Hydroelectric Power: Pollution Paradox?

Hydroelectricity is often considered a clean and renewable energy source, but it can cause pollution and have other adverse environmental impacts. While hydropower doesn't directly emit air pollutants, the construction and operation of dams, reservoirs, and power-generating equipment can affect the environment. The flooding of land for reservoirs can destroy forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and displace communities. Additionally, changes to water temperature, chemistry, and flow can disrupt aquatic ecosystems and native plant and animal life. The decomposition of vegetation in reservoirs also leads to the production of greenhouse gases, such as methane and carbon dioxide, contributing to global warming emissions.

Hydroelectric dams emit greenhouse gases

Hydroelectric dams are a source of renewable energy that is widely available, reliable, and cost-effective. However, they also contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, particularly during the installation and dismantling of hydroelectric power plants. The reservoirs created by these dams can emit significant amounts of carbon dioxide and methane, which are potent greenhouse gases.

The decomposition of flooded organic material, such as vegetation, in the reservoirs is the primary source of these emissions. The exact amount of greenhouse gas emissions depends on various factors, including the size and location of the reservoir. Some reservoirs may act as carbon sinks, absorbing more carbon than they emit, while others have carbon footprints similar to or greater than fossil fuels. The temperature of the reservoir water also influences methane emissions, with higher temperatures leading to increased emissions.

The impact of hydroelectric dams on greenhouse gas emissions has been a subject of debate, with recent studies suggesting that emissions during the operation of hydroelectric power plants can be significant. The International Hydropower Association estimates that replacing hydropower with coal for electricity generation would result in over four billion metric tons of additional greenhouse gas emissions annually.

To address the greenhouse gas emissions associated with hydroelectric dams, several improvements have been proposed. These include considering reservoirs within the context of broader watersheds, improving carbon accounting practices, and accurately measuring carbon emissions. By implementing these measures, the goal is to ensure that future hydropower projects effectively contribute to mitigating climate change rather than exacerbating it.

While hydroelectric dams emit greenhouse gases, they still play a crucial role in reducing global carbon emissions. Independent research suggests that the use of hydropower instead of fossil fuels has helped avoid more than 100 billion tons of carbon dioxide emissions in the past 50 years.

Building hydro plants can be expensive

The type of power plant is the main factor influencing the cost of an investment project. While the construction costs for solar and wind power plants have decreased in recent years due to scientific progress and technological advancements, the cost of building hydropower plants has not shown a significant decline. On the contrary, between 2010 and 2022, the average cost of hydroelectric power plants increased by 30-50% depending on the region and project type. This is because the hydropower sector relies heavily on available land and civil works, and the rising cost of labour and materials are making this type of power plant increasingly expensive for investors.

Hydropower plants in flat areas tend to require much more land than those in hilly areas or canyons, where deeper reservoirs can hold more water in a smaller space. For example, the large Balbina hydroelectric plant in Brazil flooded 2,360 square kilometres of land and only provides 250 MW of power-generating capacity. In contrast, a small 10 MW run-of-the-river plant in a hilly location can use as little as 2.5 acres.

The size of the reservoir created by a hydroelectric project can vary widely, depending on the size of the generators and the topography of the land. Flooding land for a reservoir can have extreme environmental impacts, including the destruction of forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic areas. Additionally, entire communities may need to be relocated to make way for reservoirs, as seen with the Three Gorges Dam in China.

The cost of building a hydropower plant must also take into account the potential reduction in generation due to the natural decrease in the efficiency of the system over time. The long operating lifetime of a hydropower plant (50 to 100 years) can offset some of the initial investment costs, but the high upfront capital expenditures make hydropower plants one of the most expensive power generation technologies in the world.

Hydro plants can obstruct fish migration

Hydroelectricity is often considered a clean energy source, but it can cause pollution in several ways. One of the most significant impacts of hydropower plants is their obstruction of fish migration.

