Compost Runoff: Water Pollution Risk?

Composting is widely considered an environmentally beneficial activity. However, it is important to consider the potential impact of compost on water quality, especially after run-off. Composting facilities must carefully manage their operations to prevent adverse environmental impacts and maintain their positive reputation. While composting is generally beneficial, certain aspects of the process can create problems, particularly when it comes to leaf composting and composting nutrient-rich materials such as grass, manure, or sewage sludge. These activities can result in high levels of biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) and phenols in water runoff and percolation, which can be detrimental to surface water supplies if not properly managed. Additionally, the presence of nitrogen compounds and, in some cases, phosphorus, as well as pathogens in manure or sewage sludge, can pose risks to water quality.

Compost can reduce water runoff and soil erosion

Composting is an environmentally beneficial activity that can be used to prevent pollution and promote soil health. Compost can be used to prevent water runoff and soil erosion in several ways. Firstly, compost increases water infiltration into the soil surface, helping to replenish groundwater levels and prevent surface runoff. This is due to its ability to bind soil together and slow down water flow. This, in turn, reduces the risk of flooding and washouts.

Secondly, compost acts as a natural barrier, reducing the speed and volume of runoff. This minimizes the transport of soil particles and pollutants downstream. Compost's coarse structure enables it to divert the impact of rainfall effectively. Additionally, compost's high water retention capacity—up to 27,000 gallons per acre-foot for every 1% of organic matter added to the soil—helps address flooding and runoff concerns.

Thirdly, compost promotes plant growth and soil cover by providing essential nutrients. This stabilizes slopes and prevents erosion. The addition of compost improves soil structure, enabling better root penetration and higher rates of water infiltration and drainage. It also helps maintain optimal pH levels in the soil, fostering ideal conditions for plant growth.

Finally, compost can be applied using methods such as compost blankets and compost filter berms. Compost blankets involve applying high-quality compost directly to areas at risk of erosion, such as construction sites and stream banks. Compost filter berms, on the other hand, are contoured structures that allow runoff water to flow through while filtering out sediment and pollutants. They also slow down the flow, further reducing erosion.

By utilizing these properties and methods, compost can effectively reduce water runoff and soil erosion, contributing to sustainable environmental solutions.

It can prevent the leaching of nutrients into water sources

Composting has long been considered an environmentally beneficial activity. However, compost facilities must carefully consider and mitigate any adverse environmental impacts to maintain this positive reputation. One of the main concerns is the potential for compost to pollute water sources, especially through nutrient leaching and runoff.

Compost contains valuable nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium, which can be taken up by plants. However, when excess nutrients are present, they can leach into the soil and eventually reach groundwater or run off into surface water bodies. This is particularly true for nutrient-rich materials like grass, manure, and sewage sludge, which can have high concentrations of nitrogen compounds and, in some cases, phosphorus.

To prevent the leaching of nutrients into water sources, several measures can be taken:

• Site Selection: Choosing the right site is critical for composting operations. Soils that are too impermeable can lead to increased runoff, while highly permeable soils can allow excessive nutrient infiltration into groundwater. Intermediate soil types may be best for native soil operations.
• Buffer Zones: A sufficient buffer between the composting site and water sources is essential. Deep soils above the water table can act as a natural filter, minimizing nutrient migration. Horizontal buffers are also necessary, ensuring a minimum distance between the site and wells or surface water bodies.
• Proper Pile Management: The shape and orientation of compost piles matter. Piles should be oriented parallel to the slope to allow precipitation to move off the composting area. A peaked or convex shape can help shed water, especially during heavy rain.
• Maintaining Optimal C:N Ratio: Nitrogen is one of the most mobile nutrients and is prone to leaching. Maintaining an appropriate carbon-to-nitrogen (C:N) ratio in the composting mixture helps control nitrogen levels. A ratio of 30:1 is often recommended to balance microbial needs and prevent excess nitrogen from entering the water.
• Moisture Control: Excess water can increase the potential for nutrient leaching and runoff. Keeping the moisture content between 40% and 60% provides a balance between water and air-filled pore space, ensuring adequate moisture for decomposition and airflow for oxygen supply.
• Compost Socks and Berms: In areas prone to heavy rainfall or flooding, compost socks (mesh tubes filled with compost) and berms can be used to slow down and filter rainwater, preventing nutrients from washing away.
• Vegetative Filter Strips: Grass or other vegetation can be planted near composting sites to act as a natural filter. They help trap and settle particles, reducing the amount of nutrients and pollutants entering water sources.
• Treatment Ponds: In some cases, runoff collection ponds may be necessary to treat contaminated water before it enters the environment. These ponds use microorganisms to continue the decomposition process, reducing organic matter and pathogen levels.

Composting can kill pathogens in manure

Composting has long been viewed as an environmentally beneficial activity. However, compost facilities must consider and mitigate any adverse environmental impacts to maintain this positive reputation. One of the primary concerns with composting is the potential for water pollution through runoff. This is particularly true for leaf composting, where biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) and phenol concentrations in water runoff and percolation can be high.

When composting nutrient-rich materials such as grass, manure, or sewage sludge, there is an additional risk of nitrogen compounds and phosphorus ending up in surface water supplies. With manure or sewage sludge, there is also the risk of pathogens. While these concerns can be managed through careful facility design and operation, they highlight the importance of proper attention to siting, ingredient mixtures, and compost pile management.

One way to address these concerns is by selecting the right site for composting. The soil type, slope, and buffer between the site and surface or groundwater resources are critical factors. For example, impermeable soils protect groundwater from nitrate pollution but maximize runoff, increasing the BOD, phosphorus, and pathogen threat to surface water. On the other hand, highly permeable soils reduce runoff potential but may allow excessive nitrate infiltration into groundwater. Intermediate soil types may be best for native soil sites.

