Delhi's Pollution: Do Masks Really Work?

As India's capital, Delhi, battles hazardous air pollution, the effectiveness of masks to protect against pollution is a pressing question. In 2019, around 1.67 million deaths in India were attributed to air pollution, accounting for 17.8% of total deaths. While masks are not a foolproof solution, doctors have urged residents to wear them to shield against harmful pollutants. The type of mask is crucial, with cloth and surgical masks deemed ineffective against small particles that can enter the lungs and bloodstream. N95 respirators are widely recommended as they filter at least 95% of airborne particles, but fit is also essential for optimal protection.

Cloth masks are ineffective against small PM particles and harmful gases

As air pollution in Delhi continues to worsen, doctors have urged residents to wear masks to protect themselves from the harmful effects of air pollutants. However, the effectiveness of masks in shielding against these pollutants has been called into question, especially when it comes to cloth masks.

Cloth masks have been found to be ineffective in protecting against small PM particles and harmful gases present in Delhi's air pollution. While they may offer some barrier against larger particles such as sawdust, their filtration capabilities are limited when it comes to smaller, more dangerous pollutants. The problem is that these small particles can penetrate deep into the respiratory system and even enter the bloodstream, leading to serious health issues.

The ineffectiveness of cloth masks against small PM particles is supported by research. Studies have shown that cloth masks have lower filtration efficiencies when dealing with particles in the sub-micrometer range, which includes wildfire smoke and human-emitted bronchial particles. This is in contrast to larger particle types, such as pollen grains and some fungal spores, where cloth masks can achieve better collection efficiency.

Additionally, cloth masks do not provide adequate protection against harmful gases present in Delhi's air pollution. Gases like nitrogen dioxide, which has been linked to an increase in hospital visits, cannot be prevented by wearing a cloth mask. This is a significant concern as exposure to these gases can have detrimental health effects.

The limitations of cloth masks have led experts to recommend alternative options for protection against Delhi's air pollution. N95 respirators, for example, are designed to filter out 95% of harmful particulate matter, including small PM particles. Surgical masks, while not as effective as N95s, can still offer better protection than cloth masks, especially if they have a proper fit and a tight seal against the face.

In conclusion, while masks can provide some level of protection against Delhi's air pollution, cloth masks fall short when it comes to shielding against small PM particles and harmful gases. To effectively reduce exposure to these pollutants, it is advisable to opt for more specialized masks, such as N95 respirators or, at the very least, ensure that surgical masks are properly fitted to maximize their filtration capabilities.

Respirators are the best defence against air pollution

As air pollution in Delhi continues to worsen, with the Air Quality Index (AQI) reaching 488—seven to eight times above the government-prescribed safe limit—respirators are the best defence against the harmful effects of air pollution.

While the habit of wearing masks has increased due to the pandemic, cloth and surgical masks are ineffective against small pollution particles that can enter deep into the lungs and bloodstream. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), while masks do not offer complete protection, they can be useful in certain circumstances, such as during prolonged commuting and outdoor activities when air quality is hazardous.

To effectively protect against pollutants, experts recommend using respirators like the N95 mask, which can filter out at least 95% of airborne particles. Other types of respirators include the N99, N100, R95, P95, P99, and P100, which offer varying levels of filtration efficiency. These respirators are designed to seal securely to the face, preventing particles from entering and providing protection against small aerosols and pollutants.

The 3M 8511 N95 respirator, for example, is widely available and comfortable for long-term wear, with sturdier straps and an exhalation valve that keeps the face cool. For those seeking a reusable option, the 3M 6502QL/49489 Rugged Comfort respirator is a comfortable half-facepiece model that can be fitted with filters to protect against paint fumes, volatile gases, dust, and smoke.

As air pollution in Delhi poses a significant public health threat, with 1.67 million deaths attributed to air pollution in India in 2019, respirators offer a critical defence against the harmful impacts of air pollution.

