Cows: Climate Change's Biggest Culprit?

Cows and livestock are a major source of greenhouse gas emissions, with livestock responsible for 18% of greenhouse gases, more than all transport combined. Cows produce methane, a greenhouse gas with 23 times the negative impact of carbon dioxide, through flatulence and manure. They also require large amounts of water and are a major driver of deforestation, with grazing land and farmland responsible for the clearing of tropical forests and rainforests. However, livestock also provide a livelihood for 1 billion people and thrive on feed that is not suitable for humans. While cows are a significant contributor to global warming, there are other factors and sources of emissions that must also be considered.

Cows emit methane, a greenhouse gas 23 times more harmful than CO2

Cows are a significant contributor to global warming. Livestock, including cows, are responsible for 18% of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming, which is more than all transport forms combined. Cows emit methane, a greenhouse gas 23 times more harmful than CO2. The methane emitted by cows is produced by bacteria in their stomachs, which aids in digestion. The bacteria cause cows to regurgitate their food and re-chew it, and the methane is released through flatulence.

The amount of methane expelled by the average dairy cow is estimated to be between 100 and 200 liters per day, with some estimates reaching 500 liters per day. This amount is comparable to the pollution produced by a car in a day. With millions of ruminants in Britain alone, including 10 million cows, efforts are being made to curb methane emissions. One suggestion is to add garlic to cow feed, as it has been shown to cut cow flatulence in half by attacking methane-producing microbes in their stomachs.

The impact of agriculture on the environment is complex, and the gases produced, primarily methane and nitrous oxide, have a much higher warming potential than carbon dioxide but dissipate more quickly. The production of meat generates more greenhouse gases than the transportation sector, and livestock produce more than 100 polluting gases, including ammonia, a leading cause of acid rain.

In addition to the direct emissions of methane by cows, the clearing of tropical forests and rainforests to create grazing land further contributes to carbon dioxide emissions. The burning of forests to make room for grazing land releases large amounts of carbon absorbed by these forests. This land clearance is responsible for an extra 2.8 billion metric tons of CO2 emissions annually.

While cows are a significant contributor to global warming, it is important to consider the broader context of meat production and agriculture. Meat provides a nutrient-dense food source, and ruminant animals can thrive on feed unsuitable for humans. Additionally, raising livestock offers a livelihood for many people, especially small-scale farmers in developing nations.

Livestock is responsible for 18% of greenhouse gases, more than all transport combined

The greenhouse gases emitted by livestock include methane and nitrous oxide, which have a much higher global warming potential than carbon dioxide. Methane, in particular, is estimated to be 20-28 times more potent than carbon dioxide in terms of its heat-trapping ability. While carbon dioxide is the most common greenhouse gas, methane emitted by livestock accounts for a significant portion of emissions.

Livestock produce methane through a process called enteric fermentation, which occurs during digestion in the stomachs of ruminants, such as cows, buffalo, and sheep. This methane is released when they burp or belch. Additionally, livestock manure also emits methane and nitrous oxide, further contributing to greenhouse gas emissions.

The impact of livestock on the environment extends beyond methane and nitrous oxide emissions. The production of feed for livestock involves the use of fertilizers, which emit carbon dioxide during manufacturing. Clearing vegetation and deforestation for grazing land and cropland result in the release of stored carbon dioxide. The livestock sector's demand for natural resources, such as water, and its contribution to deforestation and land-use change, have significant environmental consequences.

To address the environmental impact of the livestock sector, mitigation strategies are necessary. These strategies should aim to reduce emission intensity and consider the complex interactions within livestock production systems. Population growth, urbanization, and income rise in developing countries are driving the increased demand for livestock products, making the implementation of effective mitigation measures crucial.

Cows produce ammonia, a leading cause of acid rain

Livestock, including cows, are responsible for 18% of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming, which is more than all transport emissions combined. Cows and other ruminants emit methane, a greenhouse gas that is produced by bacteria in their digestive systems. Livestock also produces more than 100 other polluting gases, including more than two-thirds of the world's ammonia emissions.

