Are Chinese Fish Safe To Eat?

China's shores are polluted due to a combination of industrial waste, agricultural runoff, and sewage, which have severe impacts on the country's water resources and marine life. China is the world's largest producer and exporter of farmed fish, with fish farms located along its coastline. The country's aquaculture practices have led to environmental pollution and ecological problems, including the degradation of coastal mangroves and the increase in red tides. While China has taken steps to address pollution and promote sustainable fish farming, the environmental impacts of its aquaculture industry remain a concern for scientists. The pollution in China's waters has also affected the quality of the fish, with studies finding contaminants such as mercury and organic chemicals in seafood samples.

Pollution from fish farms

China is the world's largest producer and processor of aquatic products, with fish farms all along its coastline. Previously dominant and cruder forms of fish farming have left a legacy of environmental pollution and ecological problems in the country's near-shore waters. Direct discharge of fish farm effluents, faecal matter, and the uncontrolled use of antibiotics have all contributed to the degradation of coastal mangroves and the increasing occurrence of red tides.

In 2016, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs required local authorities to delineate areas where aquaculture was prohibited, restricted, or permitted by law, bringing structure to aquaculture distribution. As a result, China removed 300,000 near-shore net pens and 2.4 million mu (160,000 hectares) of fish farms in 2018 alone. Guangdong, China's leading fisheries province, has demonstrated its commitment to curtailing near-shore aquaculture and shifting towards more environmentally friendly development further offshore.

Aquaculture is a resource-intensive industry, and unsustainable practices can pollute the water in which the fish are raised. Excess fish feed, along with fish waste, are often left to decompose in riverine and coastal environments, leading to eutrophication. Fish feed is frequently doused with antibiotics to prevent disease in overstocked farms.

To address these issues, China's 13FYP on fisheries emphasizes the need for sustainable fish farming. It mandates the reduction of inland fisheries while encouraging offshore marine farming to minimize pollution. Since October 2017, 30 illegal aquaculture sites have been closed and removed from the Dongting Lake area in Hunan Province, a key region for freshwater crab and fish production.

While China's efforts to promote sustainable aquaculture are positive, the country's fishing vessels that engage in illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing continue to destroy marine ecosystems. China is also the world's largest source of plastic pollution, which further devastates fish and ocean life. As the world's largest producer and exporter of farmed fish, China's aquaculture practices have a significant impact on the environment and contribute to the pollution of its shores.

Plastic pollution

China is the world's largest producer, consumer, and exporter of plastics, with plastic pollution starkly evident in the country. China's fishing practices have been criticized for destroying marine ecosystems, and the country is also the largest source of mismanaged plastic waste and the biggest offender of ocean plastic pollution.

The Yangtze River, the longest river in Asia and the third-longest in the world, has been identified as one of the biggest sources of global plastic pollution. The river is responsible for over half of all marine plastic pollution, according to reports. Plastic pollution in China is attributed to the country's high consumption of single-use plastics, which are made from fossil fuels, and the inadequate management of plastic waste. This has led to the accumulation of plastic in the marine environment, causing harm to marine life through ingestion, entanglement, and increasing the risk of invasive species.

China's aquaculture practices have also contributed to the pollution of near-shore waters. Previously, dominant and cruder forms of fish farming have left a legacy of environmental pollution. Direct discharge of farm effluents, accumulations of faecal matter, and the uncontrolled use of antibiotics have degraded coastal mangroves and increased the occurrence of red tides. While China is taking steps towards more sustainable fish farming practices, such as expanding aquaculture in deeper waters, the environmental impacts of near-shore aquaculture remain a concern.

To combat plastic pollution, Sanya, a city in Hainan Province, has become the first in China to join the WWF Plastic Smart Cities Initiative, pledging to eliminate plastic pollution by 2030. Sanya is also participating in the 'No Plastic Ocean Initiative' and is developing bilateral projects with Norway to reduce plastic and microplastic pollution. Researchers in China are also working on producing plastics that break down when exposed to seawater to tackle marine plastic pollution.

Illegal fishing

China's shores have been affected by pollution from fish farms, with waste and antibiotics contributing to the degradation of coastal mangroves and the increase in red tides. China is also the world's largest producer and processor of aquatic products, with fish farms all along its coastline.

