 million pounds of toxic pollution into U.S. waterways, and the Ohio River watershed accounted for more than one-fifth of the total. The Ohio River watershed covers more than 200,000 miles, including a majority of Kentucky, Indiana, Ohio, and West Virginia. It is also the drinking water source for more than 5 million people.

Nitrate compounds are one of the primary pollutants in the Ohio River. In 2015, 92% of the toxic discharges were nitrate compounds, most of which came from AK Steel's Rockport, Indiana plant. Nitrate compounds are a form of nutrient pollution that can lower dissolved oxygen levels and cause harmful algal blooms. These algal blooms can be detrimental to the environment and have been observed along 265 miles of the Ohio River in 2019. Nitrates have also been linked to developmental issues and birth defects in humans.

In addition to nitrates, other toxins have been detected in the Ohio River. Mercury, for example, is a persistent pollutant that accumulates in the environment and wildlife. It has been released by power plants and industrial facilities, and it poses risks to both human and wildlife health, including potential neurological and reproductive issues. PCBs and other chemicals have also been found in the river, contributing to the complex mixture of toxins impacting the ecosystem and human communities.

The Ohio River has a long history of industrial pollution, dating back to the 1960s and 1970s when steel, coal, and petroleum industries dominated the region. While many of these industries have declined or disappeared, the toxins they released, such as mercury and PCBs, remain in the environment and continue to cause harm. Today, new industries, including power plants and manufacturers, have moved into the Ohio River Basin and contribute to the ongoing pollution issues.

To address the pollution in the Ohio River, there have been calls for regulatory changes and stricter enforcement of existing laws. The Clean Water Act, passed in 1972, has helped improve the river's health, but challenges remain due to varying rules and regulations across the states the river flows through. Environmental groups are concerned about the exceedance of permitted pollution levels, and there is a recognized need to reduce toxic discharges and protect this vital freshwater source.

Mercury and other bio-accumulating pollutants

Mercury is a highly toxic chemical that has been discharged into the Ohio River by industrial facilities. It is a bio-accumulating pollutant, meaning that it builds up or "bioaccumulates" in the tissues of animals that consume it. This has led to dangerous levels of mercury in fish, making them too poisonous for human consumption. In 2017, Eagle Natrium, LLC, a company based in West Virginia, released almost 200,000 toxic-weighted pounds into the Ohio River, causing high levels of mercury in local fish species.

Mercury is particularly harmful to young brains and can cause neurological, reproductive, and developmental issues in both humans and animals. It is also long-lasting in the environment, persisting in the sediment of the Ohio River. This persistence has resulted in the Ohio River being ranked as one of the dirtiest rivers in the United States.

Other bio-accumulating pollutants, such as PCBs and forever chemicals, have also been detected in the Ohio River. These chemicals, commonly found in waterproof coatings and non-stick pans, were present in the tissue of every fish tested by the Kentucky Energy and Environment Cabinet, sometimes at extremely high levels.

While dilution is often considered a solution to pollution, it is not effective for all chemicals. Some pollutants, like mercury, accumulate in the environment and wildlife, and their impact cannot be mitigated by simply adding more water. This has been acknowledged by environmental scientists, who recognize the need for stronger water quality protections and stricter controls on mercury pollution.

The multi-state agency responsible for maintaining the cleanliness of the Ohio River has faced challenges in tightening controls on mercury pollution due to a lack of authority. Additionally, there have been proposals to relax rules and regulations regarding mercury and other toxic chemicals, further complicating the efforts to reduce bio-accumulating pollutants in the river.

'Forever chemicals' and their impact

The Ohio River has long been a site of industrial pollution, with Pittsburgh's steel, coal, and petroleum industries dominating the city's waterfront in the 1960s and 1970s. While many of these industries have since disappeared, the toxins they released, such as mercury and PCBs, still remain and continue to cause harm. In 2020, the Ohio River Basin was considered one of the most toxic watersheds in the country, receiving the highest burden of toxic discharges.

This brings us to the issue of "forever chemicals," or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). PFAS are a class of man-made chemicals that are used to make consumer goods water-, stain-, and grease-resistant. They are called "forever chemicals" because they are nearly indestructible and extremely persistent in the environment and our bodies. PFAS can lead to serious health issues such as liver damage, thyroid disease, fertility issues, and cancer.

The impact of PFAS on the Ohio River is significant. In 2020, the steel producer North American Stainless in Carroll County dumped over 3 million pounds of toxic pollution, the most of any industrial facility in Kentucky. PFAS have been found throughout the Ohio River and in every major Kentucky watershed, with unsafe levels detected in at least 38 drinking water systems. Researchers with Kentucky's Energy and Environment Cabinet found PFAS in the tissue of every single fish they tested, sometimes at extremely high levels.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has proposed strict new limits on six types of PFAS in drinking water, but public health experts argue that all types of these toxic chemicals need to be regulated. Thousands of PFAS chemicals are in use, and the EPA does not test for the majority of them. The Biden administration has taken some steps to address PFAS contamination, such as the EPA's 2021 PFAS Strategic Roadmap, but more comprehensive monitoring, regulations, and cleanup efforts are needed to address the crisis.

The presence of PFAS in the Ohio River is a serious concern, with far-reaching consequences for the environment, wildlife, and human health. As Sujatha Bergen, a co-author of an NRDC report, states, "We lived just fine without these chemicals before, and brands could phase them out quickly if they chose to."

Regulations and environmental impact

The Ohio River has long been impacted by industrial pollution, with Pittsburgh's steel, coal, and petroleum industries contributing significantly to the issue. While many of these industries have declined or disappeared, the toxins they released, such as mercury and PCBs, persist in the waterway and continue to cause ecological and health issues.

In the late 1800s through the mid-1900s, the Cuyahoga River, which flows into the Ohio River, was heavily polluted by steel mills and other industrial activities, resulting in multiple fires on the river, the most notable being in 1969. This incident sparked local protests and advocacy, leading to the passing of a $100 million bond for river cleanup in 1968. The Clean Water Act, enacted in 1972, played a crucial role in improving the water quality of the Cuyahoga and Ohio Rivers.

Despite these efforts, the Ohio River continues to face pollution challenges. In 2015, it was reported that the Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation Commission was considering relaxing rules and regulations on mercury and other toxic chemical discharges, shifting responsibility to individual states. This proposal faced criticism for potentially creating inconsistent standards for managing dangerous pollutants.

In 2020, the Ohio River Basin was identified as one of the most toxic watersheds in the country. Heavy industries, including steel manufacturers, released nearly 41 million pounds of toxic pollution into the basin. This pollution included nitrates, which can cause developmental issues and birth defects, as well as toxic algal blooms.

The impact of this pollution is significant, as the Ohio River serves as the drinking water source for over 5 million people. While dilution in the river's vast flow of water can mitigate some pollution effects, certain chemicals, like mercury, accumulate in the environment and wildlife. This has led to concerns about the safety of consuming fish from the river due to the potential presence of harmful chemicals.

To address these issues, environmental groups have called for stricter regulations and enforcement of permit limits. Additionally, there have been efforts to designate the Ohio River as a federally protected water system, which would provide funding for its restoration and help ensure the river's long-term health and sustainability.

Frequently asked questions