Breathing Easy: Do Filters Really Block Pollution?

Light pollution filters can be a useful tool for photographers, especially those interested in astrophotography. These filters block specific wavelengths of light, cutting out the yellow and orange parts of the spectrum between 575nm and 600nm, which are the colours of sodium vapour lights used in most big cities. They can also increase the overall contrast of an image and enhance red and magenta tones.

However, light pollution filters are of limited use when it comes to visual astronomy. They are most effective at filtering out wavelengths of certain types of lighting, such as mercury and sodium lights, but with the shift to LED lighting, which emits light over the entire spectrum, light pollution filters have become less effective. For emission nebulae, a good narrow-band filter can still be useful for increasing contrast.

Overall, while light pollution filters can be beneficial for photographers, their effectiveness for visual astronomy is limited, especially in light-polluted areas.

Light pollution filters can be used in photography to reduce the yellow/orange tint caused by light pollution

Light pollution filters are designed to suppress the emissions generated by artificial lighting, such as street lamps, and can be placed in front of a lens to reduce the yellow/green colour caused by city lights. This results in images with more clarity, more natural colours, and improved contrast.

There are two main types of light pollution filters: broadband filters and multi-narrowband filters. Broadband filters are used to capture more natural-looking images of objects in the night sky, while multi-narrowband filters ignore most wavelengths of light in the visible spectrum, allowing narrow bandpasses of light in key areas to pass through. Broadband filters are ideal for capturing galaxies, reflection nebulae, dark nebulae, and natural star colours, while narrowband filters are best used on emission nebulae and supernova remnants.

When choosing a light pollution filter, it is important to consider the type of camera being used, as well as the specific sources of light pollution in the area. For example, if you are shooting with a stock DSLR camera, a multi-narrowband filter may not be as effective due to its focus on the hydrogen-alpha wavelength. Additionally, the effectiveness of a light pollution filter can depend on the level of light pollution in the area, with some filters being more suitable for moderate light pollution, while others are designed for heavy light pollution.

• Optolong L-eXtreme: A dual-band filter that isolates two important wavelengths of light emitted by many deep-sky objects, resulting in images with better contrast.
• K&F Concept Natural Night Light Pollution Filter: Targets the yellow and orange light of city streets, with a slim but strong aluminium alloy frame.
• Hoya Starscape Light Pollution Cut Filter: Reduces yellow and green colour casts, improving overall contrast and natural colour.
• Irix Edge Light Pollution Filter: Reduces the yellowish haze given off by artificial lighting, resulting in clearer and cleaner images with better contrast.
• Kase Wolverine Neutral Night Light Pollution Filter: Reduces the orange glow from streetlights, enhancing the natural reddish light from nebulae.
• Haida NanoPro MC Clear-Night Light Pollution Filter: Cuts out the yellowish glow often seen in nighttime cityscapes, resulting in images with natural colours.

Light pollution filters are most effective in remote locations with dark skies

Light pollution filters work by blocking specific wavelengths of light associated with artificial light sources, such as street lamps. They are designed to cut out the yellow and orange parts of the spectrum, typically emitted by sodium vapor lights commonly used in cities. By using a light pollution filter, the yellow/orange tint caused by light pollution can be reduced or eliminated from photographs. Additionally, these filters can enhance the overall contrast of an image and boost red and magenta tones.

However, it is important to note that light pollution filters also reduce overall light transmission, requiring some exposure compensation during shooting or post-processing. The quality of the filter will determine the extent of light reduction, with higher-quality filters blocking less light. Lower-quality filters may also introduce unwanted tints or color casts to the image, although this can usually be corrected in post-processing.

While light pollution filters can be a helpful tool for astrophotographers, they are most effective in remote locations with dark skies. In these settings, light pollution filters can enhance the contrast and colors of astrophotography images, providing a more impressive result. Thus, for those seeking to capture the true beauty of the night sky, venturing to a remote location with minimal light pollution is ideal.

Light pollution filters are becoming less effective due to the increasing prevalence of LED lighting

In the past, light pollution filters were designed to block the specific wavelengths of light emitted by low-pressure sodium street lights, which produced an orange hue. However, with the shift to LED lighting, the concept of light pollution filters has become obsolete. LED lighting emits light across the visible spectrum, making it difficult for light pollution filters to block light pollution without also removing the light from celestial objects, defeating the purpose of the filter.

