Air Pollution: Can You Smell The Danger?

Air pollution is a serious issue that affects people's health and well-being. While the impact of air pollution on physical health is widely recognized, its effects on our olfactory senses are less often discussed. Air pollution can emit unpleasant odors that impact people's quality of life and mental attitudes. These odors can come from various sources, including industrial facilities, agricultural activities, vehicle emissions, and waste processing plants.

Interestingly, our sense of smell plays a crucial role in detecting air pollution. Humans can discriminate between a vast number of olfactory stimuli, and trained smell specialists are even employed to identify harmful pollutants in some cities. The power of our noses in detecting air pollution is being harnessed through initiatives like smell walks and smellfies, where people document and share the dominant odors they encounter in urban areas. This crowdsourced data is then used to create detailed smell maps that correlate with objective air quality indicators.

However, it's important to note that our sense of smell can be impaired by air pollution, with certain pollutants causing acute and chronic alterations in our olfactory perception.

Odour pollution can affect mental health and enjoyment of the environment

Odour pollution can have a significant impact on people's mental health and their overall enjoyment of the environment. While it may not be directly harmful to physical health, unpleasant odours can affect mental attitudes and people's sense of wellbeing.

Unpleasant odours can act as a warning sign of potential health risks. For instance, emissions from wastewater treatment facilities, such as volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and sulphur compounds, can generate unpleasant odours. These compounds deplete the oxygen in wastewater tanks, creating anaerobic and septic conditions that produce harmful gases like H2S and NH3.

Research has shown that exposure to odour pollution can lead to a range of negative outcomes, including headaches, nausea, vomiting, and respiratory issues. It can also cause irritation to the eyes, nose, and throat, as well as skin irritation. In addition, odour pollution has been linked to mood changes, including nervousness, stress, and unhappiness.

The impact of odour pollution on mental health and enjoyment of the environment is influenced by individual factors such as age, sex, and medical conditions. It is also worth noting that the sensitivity to odours and responses to them can vary among individuals, making it challenging to monitor and assess the health effects accurately.

Addressing odour pollution is crucial for protecting public health and ensuring equity for residents living near odour-polluted sites, who are often low-income groups.

People can smell certain chemicals before they reach harmful levels

While air pollution by odour is not directly harmful to human health, it can affect mental attitudes and the enjoyment of the environment. Odours can be a warning sign of potential risks to human health. People can sometimes smell certain chemicals in the air before they reach harmful levels. However, it is important to note that the absence of an odour does not always indicate the absence of harmful chemicals. For example, carbon monoxide has no odour but can be extremely dangerous to human health.

Chemicals that trigger odours may cause health issues. People will usually notice an odour well below the level in the air that would cause health effects. However, individuals have varying sensitivities to chemicals and may not be affected in the same way. The type of chemical, its concentration in the air, the duration of exposure, and individual sensitivities all play a role in whether someone experiences health effects. Health symptoms from odour exposure typically disappear quickly once the odours stop.

Odours can be caused by a single chemical or a mixture of chemicals. People's ability to smell odours can vary depending on factors such as age, sex, and smoking status. Some people may notice an odour at low levels, while others may not perceive it at all. At higher levels, most individuals will be able to detect the odour.

Additionally, people may react differently to the same odour. For example, the smell of freshly baked bread from a bakery may be enjoyable for some but unpleasant for those living nearby and exposed to the strong smell daily. Prolonged exposure to the same odour may also lead to olfactory fatigue, where individuals no longer notice the smell even if it is unpleasant.

In some cases, odours can be used to detect issues such as mould, sewage backups, or gas leaks in a home. However, standard air sampling methods may not effectively measure all the chemicals that cause odours, and people's diverse responses to odours can make it challenging to interpret the measurements.

Odour masking agents are sometimes used to hide unpleasant smells

Odour masking agents are indeed sometimes used to hide unpleasant smells. Unpleasant odours can be a warning sign of potential health risks, and they can also negatively impact people's quality of life and sense of well-being.

In industrial settings, odour masking is achieved by releasing highly concentrated masking agents with strong fragrances. This method is used in industries such as industrial waste, sewage, and farming to mask the noxious odours produced. For example, facilities like sewage treatment plants may use masking agents to hide the smell of hydrogen sulfide gas, which is produced during wastewater treatment and smells like rotten eggs.

While odour masking can be an effective short-term solution, it is important to note that it does not eliminate the source of the odour. The unpleasant smell will still be present in the background, and once the masking fragrance fades, the bad odour will become noticeable again.

There are alternative methods to odour masking, such as micronutrient dosing and extraction and filtration, which aim to biologically break down the waste that produces the odours or to prevent the odours from infiltrating surrounding areas.