China's fishing industry has been accused of illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing, which is destroying marine ecosystems. China's distant water fishing fleet has nearly doubled in size over the last decade and is now one of the largest in the world. Chinese fishing vessels often turn off their transponders to hide their presence from authorities and fish in other nations' exclusive economic zones without consent. This has led to increased tensions with neighbouring countries, such as North Korea, Japan, and South Korea.

An investigation by NBC News revealed that China sent nearly 800 industrial boats to fish illegally in North Korean waters in 2019, violating UN sanctions. Chinese vessels are also known for their aggressive tactics, including ramming competitors or foreign patrol vessels.

China's fishing practices have had a significant impact on the environment and the global economy. The country's fishing fleets have contributed to the decline of fishing stocks and endangered the livelihoods of local fishing communities in developing nations. China's own data indicates that its distant water fishing fleet has expanded rapidly, with an estimated 12,000 to 17,000 vessels as of 2017-2018.

To address these issues, there have been crackdowns on polluting fish farms, and China's 13FYP emphasizes the need for sustainable fish farming. Since October 2017, 30 illegal aquaculture sites have been closed in Hunan Province. Additionally, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs has delineated areas where aquaculture is prohibited or restricted by law.

Water pollution

China's extraordinary economic growth, industrialization, and urbanization, coupled with inadequate investment in basic water supply and treatment infrastructure, have resulted in widespread water pollution. China's fishing vessels that engage in illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing practices also destroy marine ecosystems.

China is the world's largest producer and processor of aquatic products, with fish farms all along its coastline. Previously dominant and cruder forms of fish farming have left a legacy of environmental pollution and ecological problems in the country's near-shore waters. The direct discharge of fish farm effluents, accumulations of faecal matter, and the uncontrolled use of antibiotics have all contributed to the degradation of coastal mangroves and the increasing occurrence of red tides.

To address these issues, the Chinese government has taken several measures. In 2016, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs required local authorities to delineate areas where aquaculture was prohibited, restricted, or permitted by law, bringing structure to aquaculture distribution. Since then, China has removed hundreds of thousands of near-shore net pens and fish farms. Guangdong, the leading fisheries province, has mandated a shift from near-shore aquaculture to more environmentally friendly offshore development.

Additionally, the Chinese government proposed the Total Amount of Pollutants Control Plan in 2000, taking COD as one of the control indexes of 12 major pollutants. The Law of the People's Republic of China on the Prevention and Control of Water Pollution, enacted in 2008, tightened the regulation of water environmental protection. In 2012, ecological civilization was elevated to a national strategy, and discharge reduction targets for TP, COD, and NH3-N were set during the 13th 5-Year Comprehensive Work Plan from 2016 to 2020.

Despite these efforts, water pollution remains a significant issue in China, impacting not only its own environment but also that of its neighboring countries. The export of this problem has incited considerable international concern.

China's efforts to clean its waters

China's water resources have long been a defining characteristic of its history. In recent times, the country has been grappling with severe water pollution, which has had a detrimental impact on its ecology and economy. China's leadership has historically prioritised economic growth over environmental health, leading to dangerous levels of water pollution and poor soil health. However, in the face of ubiquitous public protests and growing international concern, China has initiated a massive clean-up campaign to heal its polluted waters and restore the health of its lakes and rivers.

China's water pollution crisis has far-reaching consequences, affecting not only its vast population but also the global community. The country's water resources are vital to its economic and ecological health, and the contamination of these resources has resulted in a loss of wealth and severe ecological problems. China's water pollution is driven by a multitude of factors, including industrial waste, agricultural runoff, and the overreliance on near-shore aquaculture, which has left a legacy of environmental pollution in the country's coastal waters.

Recognising the urgency of the situation, China has embarked on a nationwide crackdown on water pollution. This campaign has yielded some success, with cleaner rivers and lakes in certain regions. The government has implemented measures such as removing near-shore net pens and fish farms, prohibiting aquaculture in specific areas, and encouraging the expansion of offshore marine farming to minimise pollution. These steps towards green development have eased the strain on near-shore ecologies and provided a more sustainable future for the fishing industry.

In addition to these efforts, China is also addressing the issue of drinking water safety. Despite improvements, a significant proportion of China's water sources remain non-compliant with regulations. To tackle this, there have been suggestions to improve public awareness of environmental health and drinking water safety, conduct national surveys, and establish platforms for risk communication and information exchange. By taking these steps, China aims to enhance the evaluation of environmental health risks and reduce public panic surrounding water-borne diseases and water scarcity issues.

Frequently asked questions