While light pollution filters may still provide some benefit in areas with less light pollution or in conjunction with other filters, such as nebula filters, their overall effectiveness has decreased due to the increasing use of LED lighting. This has resulted in a growing immunity to light pollution filters in light-polluted areas.

The ineffectiveness of light pollution filters with LED lighting has been noted by astronomers and astrophotographers, who have observed that the filters no longer provide the same level of contrast and detail when viewing celestial objects. The broad spectrum of LED lighting means that light pollution filters are unable to selectively block light pollution while preserving the light from celestial objects.

To address this issue, some have suggested the use of more aggressive O-III filters, which block most wavelengths of light except for narrow bandpasses in key areas. Others have proposed government regulation to control light trespass and temperature, or the use of lower color temperature LED lights, which emit a warmer, less glaring light. Additionally, finding a suitable location away from light pollution or joining a club with access to darker skies can help mitigate the effects of light pollution.

Light pollution is harmful to human health and the ecosystem

Light pollution is the human-made alteration of outdoor light levels from those occurring naturally. It has harmful effects on both human health and the ecosystem.

Harmful Effects on the Ecosystem

Light pollution radically alters the nighttime environment for nocturnal animals by turning night into day. It can also impact wetland habitats that are home to amphibians such as frogs and toads, whose nocturnal croaking is part of the breeding ritual. Artificial lights disrupt this nocturnal activity, interfering with reproduction and reducing populations.

Sea turtles, for example, lay their eggs on beaches, with females returning for decades to the beaches where they were born to nest. When these beaches are brightly lit at night, females may be discouraged from nesting in them. Newly hatched turtles can also become disoriented and navigate toward the artificial light source, never finding the sea.

Artificial lights can also lead birds that migrate or hunt at night astray, causing them to wander off course and toward dangerous city landscapes. Every year, millions of birds die colliding with needlessly illuminated buildings and towers.

Harmful Effects on Human Health

The 24-hour day/night cycle, known as the circadian clock, affects physiological processes in almost all organisms, including humans. Disruption of the circadian clock is linked to several medical disorders in humans, including depression, insomnia, cardiovascular disease, and cancer.

Research has shown that exposure to artificial light at night is associated with an increased risk of obesity, depression, sleep disorders, diabetes, and breast cancer. Circadian rhythm and melatonin suppression are two ways in which artificial light at night can negatively impact human health.

Circadian rhythm, or our biological clock, is largely influenced by photoreceptors in the eye that are more sensitive to blue wavelengths of light. It is important for humans to experience outdoor lighting during the day and minimize the amount of light entering their eyes at night to maintain a good circadian cycle.

Nighttime exposure to artificial light also suppresses melatonin production, which is needed to keep us healthy. Melatonin has antioxidant properties, induces sleep, boosts the immune system, lowers cholesterol, and helps the functioning of the thyroid, pancreas, ovaries, testes, and adrenal glands.

Filters and Light Pollution

Light pollution filters can be used to reduce the amount of artificial light entering the eye at night. These filters can be placed on camera lenses or clipped into the camera body. They are designed to block specific bandpass lines of the visible spectrum, allowing the important colours and light emitted by astrophotography subjects to reach the camera sensor without the nasty brown glow of a washed-out sky.

Light pollution filters can be used during the daytime to enhance contrast and increase saturation in red and magenta tones

Light pollution filters are a great tool for photographers, especially those interested in astrophotography. They block specific wavelengths of light in the visible spectrum, usually the yellow and orange parts of the spectrum between 575nm and 600nm, which are associated with artificial light sources such as street lamps. This helps to reduce the light pollution levels in photographs.

Light pollution filters can also be used during the daytime to enhance contrast and increase saturation in red and magenta tones. This can be particularly useful for sunset shots or when photographing fall colors on cloudy days. The filter can help to target specific colours for enhanced saturation while leaving blue and green colours unchanged.

The Hoya Starscape Light Pollution Filter, for example, has a base filter factor (light loss) of 1/2 stop but can result in a 1-2 stop difference in exposure depending on the light source and atmospheric haze.

It's important to note that light pollution filters are most effective in dark skies and remote locations. While they can be used in light-polluted areas, capturing the Milky Way or the Orion Nebula from the centre of a big city is still challenging even with a light pollution filter.

Frequently asked questions