Smog-Sucking Tower: China's Pollution Solution?

China has some of the world's deadliest air, according to the World Health Organization. Pollution has become so ingrained in daily Chinese life that pollution masks have become must-have accessories for young urbanites. In 2013, Dutch artist and innovator Daan Roosegaarde conceived the idea for the Smog Free Tower in Beijing. The seven-metre-tall structure, which combines the design of a spaceship and a traditional Chinese pagoda, uses patented ozone-free ion technology to suck pollution into its chambers and purify it. It can clean 30,000 cubic meters of air per hour and uses a small amount of green electricity.

Daan Roosegaarde's Smog Free Tower

The Smog Free Tower is a symbol of innovation in air purification technology. It was created by Daan Roosegaarde in collaboration with Studio Roosegaarde, ENS, and advisor Ursem (until 2013). The project has received multiple awards for its innovative and sustainable design, including the Grand Award for Sustainability and the German Design Award for Excellent Product Design.

The tower is part of the Smog Free Project, led by Daan Roosegaarde, which aims to reduce pollution and inspire a cleaner future. The project has been realised in several countries, including South Korea, China, the Netherlands, Mexico, Poland, and the United Arab Emirates. As part of the project, Roosegaarde also designed the Smog Free Ring, made from compressed smog particles collected from the tower. Each ring represents 1,000 cubic metres of clean air donated to the city.

While the Smog Free Tower has been praised for its innovative design and ability to create pockets of clean air, some experts have expressed scepticism about the effectiveness of such static air cleaners in significantly reducing urban pollution. They argue that the scale of the problem requires solutions that stop harmful emissions at their source rather than attempting to capture pollution once it is already in the air.

Despite the scepticism, Roosegaarde's Smog Free Tower represents a creative approach to tackling the pressing issue of air pollution. The project aligns with the Chinese government's efforts to address pollution, as outlined in the country's 13th Five-Year Plan. By touring the tower to universities, schools, and environmental organisations in China, Roosegaarde hopes to offer a tangible solution for creating clean parks and setting a new sense of beauty through the sensory experience of clean air.

Effectiveness of anti-pollution measures

The effectiveness of anti-pollution measures such as smog towers has been a topic of discussion and analysis. While the concept of smog towers or smog-free towers is an innovative approach to combating urban air pollution, there are varying opinions on their effectiveness.

The Smog Free Tower, designed by Daan Roosegaarde, is a seven-meter-tall structure that utilizes patented ozone-free ion technology to clean 30,000 cubic meters of air per hour. The tower, which was first unveiled in Rotterdam in 2015, has since been installed in various locations, including Beijing and Tianjin in China. The tower creates a bubble of clean air, providing citizens with "clean air for free". The project also includes the creation of Smog Free Jewellery, where smog particles collected from the tower are compressed into "gemstones" and mounted onto jewellery pieces.

Some scientists and researchers have expressed positive opinions about the potential of smog towers. Reports from scientists involved in a project in Xi'an, China, claimed that their air-purifying tower could clean pollutants at a scale large enough to benefit an entire city. China's air filtration project, which uses greenhouses to generate warm air currents that rise through filters, claims to clean 10 million cubic meters of air per day.

However, it is important to approach these claims with a degree of scepticism. There is currently a lack of publicly available hard data to support the effectiveness of these towers in significantly reducing pollution on a large scale. The challenge lies in the fact that pollution is rapidly mixed in the planetary boundary layer due to turbulence and thermals. Therefore, a much larger volume of air needs to be cleaned to make a noticeable difference. Additionally, cities are not sealed environments, and they constantly experience an inflow of pollution from external sources.

Furthermore, critics argue that static air cleaners like smog towers may not be able to process enough city air quickly enough to make a meaningful impact on urban pollution. Professor Alastair Lewis, Science Director at the NCAS, suggests that it is more effective to focus on technologies that prevent harmful emissions at their source rather than attempting to capture pollution once it is already in the air. The effectiveness of smog towers is also influenced by factors such as distance, with a study on the Connaught Place tower in Delhi finding that its efficiency decreased as the distance from the tower increased.