Another important consideration is the carbon-to-nitrogen (C:N) ratio in the composting mixture. A ratio of 30:1 is ideal for microbial biomass and energy requirements. However, a lower ratio can result in excess nitrogen, which can leave the system as ammonia or nitrate, contributing to water pollution. Proper management of the C:N ratio is crucial in limiting nitrate contamination.

Additionally, maintaining the right moisture content in the compost pile is essential. Optimal water content should be between 40 and 60%, balancing water and air-filled pore space to ensure adequate moisture for decomposition and airflow for oxygen supply. Excess water can increase the potential for anaerobic decomposition, odour, and runoff.

By implementing preventative measures such as proper site design, operations, and runoff management, the water pollution threat from composting can be considerably reduced. Proper attention to siting, ingredient mixtures, and compost pile management can help address concerns related to water pollution and ensure that composting remains an environmentally beneficial activity.

Composting can effectively kill pathogens in manure. The heat and microbial competition during the composting process can inactivate human pathogens found in animal waste feedstocks. Reasonably high composting temperatures of 130-140°F (54-60°C) maintained for several days can kill most pathogens, including E. coli and Salmonella. However, some strains, such as E. coli O157:H7, require temperatures above 160°F (71°C) for reliable inactivation.

The risk of pathogenic contamination can be further minimized by understanding the mechanisms of pathogen survival during composting and implementing measures to reduce pathogen populations. Interactions with indigenous microorganisms, carbon:nitrogen ratios, and temperature changes all influence pathogen survival, growth, and persistence in finished compost. By optimizing these factors, composting can effectively kill pathogens in manure and reduce the risk of contamination in the cultivation of fruits and vegetables.

Composting can reduce the impact of rainfall, minimising washouts

Composting has long been viewed as an environmentally beneficial activity. It is an exceptional water retainer that promotes soil health and reduces the need for fertilizers. Composting can also reduce the impact of rainfall, minimising washouts.

Compost has a coarse structure that effectively diverts the impact of rainfall, reducing the risk of washouts. It also has a high capacity to hold water – up to 27,000 gallons per acre-foot for every 1% of organic matter that is added to the soil. This abundant water retention capability addresses flooding and runoff concerns, while simultaneously reducing erosion.

Compost achieves this through several mechanisms:

• Increasing Water Infiltration: Compost enhances water infiltration into the soil surface, helping to replenish groundwater levels and prevent surface runoff.
• Reducing Runoff and Soil Particle Transport: Compost acts as a natural barrier, reducing the speed and volume of runoff, which in turn minimises the transport of soil particles and pollutants downstream.
• Promoting Plant Growth and Soil Cover: Compost provides essential nutrients to support plant growth, ensuring better soil cover, which stabilises slopes and prevents erosion.
• Enhancing Soil Structure: Adding compost to soil alleviates compaction and improves soil structure, enabling better root penetration and higher rates of both water infiltration and drainage.
• Buffering Soil pH: Compost helps maintain an optimal pH level in the soil, fostering ideal conditions for the establishment and growth of vegetation.

There are two primary methods for using compost in erosion control: compost blankets or mats, and compost filter berms. Compost blankets involve applying high-quality compost directly to areas at risk of erosion, such as construction sites, stream banks, and other disturbed or excavated land areas. The primary purpose of a compost blanket is to protect the soil surface until vegetation is established. Compost filter berms, on the other hand, are contoured runoff and erosion filtration structures suitable for steeper slopes with high erosive potential. These berms allow runoff water to flow while filtering out sediment and pollutants, and their ability to slow down the flow allows soil particles to settle out, further reducing erosion.

Composting is a practical option for treating drier manures and is generally not suitable for slurry and liquid manures. It is important to note that while composting has many benefits, there are some potential drawbacks if not managed properly. For example, compost facilities should consider the site selection, ingredient mixtures, and compost pile management to ensure water quality protection.

Compost can help maintain optimal soil pH levels

Composting has long been viewed as an environmentally beneficial activity. However, compost facilities must consider and mitigate any adverse environmental impacts to maintain their positive reputation. While compost can be beneficial, it can also cause pollution.

How Compost Can Help Maintain Optimal Soil pH Levels

The pH of compost is worth measuring because it can be used to follow the process of decomposition. The pH of compost will vary as it decays, and the majority of plants thrive in a neutral pH of around 7. However, some plants prefer a more acidic or alkaline environment. Therefore, compost can be modified to counterbalance and amend the soil.

The decomposition of organic matter in a compost pile is mostly achieved by microorganisms such as bacteria and fungi. The bacteria and fungi that are so important to this process are most efficient at neutral pH levels of between 6 and 7. A good mix of varied materials and a well-aerated compost bin will naturally produce neutral pH compost.

The final pH of the compost depends on the type of material in the bin. Certain organic substances in larger quantities can affect the acidity or alkalinity of the finished compost. For example, large quantities of pine needles or oak leaves will probably lower the compost's pH to a slightly acidic level. This type of compost is called ericaceous compost, which is suitable for acid-loving plants.

If the compost is too acidic, it can be neutralized by exposing it to air for a month or so. Turning or aerating the compost to improve air circulation and foster aerobic bacteria is the best way to reduce acidity. Also, be sure that there is plenty of "brown" material in the compost. Some people say that adding wood ash to compost will aid in neutralizing it.

If the compost is too alkaline, it can be lowered by adding more acidic materials, such as pine needles or oak leaves, to the compost as it breaks down. However, compost already has the quality of balancing pH values within the soil as needed, so amending the pH of compost is not generally necessary.

Frequently asked questions