N95 masks are the most widely used and popular choice

As air pollution in Delhi continues to worsen, doctors have urged residents to wear masks to protect themselves from the harmful effects of air pollution. Masks have become a winter staple in the city, with the pandemic having already made the practice of wearing masks more common.

Pharmacists in Delhi have reported that customers are mostly looking to buy N95 masks to get extra protection from harmful particles in the air. Air pollution experts have also recommended the use of N95 masks when outside to minimise the impact of severe pollution levels. Dr Arvind Kumar, a chest surgeon from Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, notes that while it is impossible and impractical to wear N95 masks at all times, they do offer some protection when worn properly with no leaks from the sides.

The World Health Organization (WHO) notes that while masks do not offer foolproof protection, they can be useful in certain circumstances, such as during prolonged commuting and outdoor activities in situations of hazardous air quality. It is important to note that no mask will be able to prevent the inhalation of gaseous pollutants like nitrogen dioxide, and masks are generally not effective when worn only outdoors, as people spend a majority of their time indoors where they are exposed to indoor air pollutants.

Masks don't protect against chemicals, gases, and vapours

As air pollution continues to be a yearly concern in Delhi, India, many residents have turned to masks to protect themselves from the harmful effects of air pollution. While masks can offer some protection, it is important to note that they do not provide complete protection against all pollutants. Specifically, masks are not effective against chemicals, gases, and vapours.

The effectiveness of a mask depends on its type and the way it is worn. Basic dust masks, for example, are designed to reduce exposure to solid particles like dirt, silica, and pollen. They are not approved by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and do not offer protection against hazardous dust, gases, or vapours. Similarly, cloth and surgical masks, which have become common due to the COVID-19 pandemic, are ineffective against small pollution particles that can enter the lungs and bloodstream.

To protect against chemicals, gases, and vapours, specialised respirator masks with appropriate filters are required. Respirators are a type of personal protective equipment (PPE) that removes contaminants from the air using cartridges, filters, or canisters. When choosing a respirator, it is important to consider the specific contaminants you need protection from, as different filters are designed for different purposes. For example, green filters protect against ammonia gases, while black filters are meant for organic vapours like solvents in paint and gasoline.

It is worth noting that even with the right respirator and filters, masks may not provide complete protection against all chemicals, gases, and vapours. Some gaseous pollutants, such as nitrogen dioxide, are extremely difficult to filter out, and no mask can completely prevent their inhalation. Additionally, the effectiveness of masks depends on proper usage, including ensuring a tight facial fit to prevent air leakage.

While masks may not offer comprehensive protection against chemicals, gases, and vapours, they can still provide some level of defence against particulate matter and liquid contaminants. N95 respirators, for instance, are designed to filter at least 95% of airborne particles and are more effective than cloth or surgical masks. However, it is important to follow guidelines for proper usage and replacement to ensure maximum protection.

Masks with a snug fit are more effective

As air pollution worsens in Delhi, doctors are urging people to wear masks when going outside. Masks can help reduce the number of deaths attributed to air pollution, which accounted for 17.8% of total deaths in India in 2019.

While masks do not offer foolproof protection, they can help. The World Health Organization (WHO) advises that masks "are generally not regarded as a suitable measure for the protection of health but may be indicated in certain special circumstances, for example, during prolonged commuting and outdoor activities in situations of hazardous air quality".

The type of mask chosen is very important. Surgical and cloth masks should be avoided as they do not offer protection against pollutants. Experts note that while these masks may trap larger air pollutants such as sawdust, they don't offer the same level of filtration as N95 respirators.

To ensure maximum protection, masks must fit snugly over the nose and mouth to stop polluted air from leaking in. Most commercially available masks do not provide adequate protection against particulate matter and black carbon due to poor facial fit. Masks with a snug fit are therefore more effective.

NIOSH-certified masks are recommended, as well as masks with HEPA filters. The OxiClear N99 Anti-Pollution Face Mask is one example of an effective mask. It features activated carbon filters and a detachable headband.

Frequently asked questions