Ammonia is a nitrogen compound that contributes to the greenhouse gas nitrous oxide and fine airborne particles that threaten human health. It also harms the environment by acidifying soil and adding nitrogen to lakes, which boosts plant growth at the expense of animal life.

Ammonia emissions result from excess protein—which contains nitrogen—in livestock feed. Unused nitrogen is excreted in urine as urea, which a bacterial enzyme called urease then turns into ammonia. Cows excrete up to 90% of the nitrogen they eat, while growing pigs excrete about 70%. However, balanced diets that supply adequate essential amino acids without a protein overload can cut nitrogen excretion by up to 40%.

Ammonia emissions are also affected by factors such as animal diets, housing, and manure management. In barns with slatted or solid floors, ammonia emissions were much lower (about 40 and 48 g per cow per day, respectively) than in open lots (about 165 g per cow per day). This is because urine and feces are typically removed regularly from barns, while in open lots, urine streams into the soil, which contains the enzyme urease that rapidly produces ammonia.

To reduce ammonia emissions, proper management of animal diet, housing, manure storage, and land application is necessary. For example, impermeable covers made of wood, fiberglass, or cement can reduce ammonia emissions by 80-95%. Filling large storage tanks from the bottom allows a manure crust to form, which also reduces ammonia loss. Acidification of manure with additives such as phosphoric acid, hydrogen sulfide, and sulfuric acid will reduce volatility potential because the microbes that convert more complex forms of nitrogen to ammonia prefer a basic pH.

Ranching is the primary driver of deforestation

Livestock are responsible for 18% of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming, with two-thirds of those gases directly emitted by ruminants like cows. Cattle ranching is a major driver of deforestation, with overgrazing turning a fifth of all pastures and ranges into deserts.

Brazil's expansion of beef production accounts for a quarter of tropical deforestation, with 72% of deforestation in Brazil driven by cattle ranching. In other parts of Latin America, such as Argentina and Paraguay, cattle ranching accounted for 11% of deforestation. Thus, most deforestation for beef occurs in Latin America, with another 4% happening in Africa.

In Brazil, the National Institute for Colonisation and Agrarian Reform (INCRA) divided the Amazon territory in the 1980s into small lots, intending to attract farmers and boost smaller-scale farms. However, this led to the profitable expansion of cattle ranching in the Amazon, as land was cheaper and more accessible, even if it was illegal. This expansion has affected small farmers, ranchers, and indigenous people whose territories are protected by law.

Cattle laundering is a practice where land grabbers invade conservation areas, deforest the land, and shuttle cattle to legalised land before sale or to evade inspection. This practice further perpetuates the cycle of deforestation for cattle ranching.

Overall, ranching is a primary driver of deforestation, particularly in Latin America, with Brazil being the single country where large forest areas are lost due to cattle ranching.

Cows require large amounts of water: 990 litres to produce 1 litre of milk

Livestock, including cows, are responsible for 18% of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming, which is more than all forms of transport combined. They emit over one-third of methane, a gas that warms the world 20 times faster than carbon dioxide. Moreover, they produce more than 100 other polluting gases, including ammonia, which is one of the main causes of acid rain.

Cows also require large amounts of water. Dairy farming at current levels of intensity is unsustainable. A study based on the global milk supply conducted in 2018 demonstrated that 628 litres of water are required to produce one litre of cow's milk. Another source claims that it takes 990 litres of water to produce one litre of milk. This is because cows in early lactation (less than 100 days in milk) will produce 40 litres of milk per day and eat 50 kg of feed, which averages 50% water and 50% dry matter.

Water scarcity is a critical global issue, driven by shortages and pollution. Dairy farming in Canterbury, New Zealand, for example, has led to significant pollution of the region's groundwater, which is used for drinking water. The use of synthetic nitrogen fertilizer has increased nitrate levels and water pollution problems. This disruption of the nitrogen cycle threatens human sustainability through its impacts on the climate and local fresh water.

To maintain the current level of milk production in Canterbury and have healthy water, the region would need either 12 times more rainfall or a 12-fold reduction in cows.

Frequently asked questions