In certain situations, such as in healthcare settings, odour masking may be preferred as a quick and inexpensive solution. For example, healthcare workers have been known to apply products like toothpaste or Mastisol to their surgical masks to lessen the impact of noxious odours.

Well-trained noses can be used to detect air pollution

The human nose is a powerful tool that can be used to detect air pollution. While it may not be as accurate as scientific instruments, a well-trained nose can identify specific pollutants and even estimate their concentrations. This ability can be particularly useful in identifying potential health risks and taking appropriate action.

Human Nose as a Detector

The human nose is a complex system that can detect a wide range of chemicals and odours in the air. While some odours may be pleasant, others may indicate the presence of harmful pollutants. For example, the smell of smoke may indicate a fire, while the smell of rotten eggs may indicate the presence of sulphur dioxide, a common air pollutant. In some cases, people can smell certain chemicals in the air before they reach harmful levels, serving as an early warning sign.

Training the Nose

To train the nose to detect air pollution, one must first familiarise themselves with the common pollutants and their respective odours. This can be done by exposing oneself to controlled environments with known pollutants in safe concentrations. For example, one may visit industrial sites, agricultural areas, or scientific laboratories to experience the odours of pollutants such as methane, carbon dioxide, or volatile organic compounds. Additionally, odour diaries can be maintained, where individuals record their observations of different odours, their impacts, and the conditions under which they occur.

Limitations and Challenges

While the nose can be a useful tool, it has limitations. The sense of smell varies from person to person, and some individuals may have a more sensitive or less sensitive sense of smell. Additionally, the nose may not be able to detect all types of pollutants, especially those that are odourless, such as carbon monoxide. Moreover, the nose's ability to accurately identify and quantify pollutants can be influenced by factors such as age, sex, medical condition, and environmental factors.

Technological Enhancements

To enhance the capabilities of the human nose, technological advancements have been made. Electronic noses, or e-noses, are devices that combine an array of chemical sensors with pattern recognition systems to identify and classify odours. These devices can provide more accurate and quantitative data on air pollutants. For example, the electro-optical nose combines metal oxide semiconductor sensors with non-dispersive infrared sensors to detect gases affecting indoor air quality.

Well-trained noses, combined with technological advancements, can be a powerful tool for detecting air pollution. By understanding the limitations and enhancing our capabilities with technology, we can better identify and address potential health risks posed by air pollutants. This approach can help improve air quality and protect the well-being of communities.

Human descriptions of city smells can be used to build smell maps

The sense of smell is often overlooked, yet it is strongly linked to the creation of emotional memories and contributes to our understanding of the world. Urban odours are largely the result of human activity, and so smells can reveal the cultural practices, industries, commerce, culinary offerings, and municipal services of our cities.

Researcher Dr. Kate McLean has spent the last decade surveying the smellscapes of different cities and translating their sensory qualities into maps. She leads scent walks for each city she investigates, guiding small groups of people to move through the city, focus on the olfactory stimulants, and describe their feelings. The data collected is then synthesized into smell maps—visual translations of the perceived 'smellscape' in each place.

McLean's approach underlines the role of odour as a place-making element and a component of public space. The resulting maps are not only helpful in documenting hidden aspects of a city, but many participants describe the process as transformative. Some of the unusual descriptors from her work include the "smell of shattered dreams", "broccoli / deep dark secrets", and "a hard life".

In Amsterdam, the 44 volunteers identified over 600 perceived scents, some belonging to the city and others more in line with expectations of walks in the countryside. Over the warm powdery sweetness of waffles, oriental spices emanated from Asian and Surinamese restaurants, and pickled herring from the herring stands and markets, a link to one of the city's key historical industries. Old books were detected in basement doorways and laundry aromas drifted up into the streets from Amsterdam's many house hotels.

The smell maps are a way to facilitate discussion and raise the awareness of communities. They represent key indicators of human activity. The perception of the stimulus depends on the context: we might enjoy the smell of seafood in a fish market, but find it disconcerting if we encounter it in a park. As most smells are the result of human activity, paying attention to these aspects can also speak to the cultural practices within the neighbourhood, from culinary traditions to the prevalent type of industry or favourite pastimes.

The first recorded smell walk was undertaken in 1790 in Paris by Jean-Noël Hallé, who walked ten kilometres along the Seine to investigate its noxious smells, which were thought to be a direct cause of disease. Moving from odour nuisance control to smellscapes opens up opportunities to appreciate the benefits of smells in human experiences and well-being. Part of understanding the world more holistically, smells, either negative or positive, should be considered an essential aspect of the design and planning framework of public spaces alongside other sensory components.

Frequently asked questions