While smog towers may not be a standalone solution to ending pollution in China, they can serve as a part of a larger effort to address the issue. The Smog Free Tower project, for example, aims to raise awareness about the dangers of air pollution and encourage a dialogue about the value of clean air. Additionally, the project explores the intersection of technology, design, and fashion, offering a new perspective on sustainability and clean beauty.

China's air filtration project

The Smog Free Tower was designed by Dutch artist and innovator Daan Roosegaarde and his team of designers and experts at Studio Roosegaarde. The project was inspired by Roosegaarde's travels in China, particularly his visit to Beijing in 2013, where he experienced the severe smog that often engulfed the city. The tower was first unveiled in Rotterdam in 2015 and later toured or was installed in other cities in China, such as Beijing and Tianjin, as well as in other countries.

The Smog Free Tower is part of Roosegaarde's larger Landscapes of the Future vision, which aims to create a new sense of beauty and a clean future through the sensory experience of clean air. The project also includes the Smog Free Jewellery line, which features compressed smog particles collected from the tower and sealed in resin cubes mounted on rings and cufflinks. Each piece of jewellery represents 1,000 cubic meters of filtered air.

While China's air filtration project and similar initiatives around the world offer a technological route to combat air pollution, it is important to consider their effectiveness and scalability in addressing the complex challenge of reducing pollution on a large scale.

Alternative pollution-reducing methods

While smog towers are a novel approach to reducing air pollution, they are not the only method available.

One alternative method is the use of anti-smog paint, which has been explored in London and India. This paint acts as a sink for nitrogen oxides (NOx), a major air pollutant. While the basic chemistry behind this approach is reasonable, there are challenges in ensuring that the pollution comes into contact with the painted surface, particularly when considering the deeper layers of air that are influenced by turbulence and thermals.

Another approach is to increase vegetation in cities, as trees and shrubs can help to clean the air. However, the impact of this method may be limited, and it cannot effectively address the constant inflow of pollution that cities experience.

In addition to these technological and natural interventions, policy changes and individual actions can also play a significant role in reducing air pollution. Successful policies can include implementing clean technologies in industries, improving waste management practices, promoting clean household energy solutions, and prioritizing clean modes of transportation and power generation. Individual actions, such as reducing motor vehicle usage, choosing fuel-efficient vehicles, saving energy at home, and using air filters indoors, can also collectively make a significant difference in reducing air pollution.

Furthermore, the use of solar updraft towers or tall stacks that utilize the chimney effect to remove pollution can be explored. These structures may not require external energy input beyond what is produced by the updraft, providing a more sustainable solution.

While smog towers offer a technological route to combat air pollution, it is important to recognize that a combination of these alternative methods, along with policy interventions and individual efforts, may be more effective in tackling the complex issue of air pollution.

The future of smog towers

Smog towers are large-scale air purifiers designed to reduce air pollution particles. The world's first smog tower was unveiled in September 2015 in Rotterdam by Dutch artist Daan Roosegaarde. The 7-metre-tall tower uses patented positive ionisation technology and is expected to clean 30,000 m3 of air per hour.

Following the success of the first tower, similar structures were installed in several cities in China, such as Beijing and Tianjin, as well as in other countries like Poland, South Korea, and the UAE. These towers aim to provide clean air in public spaces and raise awareness about pollution issues.

Another challenge is the power source for the towers. In the case of Delhi, the smog tower would be powered mainly by coal-fired electricity, which could potentially add to pollution in other areas. Additionally, the filters used in the towers are expensive, and the overall cost of operating and maintaining these structures can be high.

Despite these limitations, smog towers can provide temporary relief in highly populated areas while investments in clean energy technology are made. David Pui, Regents Professor at the University of Minnesota, suggests that smog towers can be particularly effective in countries like India, where the population is more densely concentrated.

The team behind the original smog tower, including Daan Roosegaarde, is committed to creating a cleaner future. They have expanded their vision beyond the towers and are working on projects like the Smog Free Bicycle, which purifies air as cyclists ride around, and the Smog Eating Billboard, which uses a special coating and sunlight to purify air for up to 104,000 people per day.

In conclusion, while smog towers may not be a permanent solution to end pollution in China or other countries, they play a crucial role in raising awareness, inspiring innovation, and providing temporary relief in highly polluted areas. The future of smog towers lies in their ability to spark further creativity and drive the development of more sustainable solutions to combat air pollution on a global scale.

Frequently asked questions