In the United States, more than 2 million dams and other barriers, including culverts, block fish from migrating upstream. This obstruction has led to the decline of many fish populations, including Atlantic salmon, which is now an endangered species. Fish migration is essential as it allows fish to reach their native habitats to reproduce and grow. When they are unable to complete their journey due to these engineered barriers, fish populations suffer.

Dams, a essential component of hydropower plants, are a significant barrier to fish migration. The construction of a dam and reservoir can change natural water temperatures, water chemistry, river flow characteristics, and silt loads. These alterations can have detrimental effects on the river's ecology and physical characteristics, impacting native plants and animals in and around the river.

To mitigate the issue of fish migration obstruction, various methods have been implemented. One approach is the construction of fish ladders and elevators, such as those at the Bonneville Dam and the Safe Harbor Dam, which assist fish in bypassing the dams and reaching their spawning grounds upstream. Another method is the use of turbines that reduce fish deaths, with the U.S. Department of Energy sponsoring research and development in this area.

Additionally, organizations like NOAA Fisheries play a crucial role in improving fish migration at hydropower dams. They work with partners to identify and implement solutions, such as removing obsolete dams or enlarging culverts, to reopen rivers and streams for fish migration while also preserving hydropower generation. These efforts are vital for the recovery of threatened and endangered migratory fish species and the sustainability of economically important fisheries.

Hydro plants can cause human displacement

Hydroelectric power plants can have a significant impact on the environment, including the displacement of human populations. The construction of a hydroelectric complex often requires the flooding of land, which can lead to the relocation of entire communities. This was the case with the Three Gorges Dam in China, where people had to move to make way for the reservoir.

The size of the reservoir created by a hydroelectric project can vary, depending on the size of the generators and the topography of the land. In flat areas, hydroelectric plants tend to require much more land than in hilly areas or canyons, where deeper reservoirs can hold more water in a smaller space. For example, the large Balbina hydroelectric plant in Brazil flooded an area of 2,360 square kilometers—similar in size to the US state of Delaware—and only provides 250 MW of power generating capacity. In contrast, a small 10 MW run-of-the-river plant in a hilly location might use as little as 2.5 acres.

The flooding of land for a hydroelectric reservoir can have extreme environmental and human impacts. In addition to destroying forests, wildlife habitats, agricultural land, and scenic lands, the construction of reservoirs and dams can also result in the relocation of people. This disruption to the natural ecology of the river can affect habitats and ecosystems, siltation, and erosion patterns.

The physical impacts of a dam and reservoir, as well as the operation of the dam and the use of the water, can change the environment over a much larger area than just the reservoir itself. The changes in water temperature, chemistry, river flow, and silt loads can have negative effects on native plants and animals in and around the river. Additionally, reservoirs may cover important natural areas, agricultural land, or archaeological sites, further displacing human populations.

Overall, while hydroelectric power is a renewable and clean energy source, it is important to consider the potential impacts on human populations, including displacement, when planning and constructing new hydroelectric complexes.

Hydro plants can affect water quality

Hydroelectric power plants can have a significant impact on water quality. The creation of a reservoir or the diversion of water to a run-of-river hydropower plant can obstruct fish migration and change natural water temperatures, water chemistry, river flow characteristics, and silt loads. These changes can have negative effects on native plants and animals in and around the river.

Reservoirs tend to have higher levels of sediments and nutrients than natural river water due to the more stagnant nature of the water. This can lead to excessive growth of algae and aquatic weeds, which can crowd out other plant and animal life. These weeds must then be manually harvested or controlled by introducing fish that eat these plants.

The water in reservoirs is typically colder and has lower dissolved oxygen levels than natural river water. When this water is released, it can negatively impact downstream plants and animals. To mitigate these effects, aerating turbines can be installed to increase oxygen levels, and multi-level water intakes can ensure that the released water comes from various depths of the reservoir, helping to improve temperature and oxygen levels.

Additionally, if too much water is stored behind the reservoir, downstream river segments can dry out, harming plant and animal life. To prevent this, hydroelectric operators are often required to release a minimum amount of water at specific times of the year.

Frequently asked questions